Diesel Power

bsteven43

Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2007
RO Number
28678
Messages
76
Guys - It seems there are three commons diesel engines on the higher end sedans/convertibles I'm looking at. Either Cat, Cummings or Yanmar. Are there any general thoughts around quality, reliability, performanc etc. of the three? All other things being equal, would you be inclined to prefer one versus the other?
 
All could be good- Model numbers would help- if these are used boats the history of the engines are most important
 
I would also consider what service you have in your area. We have had cummins for the past 5 yrs, with no problems, and the new one coming has John Deeres. If you haven't scanned boatdiesel. it may help in your consideration.
 
I've heard alot of good about Yanmars. On the boats we sell that htey are available in, they seem to return the best fuel economy. I've also run a Formula 40PC with (I believe) 440 Yanmars, and turbo lag seemed non existant and the boat pulled very nicely...almost like a gas engine...right from the onset of throttle input
 
Had tired, worn 454's with 2600+ hrs.

Repowered to 315 Yanmars 2 years ago.

It's a 24 year new boat !

Increased speed, range and ease of operation, not to mention safety and reliability.

If you are in a situation that requires rebuilding or replacing the propulsion system in a good quality vessel and plan on keeping her it's worth a serious look.

The DIFFERENCE in cost between the new Crusader 8.1's and the Yanmars wasa not that great as the 8.1's would have required bigger shafts.

Good Luck,

RWS
 
all of the major names have good engines and once in a while produce a bad one. i would make my decision based on support in your area.
 
Back
Top