Cruising fuel use example

pdecat

Well-known member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
842
Messages
11,588
Continuing the recent discussion on fuel economy I though folks might be interested in the fuel data from a recent 300 NMi trip.

On the outbound leg of approximately 200Nmi I ran at 8.5Kts, somewhat above many trawler speeds and with some bow rise and wake but still not plowing The outbound leg produced about 2NMPG. On about 100 NMi of the return we ran on plane at 17 KTs into some building winds and seas at about .5NMPG.

So for those desiring some economy and considering a “trawler" as their next boat here is some actual data showing operating conditions not a marketing name are what determines fuel use.
At 8.5Kts I was above what I consider my better “trawler range " economy speed of 7.5Kts. The boat is a 38,000# Carver 44' aft cabin with twin Cummins 450s
 
Wow - hull speed consumption was pretty good.

My Harley 43 gets 1.4 nmpg at 8 kts. IF I slow it down to 7 kts I get about 2.1 with crabed gas 502s.
If I get up on plane and run at a conservative 28 mph, I get .90 mpg
Sorry I changed from knots to mpg ... I dont have slow speed stuff in mpg

Cheers
 
Bruce, I generally agree with your argument that you can operate any boat at hull speed and get decent economy, but that still doesn't really reach trawler economy. My boat, which isn't even a real trawler, gets over 3 nmpg. True trawlers do even better.

Of course, just because something is marketed as a trawler doesn't mean that's what it is. I know you've said that in other posts, and I agree. Real trawlers have small (low hp) engines and are hull speed only.
 
I agree some, even many, will do better, my last sailboat got better than 6MPG. All boats are a compromise. I get more like 2.5 to 3NMPG at 7 kts but chose to do 8.5KTs on this trip. My low speed range becomes 700++ miles, not bad for a 38,000# aft cabin planing boat.

My point is that there are a range of fuel use options and a low powered trawler is not the only option between a planing boat and a sailboat for people looking for a larger boat for long term living. People can make informed decisions and know in advance that they have the option to get home fast with an 80Mi gulf run as we did last week while a friend on a true trawler did not have that option and will be dealing with cold and windy trip.

Funny thing is that an issue of Passagmaker I read at a marina had several articles on faster cruising so even they acknowledge that not everyone wants to be forced to go slow all the time. I sure like the option.
 
Bruce,

Good post! A great way to look at performance and economy together is an overlay plot of speed and MPG vs rpm on a single plot. It makes it easy to see where, if you have a planing hull, you achieve optimum efficiency at higher speed as well as the range to avoid where efficiency goes in the vacu flush.
 
Extended low RPM running on engines (gas or diesel) that are designed to run at higher RPM's is not good. You need to run them once in a while at cruise RPM for more than a couple of minutes.

Trawlers are running at hull speed with the engine at it's desired RPM -and can do so for hours and hours on end. No so for 'non trawlers'.
 
two rocks: please show us data from any engine maker to support this myth.
 
Basic Principle #3: Diesel engines are a lousy choice for people who don't use their boats much, or who frequently make only short jaunts. High speed diesel engines should not be run at low speeds for either long or short periods, and then shut down. The problem here is that diesels build up carbon in the cylinders at low speeds; they need to be run long and hard to burn out that carbon after slow speed running. If not, then carbon builds up in the ring grooves of the pistons and will eventually cause the rings to stick. When that happens severe, even catastrophic engine damage will result. High speed marine diesels (2000 RPM and over) are not made for idling around.

http://www.yachtsurvey.com/GasNdiesel.htm

don't have the rest of the library handy for referece
 
Pascoe has opinions many of which are questionable but again I ask for any makers warning about not running their product too easy. You won’t find it though they are very careful to state high load conditions and cautions to avoid damage.
 
what if only one manufacturer made such a statement? Do you think they would sell more engines that way? Why are they in business again?

Oh yeah, to sell engines.

8th grade marketing.
 
Anything that would harn an engine is specifically ruled out in the operating instructions for warranty purposes. Their operating specifications are very clear and complete, I suggest reading them. if you have no proof then the statment is just another of many diesel myths.
 
Pdecat,
Great info on fuel consumption. The only place to get real data is from owners like yourself in real life conditions.

