Deadliest Boating

muddkatt

exMember
Member
exMember
Joined
Jul 8, 2007
RO Number
27304
Messages
1,514
Florida leads the nation. Its great to be number one!!

http://www.tampabay.com/sports/outdoors/article493970.ece

Boating deaths jumped 10 percent in Florida last year, marking the 16th year in 20 that the Sunshine State has led the nation in fatalities.

All told, 77 people died. Eight deaths were in Tampa Bay - from a 49-year-old Spring Hill man thrown from a speedboat to a kayaker who became unconscious after he fell into the water near the Gandy Bridge.

The 2007 statistics, released this week, come just weeks after state lawmakers bypassed a plan to phase in boater education requirements, which state officials believe would reduce deaths by as much as 25 percent.

Last year, 70 percent of all boating accidents involved operators with no formal safety education; for fatalities, that number was 85 percent.

The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission asked the Legislature to approve a plan to phase in mandatory boater education over the next 11 years. Currently, only boaters under 21 must take such coursework.

"The numbers show that boater education works," said Capt. Richard Moore, the state's top boating law administrator. "Our research shows that we could save 15 to 25 lives a year if everybody took a safe boating class."

But at a Feb. 6 meeting of the House Committee on Conservation and State Lands, the commission's proposal fell on deaf ears. Legislators were skeptical about expanding the current regulations, equating it to big government.

"I don't think it's necessary for every person, especially those who have grown up with boats and would have enough common sense to know what's right and wrong when on the water," said Rep. Faye Culp, a Tampa Republican and vice chairwoman of the committee.

Two other Tampa Bay area lawmakers also weighed in. Rep. Rob Schenck, R-Spring Hill, called it "another case where government tries to act as our grandmothers."

Rep. Will Weatherford, R-Wesley Chapel, voiced support for the current regulations, but felt older boaters should recognize the risks. "For everyone who swims in a pool, we don't force them to go take a course to tell them you are swimming at your own risk," he said.

But Moore said older boaters are at the heart of the problem.

"Most of the boating accidents and fatalities involve people 36 years or older, who have more than 100 hours boating experience and no formal boating education," he said.

In 1996, Florida began requiring boaters 21 years or younger to take a boater education course. Since its passage, young boaters have gone from being involved in more than 21 percent of accidents to 14 percent.

The Florida Boating Advisory Council, which is comprised of 18 people representing a variety of boating interests, supported the Conservation Commission measure. So does a majority of voters and boaters in the state, according to commission surveys, including one conducted by Mason-Dixon Polling and Research in 2007.

The Mason-Dixon poll showed that 89 percent of those polled support requiring all boaters to undergo mandatory education.

The deadliest area for boaters in Florida was Miami-Dade with 13 fatalities. Statewide, the leading cause of death continues to be drowning.

State officials say drowning deaths would also decrease if boaters would wear life jackets, or personal flotation devices.

"There is really no excuse for it. Today's PFDs are not hot or cumbersome like the old ones," said Lt. Ed Cates, a commission boating safety officer. "You can wear one all day and forget you have it on."

Ken
 
nanny state officials intent on expanding the reach of their bureaucracy and thus their salaries are on the rise again.
 
Interesting, but what is the rate per 1,000 boats lets say. The article only gives absolute numbers, which would not take into effect i) The density of boats in Florida, versus say Rhode Island, and ii) the effect of seasonality of Florida vis-a-vis other states, amongst other factors.

The article also seems to have a tone of fear mongering to push certain agendas.
 
ITK, you have a point. Boating season last all year in Florida, and Fl. probably has more boaters than any other state. I don't know how they could determine accidents per hours operated. This is just one of those fact sheets that does not address every possible circumstance.

Ken
 
That is a good point. I'm sure Minnesota has more snowmobile-related deaths than Florida...
 
Chicken or the egg? Do untrained boaters make more mistakes, or are the people who make mistakes likely not to want training???? I would think that it's a little of both, but the data on educating younger boaters seems to bear out that training doesn't hurt. Why not just require a test? If they pass, no classes are required. If they don't pass, then it can't hurt. Just don't expect to be able to legislate common sense. Darwin will always prevail in some cases....
 
it seems pretty silly not to require formal training. imagine if they did'nt require it for people over 21 on our highways?.......lol. an easy solution is phase in the change. require it for registration renewal. it can't hurt. anyone that grew up boating will breeze thru the course. its not that big a deal i've taken it and it translates to a break on my insurance rate. if it really did'nt matter the insurance company would'nt care.
 
Incentives for voluntary training would be fine, but the current motivation for mandatory training classes is to put more money in the coffers, educating boaters and reducing accidents is a distant concern...
 
How do you practically mandate formal training? The only way to learn is thorugh actual on water experience, and in boating, I do not see how you regulate, or even test this proficiency.

Lets be real, a partially trained lab monkey could pass the current boater education class.
 
I'm surprised they didnt mention Shark deaths along with boating accidents.
I made one trip to FL in my pickup a couple years ago. The 'density' of boats is amazing in all those harbors and marinas. But for every boat you have in the water, there are Yards full of boats on trailers. Cartoppers leaning against hedges, etc. Lots and lots of boats that dont go in the water real often.

