I was a gas dock attendent when I was a kid. I almost never got tipped, and still found it to be the best job I ever had. I worked there because I loved boats and loved being out in the sun.
One gas dock nearby has a sign on the dock that says "Dock girl works for tips only". I found the idea that the marina owner should expect the boaters to be the sole source of his employee's compensation insulting. Additionally, she was terrible at what she did. She didn't know the first thing about docking or tying off a boat. She has some assets, but none related to boating, if you know what I mean. I quit gassing up there.
On the other end of the spectrum, a gas dock further up the cove has a couple of young kids who go out of their way to tie you up and assist with anything you need - even giving a nice push-off when conditions are appropriate. I generally give $5. If they're both there, I give it to one and tell him to get a beer with his associate. They are always appreciative and I find it to be a small amount of money well spent.
I think here in New England though, we're in a whole different boating world than what you guys described in Florida. There are many small 'mom and pop' type marinas, as opposed to the nautical version of a country club.