Deadly Boating Accident

Sad story yet amazing that the guy could hold onto his friend that long! Another example of why you should never, never....I mean NEVER pass between a tug and barge. Its taught in all the classes I've ever taken, including my captain's class for my masters license.
 
fishless, I can't believe that classes even have to teach that. One would think common sense would tell you not to pass between a barge and a tug. DUH!
 
Bob,

The classes are really telling you not to pass between the 2, (as you say common sensebut more important how to recognize, at night, a barge in tow.

They were 800 ft apart according to the article.

Very sad.....
 
It's amazing, isn't it. Once in awhile even the pros do it. A few years ago off NE FL, the VHF just lit up with hollering. A SHIP had run between tug and barge and cut the cable. Luckily, towing gear damage but no injuries and other vessel damage.

Deep water offshore boaters need to remember that many ships go on auto pilot about as soon as they can steady on course to destination. At that point they may rely on lookouts or none or radar collision alarm which may or may not work or have somebody near the speaker.
 
They teach it...sad to say some never pay attention to lights. They may use them as a way to know the location of another boat but not understand what they really mean. They teach it for a eason...there are a lot of knuckleheads out there who lack common sense...some still don't get it after that and that's when stuff like this happens.

MAYBE (To get attention) we oughta have a section on boatfix for laying out the meaning of all the lights. SOmething the administrators may want to think about. (Maybe we already have it and I don't know about it yet......

Oh......just checked. We have the entire manual for lights ect in the RO menu section. EVERYONE should take a look at it as a refresher!
 
quote:

Originally posted by interj

Bob,

The classes are really telling you not to pass between the 2, (as you say common sensebut more important how to recognize, at night, a barge in tow.

They were 800 ft apart according to the article.

Very sad.....






With the vessels 800 feet apart, in the dark with five foot seas, and against a glare of a maze of lights along the shore, it's possible they simply didn't see either the tug or the barge before crossing over the towline.
Very sad indeed.
 
The amazing thing is that the tug put played it's spot light on the cable so the other boat would see it. That's the equivalent of a big flashing "danger!!" sign. Plus the guy should have had his radio on. I'll admit that once in a while I forget to turn mine on, but there's no excuse for a commercial vessel at night on the ocean in a busy shipping lane. Really sad situation.
 
There's less excuse for a private boat in a commercial channel at night that does not know the rules of the road. Hopefully that's what you meant?
 
I saw an interview last night with the kin of the boat owner who stated that this was the boat owner's first night fishing trip...
 
quote:

Originally posted by boatbum

There's less excuse for a private boat in a commercial channel at night that does not know the rules of the road. Hopefully that's what you meant?






Right - I think the fishing boat was a commercial charter, but may be mistaken. Boats should always have their radio on, but those for-hire should definitely know better.

Being out at night close to a shipping lane means you really, really need to have all your gear on.

I know it was a small boat, but I'd bet that this is a case where having had either radar or an AIS receiver (and knowing how to use them effectively) could have helped.

Then again, I just read that the fishing boat captain thought it was OK to pass 400 feet in front of the tow - maybe no amount if information or tools could have prevented this.
 
I hate to think about the eventual litigation in this case. Suppose the deceased (rest in peace with all respects to family) insurance co. doesn't want to pay because they claim wrongful death?
 
b_arrington,
The charter boat was not involved in the accident. They picked up either a survivor or victim, can't remember.
 
Back
Top