Danforth vs. Plow Anchor

You can still buy the original Danforth anchor. Tie Down Engineering now manufactures the Danforth models under the Danforth trademark.

I have a 26' wooden boat and use a Danforth Standard. This is the original Danforth design: strong and heavy for its size. The Danforth Standard is reasonably priced and effective. I believe the heavy weight improves setting performance.

Danforth recommends the Standard S600 (9 lbs.) for a 26' boat. I use the S1300 (16 lbs.) Danforth Standard. That's two sizes larger and is rated to hold a 36' boat in 20 knot winds. It will hold a 26' in a lot more wind than that.

I anchor overnight in waters with mud bottoms. Lots of tidal current and wind, too. Last week I had two days with afternoon and evening winds gusting to 35 MPH. That anchor was buried in the first try and never slipped. Full scope is highly advisable in gusts like this. I was almost full scope at six-to-one.

The rest of my rode includes an ACCO swivel, 30' of 3/8" 3B chain (3B or BBB is a heavy weight anchor link) and premium nylon line. For sleeping on an anchor for a couple of days, I don't think this is anchor overkill at all.
 
I just swapped my Danforth II 2500 for a Fortress FX-16.
Seems to be better at holding for my type of bottom.
I will be selling the Danforth if anyone is interested.
It's in good shape, weighs 20 lbs. I don't think I can ship it, so pickup is best.
 
I might be interested, but the freight may make it cost prohibitive.
 
The Danforth pattent was basically for the 32 degree angle between the flukes and the shank. The Danforth was inverted by Robert Danforth in the late 30's and there was a patent application about 1941. Almost immediately Northill filed a law suite. Northill was working for Northrop aviation and developing sea plane anchors. The anchors were enough different that both patterns were allowed. The use of the Origional Danforth (as slightly modified by the Navy) was primarly for landing craft. The landing craft had large reel winches with cables attatched to the anchor which was deployed from the stern as the boat drove onto the beach. The anchor would winch the boat off the beach after the load was depolyed. I have a couple of the origional Danforth and Northill anchors. The Danforth came in two forms (neither is currently produced). One was an anchor which had both flukes forged in one piece. The shank and crown was also forged, with the cross bar pinned in place. The second type had each fluke forged (with the "T" inner flange like the current HT)separately, and the two crown pieces forged separately. The two halves of the crown, were riveted to the flukes and other half of the crown--no welding. The shank was heavier than the current anchors and the cross bar, was also heavier. These were mass produced in 40, 75 and 150 lb sizes (some much larger for the larger landing craft). Some were made in bronze. These were almost given away at the end of WWII.

Rule industries made a number of versions of the Danforth--all variations of the standard or HT. Some were not particularly good anchors. (as I recollect the 2500 was one I almost gave away after trying) None were better than the HT, or the origional ones made for the landing craft. The HT is a forged steel. The standard is just bent heavy sheet metal. The deep set have higher strength steel, and a spring type steel for the shank, but both of these are susceptable to bending if caught under a rock or coral head. In the sands of S. Calif, or some of the small rocky/sandy beaches of S. Calif (and many other places) the standard Danforth is a satisfactory anchor. I never trusted my boats to a standard Danforth anchor as its primary anchor in the 40+ years I sailed out of S. Calif. I used a high test. The problem with "XX size rated for 20 knots winds" is that winds often shift, currents shift, and the danforth can pull free--then if the boat starts dragging, the anchor will not reset, and tends to float. Fluke area and design, not only weight is important in an anchor. The lighter Fortress holds better than the standard Danforth. One of the other reasons that folks get away with using the standard danforth in S. Calif. is that it is customary to anchor fore and aft, to keep the bow into the wind and swell, thus the boat does not swing widely and pull out either of the anchors.
 
Success with a particular anchor depends on how and where you use it. I usually anchor with the Danforth Standard as a primary anchor, no second anchor. Due to the geography of where I boat, the river systems run primarily North-South with a prevailing wind from the W-SW. The boat points basically to the West and will swing with current change, but will not swing enough to turn the anchor. All bets are off during slack current with little wind, and that's where all of that chain works to my advantage again.

If I use a stern anchor at all, it's a smaller Danforth clone that's used to limit, but not eliminate swing.

If I should ever replace the Standard though, I'll try the lighter weight HT.

Re: Danforth clones...

West Marine “clone” fluke anchor is a copy of Danforth?

I don’t think so. When you compare the traditional Danforth Standard anchors with the West Marine Traditional anchors some differences become apparent. These are the least expensive fluke anchors from both companies but they are certainly not the same anchor.

The Danforth Standard comes in nine sizes, the West Marine Traditional in four sizes.

The flukes and shanks of both makes are of different design and size.

West Marine makes its “Traditional” in sizes that fall between the Danforth Standards, making a direct comparison impossible. However, if you compare at the specs of the anchors weighing less than 40 lbs. you will find that WM Traditionals seem to weigh a little less for their size than the Danforth Standards.
 
My neighbors lost their anchor, so each of the brothers would take a turn in the water holding the anchor rode. They had excellent holding power in sand, although they did not work well in more then 4 feet of water. They actually had more holding power as the day wore on because they would gain beer weight. I can't remember if they had chain. Retrieval was very easy.
 
(I've got to wipe Diet Coke off of the computer screen after that one.)
 
I treat those 'tests' with high suspect based on 25 years of real world experience overnighting many hundreds of times using a variety of anchors.

The most rediculous observation relates to the Bruce/claw type.

My types used, in order, are the Danforth hi tensile, the CQR (very briefly, POS), the Fortress (easy to use lunch hook) & the Bruce (happens to be the 33 as tested). The Bruce, by far, is the best all round. Over half of our on anchor overnights have beenspent on this anchor. All, without incident.
 
few "tests" simulate real world conditions of differing bottoms and untended resetting. The best holding anchor that has difficulty resetting is a bad anchor. The bruce and delta seem very good at resetting.
 
you know, there are no such thing as a bad anchor... except maybe some of the cheap knock offs. 99% of the time, the failure to set or hold is operator error : not enough scope, not enough chain reversing to fast, wrong type for the bottom.

that said, Bruce made a good point. if you anchor out in places subject to tide reversal and you need you anchor to reset, Danforth maybe not be ideal because they will clog with grass and mud.
 
I just bought a Rocna this year. So far it has been very good. It sets very quickly and it digs in. I've been down to the bottom to see how it set and it's always buried completely. I always need to power past the anchor to pull it free, but it pulls free quickly like that.

I used a Bruce on all my previous boats, but this one was much bigger, so I wanted an anchor I would be confident with while I slept. I'm happy with it (but it is expensive).
 
Back
Top