Danforth vs. Plow Anchor

PJForcino

Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2007
RO Number
27038
Messages
1
I just purchased a Maxum 2800 SCR.
It came with a Danforth 18. On first day, after pulling up anchor in bay (4 ft/windy day), shaft was severely bent. Maxum suggests I replace Danforth with 14lb Plow. I've always had a danforth and not sure if problem was a poor quality/economy anchor, or if I should take Maxum's advice and buy a plow. I do my boating on south shore and am not sure a plow is appropriate for the bottoms we encounter.
Any suggestions?
 
a 14 lbs anchor on a 28 footer ? ask the clown who suggested that if he has ever actually been on a boat !!!

"it came with" is your clue there... dealer supplied "coast guard package", right? as in the cheapest POS they could sell.

if you've always had danforth in these waters and they worked, then stick to them. indeed they work, except in grass.

but if you bent it, it means it was holding... just get a quality danforth, not the dealer el cheapo special...
 
Check my thread "Anchors-revisited" last week. I just dumped a 14# Delta in favor of a 22# Delta because it wouldn't hold in anything but dead calm. I anchor in sand.
 
My Chaparral 310 came with a 35# Delta, 30 feet of chain and 200 feet of line. All has been fine so far. We anchor in red, mucky clay type soil....unless it wraps around a tree stump or discarded Christmas Tree.
 
Last season I switched from the "recommended" size danforth to an oversized Fortress Aluminum. (My brother helped me make the decision by dropping my anchor, with line, overboard!)

The Chesapeake varies from sandy to muddy (rarely rocky) and the Fortress is fantastick. And it's a pretty piece of hardware to have hanging off the front of the boat!
 
At least a 22 lb Delta (not a plough or CQR). Use genuine brands. I don't believe that Danforth ever made an 18, so it is a knock off (perhaps a "hooker" which came in a 18 lb. Toss it. If you buy a Danforth, buy a High Test--they are in 12, 20 and 35 lbs. The steel is a better alloy, the design is better.
 
Danforth v. Plow - depends on the bottom where you're gonna anchor. Plow works beter in grass while Danforth works better in mud. Have a 60 lb plow, but replaced with a Danforth for the mud bottom I anchor in.
 
bill, you're right about mud. my FX55 has NEVER failed to set in the muddy bottom of my favorite anchorage. it's like clockwork. I stop, payout 75' of chain and i know that when i put the engine in reverse the chain will come taught and cause the windlass clutch to slip. and that's on only 5:1 scope. In morning, the thing is buried so deep that i have to work it out of the bottom.

on the other hand, i see many boats failing to to set or drag with deltas.

it's not surprising, when you look at the shape of a delta it doens' have the horizontal surface of a fortress.
 
I wonder why the plow is becoming more popular on new boats.
The danforth has always been more popular and one of the reasons is that it's prety good on almost any bottom except for grass as Pascal mentioned.
But lately, when I look at small cruisers passing by, they all seem to have a plow.
Is it cheaper for the manufacturer?
 
I had a guy tell me I should get rid of my Bruce because "it's ugly"....WTF?
I felt like pushing him in the lake after hearing that one. LOL
I told him it's an ANCHOR not a trophy. LOL
 
I have not had good experiences with the cheap knock-off Danforths, which is probably what the boat came with. If you'd had good success with Danforths before, I would stick with that, but as Bob Austin said, go with the Hi-Tensile series, they work very well for me but are not cheap.
 
I replaced my 20H Danforth with a 35# Delta and it has not failed to set the first time in grass, sand or mud bottoms.
 
Make sure your bow roller will accept the Ronca before you put big $'s into that??
 
Danforths and plows are simply not comparable - the Danforth is a light weight single purpose specialist anchor, designed to hold well in simple straight line pulls. The plow is the opposite, intended as a general purpose type.

If a general purpose type is wanted, then the plow is about the poorest and most out-of-date (what other piece of equipment on your boat dates directly to 1933?).

The fact that the Danforth shank was bent does not necessarily mean "it was holding" and that another Danforth should be obtained. More likely, it was stuck on something, and the damage was done during retrieval.

If I may add the following for reference...

Summary of West Marine 2006 testing (quotes direct from their current catalog):
wm-catalog-table-testing.gif


These are the results on a weight-for-weight basis:
wm_testing_chart_740w.jpg


Nbs:
- The "claw" is the Bruce from Lewmar
- The CQR is the genuine (original) plow
- The West Marine Performance 20 is a Danforth copy
 
Anchors must first set before they can hold. The CQR doesent set well; IMO but the Deltas, also a plow desigs, sets well probably because of the sharper point. deltas have set and held well for me in all bottom conditions. Danforths are excellent in sand and soft mud but dont like grass and hard bottoms and a believe it or not rock or clam can wedge into the V and prevent holding.
 
Understand that Craig Smith is pushing his Anchor! Take your advertising elsewhere. That test, which you cite when you post on multiple lists, only shows how the Ronca anchor set that day under those conditions. Anchoring tests are very difficult to reporduce, and every maker has their favorite.
That the West Marine Performance 20 (an exact copy of the Danforth Pattern) failed to set, shows some defect in the testing methodology.

The "plows" which are being described and are on many of the new United States boats are Delta fast sets.

The genuine CQR plow, is a very well tested and tried anchor, used by many long distance cruising vessels. I have used them, in the appropiate size, many thousands of nights all over the world. The Danforth was also designed in the 30's--as was the Northill pattern. Fisherman type of anchors were designed long before 1800.

The Danforth high test is a very good anchor in a variety of conditions--but best in sand and seconday best in mud. The comperable size Danforth and Fortress will have approximately the same holding power in mud.

Read some of the posts on anchoring technique and how to deploy and set an anchor.
 
Not saying that craigsmith is biased, but it would have gone a long way toward increasing his believability is he had stated that:

a) he is an employee of Rocna.
b) the son of the designer of the Rocna anchor.

By not stating this, the value of the data is greatly reduced.

-edit-

Above unchanged.

Add:

We welcome representatives of manufacturers. They provide a valuable service to the community and we appreciate it ( Thank you! ). It is important, however, that such a relationship is announced for all to see, so that the point-of-view of the poster is evident.

When a mfg rep posts, but hides the relationship, the assumption is that they intend to do something sneaky and not in the best interest of current/potential customers.
 
I switched to a CQR and use a danforth as back up or stern anchor. We have a lot of grass bottoms in my area and I got frustrated with the danforth. I also appreciate the CQR's holding power on a tide change vs the danforth which would loose it's grip when the boat would swing around on a tide change. IMO most people do not use enough chain which can greatly improve an anchors performance on a shortened scope. My rule of thumb is to always go up one size from the mfgr. maxium recomendation. Just my opinion
 
Which brings up another question: why do mfgrs always seem to recommend one size too small??? Why not say it as it is?
 
Back
Top