Deposit question

mefirst, a PSA is more than just deposit protection. It should govern all the terms of the sale, including when full payment is due, what equipment is included and the condition of the boat (as is, etc.). Trust me, we've heard a few dozen horror stories here concerning boat sales that later came back to haunt the seller.
 
Without a written agreement you may have a tough time keeping the money. I seem to recall that anything over $500 needs to be in writing to be legally enforcable. What is catastrophic to one person might not be to someone else. The guy's wife leaving him because he just bought a boat might be catastrophic to him. If it were me I would give it back and do a little research to find a written agreement for the next purchaser.
 
For the sake of $1,000.00 dollars I would destroy the cheque and move on. Not worth the agrivation should you try and cash it. Could be returned NSF or stpped payment, or go through then have him crying or yelling on the phone at you.
Life is just to short for any of this.....
 
Just a follow up, the buyer emailed me today saying he had the right to change his mind (legally I'm pretty sure he did not), he put a stop payment on the check (I figured he would do that, even though I never said I was going to deposit it) and then complained he is out $50 for gas and the stop payment fee. A real winner.

But I've moved on ... anyone want to buy a boat? [:-bouncy]
 
With an idiot like that, it probably would have bounced.
 
Scot I know how you feel. I sold a PWC in the past got a deposite form a guy who said he would pick it up at the end of the week, he shows up friday asking for his deposite back. somthin g about he did get the refund as big as expected ect. Im like whats a deposite for then also? one thing i still get is a signed contract for a canvas or upholstery job with deposite then they call to cancel because they got a buyer for the boat.
 
quote:

Originally posted by dancerscap

I believe that most state laws provide a 72 hour buyers remorse period. In real estate deals that deposit is called earnest money and is not refundable except if there is a problem such as with a deed or mortgage title.






NYS laws are the same as you quoted, 72 hours. Me, I would give the money back. Also, anyone else that may be intreseted, I would tell them you have a commitment, but it is not a deal to the deal is done. So get there info, and tell them you will contact them either way. Also, if it is a done deal, follow through and let the others know it is a done deal.

Simple rule of life, what goes around comes around. Do onto others as you would want to be done to you.

Walter
 
I guess I am old school. If a deposit is given and boat taken off the market. The deposit is only refundable if the boat fails a survey, does not perform or buyer can't get financing.What good is a deposit if it is refundable for any reason at all. I always cash the checks and tell the buyer that I am going to cash it. If he protests, I would tell him that as far as I am concerned tha boat is still for sale to the first person to come along with money. If they default I feel that as a minimum the cost of re advertising should come out of the deposit.
 
You never told us the reason he gave you for changing his mind so I won't address that. What I do see in your post is that you told people that the boat was sold when it was not. You had a "deal pending" not a sold boat and you took it off the market prematurely. Please learn from this and hopefully you will get a better result in the future. In your best interest good luck!
 
I'm pretty sure that if anyone were to research the actual laws regarding the 72 hour "cooling off" period that this applies only in door to door type sales.
I was in the Automotive Business for over 30 years and believe me........there have been numerous times that dealerships have been taken to small claims courts by people trying to get their deposits back after they go home and change their minds about buying a car. You wouldn't believe some of the excuses that people TRY to use. Anyways......They are very seldom successful.
These laes don't apply when a person leaves their place of residence (or whatever) and goes to a business establishment and makes a purchase. They apply only when someone (a person or business) approaches you away from THEIR place of business and you make a purchase. You now have 72 hours to back-out of it.
To REALLY simplify it....
YOU left YOUR house and went to THEIR place of business and bought something. THEY took the whatever it is you bought off the market and technically legally COULDN'T sell it to someone else because YOU already owned it. By putting a deposit down you are actually entering into a legal and binding contractual agreement to follow through with the completion of the purchase and the seller (business) by the same token has entered into the same legal contactual agreemnet with you NOT to sell it to someone else. Case Closed.
I would have cashed the check imediately and told the guy to either come pick up his boat or go pound salt.
I'm sure that alot of you guys/gals here have at some time and probably more than once made more than one purchase that other than a car/boat/house was a major purchase to you and left a check or even cash as a deposit for a product and/or services of some sort. For those of you that left checks for a product to be delivered at a later date or a service to be performed at a later date..........ever take a look at the cancelled check? Pay close attention to the date that check was deposited in the reciever's bank account. 99% of the time you'll see that it was the same day or the day after. Why?......Simple.......YOU gave it to them in return for something they are going to give to you and there's no reason for them to assume that you aren't going to complete the transaction for any reason other than non-performance of the product/service they are providing.
It's really THAT simple.
 
Learn from this experience and move on. In this case (even though the guy seems rude) you are doing the right thing by giving the check back - and you might even feel a little better knowing that he is upset about the gas and the cost of the stop payment.

Next time, don't take the boat off the market until full payment is received. Be up front with the next buyer and tell him that if you get another full offer or a better one than his, then you will be returning his check unless he comes up with the money immediately. Without full payment, you have every right to accept other offers. Any buyer should understand the rules and accept the risk that goes along with a down payment - but you must explain that risk every time.
 
Well said Tanq. With commited's logic (and the majority of responders here), don't even bother taking a deposit and just keep right on trying to sell until somebody comes up with the cash! If I give you a deposit on a boat and you sell it to somebody else later today or tomorrow, I'll be seeing you in court!
 
The reason given by the buyer for backing out was the boat was too big (after he said last Saturday that it was just the right size) and he paid too much (which indicates his lack of morals and/or intelligence)

I did a little web searching last night and found the following

Tanqueray is right (at least in MI) the only cooling off period is for sales at the consumers home (door to door) or sales where you are given a gift for showing up (like time share sales)

I also found out that contracts over $1000 in MI need to be in writing. The language gets a bit legal, but I believe that the signed check I still have from the buyer stating "boat deposit" on the memo line would satisfy the legal requirement and pass for a document indicating the sale of the boat.

Just thought I would pass that along so that others may learn.
 
Clearly he got shafted. So, he now has a choice - take the guy to court or rip up the check and move on. My guess is that he's going to rip up the check and move on. Is it the right move? Only Mefirst can answer that one.

Regarding my logic above - If I come back to the person who made the original offer with only a deposit to show for it, and tell him I received another similar offer and I need him to "show me the money" or I'm returning his deposit - I'll gladly meet him in court.
 
RE: the stop payment - if you can get a check cashing place to cash the check, they will go after the guy, regardless of a stop payment.
 
"Regarding my logic above - If I come back to the person who made the original offer with only a deposit to show for it, and tell him I received another similar offer and I need him to "show me the money" or I'm returning his deposit - I'll gladly meet him in court."

I'm not sure exactly what you mean by this so I won't comment. But could you clarify it? I'm referring the 'show me the money' part.
 
And you'll probably lose. Once money exchanges hands, a contract is made unless spelled out otherwise in a written contract which it wasn't in this case.
 
Back
Top