dangerous???

deltabighat

Member
exMember
Joined
Aug 17, 2004
RO Number
14904
Messages
493
Last year while boating out here on the left coast where I live, my brother and I came across a boat dead in the water in a rather remote area. A guy on the boat was standing up waving his arms above his head....an I need help sign. As we went over, I told my brother we would stay clear of him until we knew who was on board and what the deal was. As we got closer it turned out to be a guy and his wife who had run their only battery down trying to start their boat. We jumped them and they got on their way and everyone was happy. We do not have much trouble our way with piracy and such but it is my opinion you be very careful with such things. Anyone have any tales where caution was the better part of valor. I tend to be overly cautious when this kind of thing happens. I always help no matter what, but I wait a bit and try and see just what I'm getting into. Am I a bit over cautious?

DBH
 
Ever see the movie Dead Calm. If you haven't, rent it.
 
It sounds to me like you handled the situation correctly. I don't think you're overcautious at all. Yet at the same time, you provided assistance where needed. You're probably going to heaven :-)
 
in US waters i wouldn't worry and assist. Maybe with a call to the USCH before.

in foreign waters, incl. the Bahamas, i would avoid getting to close and instead try to get help on the way. Especially these days with crime on the rise in the islands.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

in US waters i wouldn't worry and assist. Maybe with a call to the USCH before.

in foreign waters, incl. the Bahamas, i would avoid getting to close and instead try to get help on the way. Especially these days with crime on the rise in the islands.






That's what I'm worried about for our next Bahamas trip. We'll keep an eye on the Abacos forums and if it gets too bad before we plan to head to FL, we might come visit you and then cruise the Keys.
 
I am sure this has been covered completely before in this forum but a couple years ago I brought up the subject of guns on board and all hell broke loose on another forum. Don't know about you, but when I am offshore or camped out on the hook, I always have a large caliber weapon on board. Never even a hint of using it in over 15 years but its there. Ya never know.

DBH
 
quote:

Originally posted by adru

Ever see the movie Dead Calm. If you haven't, rent it.





In the middle of nowhere there is nowhere to hide.

Dead Calm is a decent thriller but's it's about as realistic as Captain Ron. Hughie the psycho pirate guy kicks the victim's shotgun overboard (so much for the NRA idea) but is brought to justice after a flare is shot into his mouth. Hughie drifts away face down in the sea with his head smoking.
 
Not to make this a threadjack but...

As long as we're talking about boating movies, has anyone ever seen/know the name of a movie where about six people in their early twenties with prior boating experience sign on to do a yacht delivery, of a sailboat, I believe, and there are two main characters, one male and one female, with rival boating skills, and foul weather approaches, and the female wants to seek shelter, but the male "captain" pushes on. I've seen parts of this movie a couple of times, but I can't remember the title of it, nor can I remember all of the pertinent details either, apparently! Thanks.
 
quote:

Originally posted by yzer

Dead Calm is a decent thriller but's it's about as realistic as Captain Ron.






Now you've went and done it, don't you dare start messing with Captain Ron!!!!!

If it's gonna happen, it's gonna happen out there!

:)
 
After the long thread anout "Carrying guns in the NE" I am surprized you would be concerned about this ... most folks in that thread felt no concern whatever about threats on the water. Personally I will render any aid that I can, but will acesss any situation carefully and with Mr. Ruger close by.
 
Even on the St. Johns river in a bass boat, I go armed. To much BS out there.
 
Captain Ron: [telling how he lost his eye] Yeah, it happened when I went down off the coast of Australia.

Katherine Harvey: Your boat sank?

Captain Ron: No, no, no, no. Not my boat. My boss's boat. Yeah, we hit this reef. Huge son-of-a-bitch. Ran the whole coast.

Katherine Harvey: Wait. The Great Barrier Reef?

Captain Ron: You've heard of it, huh? Smart lady.
 
Don't get me started... [:-spin]

What Pascal said. Call the USCG immediately, with coordinates and description of their vessel and your own. Then keep them updated as you approach and learn more. Try to raise the other vessel on the VHF. Once communication is established, advise the other vessel that you have notified the CG. It is your duty to keep the situation safe for both vessels, yours first. Then render aid as is also your duty. I'll take the million to one odds that the other boat is a bad guy trying to "get" me.

If you are packing, think about the implications for a minute before you proactively get the gun into position to use it; now you will be the aggressor and viewed as hostile by the other party. They don't know any more about you and your motivations than you do about theirs.

As for the Bahamas, I'd be doing some serious profiling from a distance, and likely error on the side of just calling it in.

I promise not to say anything more on this on this thread! Good topic though.

George
 
I am shocked by the sentiments expressed here!

How could you all say that Captain Ron isn't realistic??!!

:)

To the question at hand- prudent move and good job for helping.
 
I hear a lot of VHF traffic off the mouth of the Mississippi River in the Gulf.
WHen boats call the USCG for help, they quickly send out a message asking for
others to help. From what it sounds like to me, they only come out to help if
you are sinking or in really bad shape. They always try to get someone else in
the area to help first.
If you call them, they will tell you to help the boater. It is your responsibility.
I have towed a few boats before, but we are not in a dangerous place, so far.
I keep a gun on board, just in case. Most people I have found drifting have no VHF
on board and they are out of range for cell service.
I tow them to the nearest dock and let them get help from there. Then go on with my
day. I hope that if I am ever broke down that someone will do the same for me.
However, after reading about all the bad things that happen in other countries waters,
I would steer clear of anyone drifting unless they call for help on the radio.
 
Just can't resist - Sorry George! LOL

BUT - you can be packing and at the ready and those around you won't even know the difference. It all boils down to prep/carry methods, just something to think about. Now if you're wearing an itty bitty speedo, well, I can't help you there...LOL

quote:

Originally posted by caltexfla

Don't get me started... [:-spin]

<snip snip>

If you are packing, think about the implications for a minute before you proactively get the gun into position to use it; now you will be the aggressor and viewed as hostile by the other party.




 
How did this turn into a Captain Ron thread..

Deald Calm!! love that movie it's a definate must see for anyone into boating. or if you just like nicole kidman... who was the other guy??? Sam Neil? and Billy Zane? couldent remember all I remmebr is Nicole running around half naked the whole movie.

As far as stopping to help.. I guess it's a throw back to my boy scout days, but I have to stop and help!! wheter it is a car on the side of the road a boat or even a hitch-hicker. Im sure someday it will get the better of me but until then I just think of all the people I have helped. Although sometimes that hours long tow to safe harbor or a dock can hurt at the fuel pump but it's still worth it.
 
yep, Sam Neil and Billy Zane. good boating movie.

i'm not too worried in US waters... i came upon a couple of fishermen stranded a few miles of Pt Judith RI last fall, gave them a tow into Pt Judith. Not that easy since i was alone but that was the right thing to do.

in foreign waters, like the bahamas, if i had to take someone in tow, I would but without getting too close to pass the line and with a line i could quickly release or cut if they suddenly fire up their engine to close the gap and board.
 
Back
Top