With all that to consider, Training wouldn't amount to much. I'd bet if you had to put the causes of all those accidents into one word....the word would be: "Distraction"
How is Training gonna help out there?
 
good point I think FL overtook MI in the number of registered boats.
 
quote:

Originally posted by In the know

Lets be real, a partially trained lab monkey could pass the current boater education class.






Case in point: ME!

I looked over an on-line course for about 30 minutes, then took the online test. Passed with flying colors.

Now, that was a few years ago. I've learned and experienced a heck of a lot since then. Quite frankly, I'm kinda surprised I didn't hurt myself those first few times I went out, with my handy dandy certifcation card in my pocket!

And geeze, I don't even want to think about back in the 80's on my PWC. I knew NOTHING about boating rules and regulations back then.
 
Testing does not equate to common sense, if it did there would be no highway deaths. Anyone can study one weekend and pass a USCG Captain's test but that doesn't mean squat about actually boating or being a Captain either. If a Kayaker falls from a bridge and kills himself, I guess there should be a bridge safety course too.
 
it's not just registration, in winter half the boats at florida marinas are registered out of state. and registration nrs dont' include documented boats...

show me a state where the mandatory education is even worth the fee... in most states, incl. florida for the under 21, it's a revenue making joke.
 
quote:

Originally posted by C_Spray
....... Why not just require a test? If they pass, no classes are required........






Yeah! Also, we should have a national holiday just for our veterans.

Wait a minute. We already have this, um, them.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

...

show me a state where the mandatory education is even worth the fee... in most states, incl. florida for the under 21, it's a revenue making joke.






I can not speak for all boaters’ education. I can only speak for the local class I took with my daughter.

First, let me say I read and learn from your posts here. With your vast experience as an boater I enjoy reading your posts.

I do not agree on the above post due to my personal experience.

In Wisconsin, boater’s education is mandated by law to operate a boat if born after a cretin date. I’m above the line. My daughter who just turned 12 is not.

I have previously taking the course online just to satisfy my own wish to take it.

As she was about to turn 12, the lowest age that a person in Wisconsin that has passed a boaters safety class can operate a motorboat, I enrolled her in the local USCG auxiliary class. The fee is $10/person and only covers the cost of the book. The labor, the instructors are volunteers. The classroom, the public library meeting room, is provided with out charge since they are a not for profit .

In our class we had three different instructors rotate thru, each taking a portion of the education. We also had a DNR (department of natural resources) officer come in and give a presentation as well as answer questions. We got a self study book that had chapters followed by practice quizzes and we reviewed the answers to the quizzes as a group.

I am not a fan of mandatory boater’s education. However I disagree that the class, at least in Wisconsin at a fee of $10/student and you keep the book, is a revenue maker.

I decided to not just drop off my daughter and pick her up at the end. I asked the instructor if I could join her and he said sure. I paid the $10 and sat next to her. At home, between the classes my daughter and I worked thru the book together.

Did I learn anything? Some, minor things, yes. Did my daughter learn anything? Yes, a lot. As we read the book I explained things to her. Some words were simply not in her vocabulary.

Now she (we) have the certificate. We have went boating twice since and I am in the process of reinforcing what she learned in practice, sort of like ‘behind the wheel’ in drivers ed speak. Basically I’m comfortable with her driving out in the open. When a few boats are passing I am on the lookout but she is behind the wheel.

In time I will have her take the boat thru locks, under bridges and dock. We will go one step at a time.

Again, at $10/student, I don’t believe this is making anyone money.
 
It's not the classes that make money but the fines for boating without a safety certificate, ouch!
 
quote:

Originally posted by In the know

How do you practically mandate formal training? The only way to learn is thorugh actual on water experience, and in boating, I do not see how you regulate, or even test this proficiency.

Lets be real, a partially trained lab monkey could pass the current boater education class.






the existing current boater ed class is not required over the age of 21. however deficient you might think it is, some kind of training is better than none.
 
quote:

Originally posted by vic33004

quote:

Originally posted by In the know

How do you practically mandate formal training? The only way to learn is thorugh actual on water experience, and in boating, I do not see how you regulate, or even test this proficiency.

Lets be real, a partially trained lab monkey could pass the current boater education class.






the existing current boater ed class is not required over the age of 21. however deficient you might think it is, some kind of training is better than none.








Man I like the idea / the concept/ the sales brochure.

But reality ?????

have ya driven on any road, parking lot, or to a DMV.

Cause from what I see it dont work !!!!! <grin>
 
quote:

Originally posted by vic33004

quote:

Originally posted by In the know

How do you practically mandate formal training? The only way to learn is thorugh actual on water experience, and in boating, I do not see how you regulate, or even test this proficiency.

Lets be real, a partially trained lab monkey could pass the current boater education class.






the existing current boater ed class is not required over the age of 21. however deficient you might think it is, some kind of training is better than none.








Without having an actual on water practical element to it, I fail to understand how you can call it training.
 
Back
Top