Thanks for sharing,
Mark
 
quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

Anything that would harn an engine is specifically ruled out in the operating instructions for warranty purposes. Their operating specifications are very clear and complete, I suggest reading them. if you have no proof then the statment is just another of many diesel myths.






I agree, you don't hear about diesels failing from light use (not to be confused with no use). But they do fail from too high of a load. Diesel life is measured by gallons burned -- use it light or use it hard.
 
Bruce
How did the boat handle at the "trawler" speeds?
What was the sea conditions? and how was the ride?
 
Seas were generally calm or 1-2' chop at times while running slow, winds were offshore from calm for most of the first two days to 25+ with one report of 37 once we got into Charlotte Harbor bay. Ride was uneventful with no sudden course changes etc and far less engine and other noise so the admiral reports it being less stressful. Steering at slow speeds is easy and predictable and the autopilot happily attends to those duties.
While running about 3 miles off, even when the offshore wind picked up considerably, steering remained easy in the calm sea. It was easy to move about on the boat for galley and other activities as well.
All in all a very comfortable but slower way to travel but I admit to the desire to speed up after exceeding my personal daily limit of 4-5 hours running. On the windy ride back I didn’t try slowing but expect the waves would have knocked us about more so I kept blasting away, at great expense, into quartering head seas in the interest of getting home as the weather was deteriorating.
While offshore running slow we spent some time reading the paper and books. In the water ways overtaking boats making big wakes are a PITA but that is true at speed as well. Near shore the view was interesting but I prefer to run in depth of 25’ or more so we were a bit too far for any shore detail.
The Admiral is sold and I don’t care as long as I can be docked or anchored by 2-3PM.
 
quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

All in all a very comfortable but slower way to travel but I admit to the desire to speed up after exceeding my personal daily limit of 4-5 hours running. On the windy ride back I didn’t try slowing but expect the waves would have knocked us about more so I kept blasting away, at great expense, into quartering head seas in the interest of getting home as the weather was deteriorating..




this proves your point of having the power & speed when you need it and yet have some economy at the lower speeds -
 
PDECAT, I’ve read your other threads on this topic and I can understand being defensive if you feel that people are implying that you’re damaging your engines by running your boat slowly. I agree that you are not: that at slow speeds, with a little bow rise and a little additional throttle, your diesels will happily push your boat for a very long time and stand a good chance out-living a lot of the components around them.

However, you’ve left out critical distinction. What you’re describing is not a “low idle / no load” condition, and it’s this level of operation that is WIDELY accepted by owners, operators and manufacturers alike to be DAMAGING to a diesel engine.

There’s an incredibly-wide range of engines out there: 2 stroke, 4 stroke, high HP, low HP, turboed, and natural, on-road, off-road and marine to name a few. The tolerance for low running will vary, but by and large, you’ll find more data to support that prolonged low idle should be avoided than you will the contrary.

A friend of mine runs a Freightliner with a DD Series 60. His primary goal to support himself and his family is to squeeze every possible penny from each gallon of fuel, yet he NEVER leaves that cab for an extended amount of time before hitting the factory-installed Idle Control button on the dash to increase the idle. Truckers don’t do this for kicks – just to burn more fuel, make more noise and produce more exhaust, they do it to protect their largest asset.

So again, I don’t disagree with most of your point, and you’ve extracted great economy from your boat, and that’s cool, but I hope no-one comes away from these threads thinking that it’s a good idea to let their engines chug along incessantly at low idle/in neutral because they think the potential for damage is “myth.”
 
I am happy to see that you understand slow is not no load/idle. I wouldn’t be moving much under those conditions and agree long idle is to be avoided even though it doesn’t seem to cause harm when followed by a heavy load run as in sport fish boats. Maintaining proper operating temperature is always a requirement, however it is maintained. I disagree with the too common practice of "warming up" the engines at dock idle as well for the reasons you state.
 
Bruce, I'm with you. I really like having extra power & speed available, and I'm just not ready or willing to travel at 6-8 knots all the time anyway. Sometimes it's nice to go slow, but it's good to know that there's a little throttle left when things get snotty.
 
Back
Top