DSC radios

Robski97

Active member
Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2002
RO Number
7334
Messages
5,991
Ok i did alot home work and and what i found out disappointed me. This is what I discovered

1) With a DSC radio ur calls are not private. I thought if u made a dsc call u couold talk privately on channel 70. Thast not the case . U initiate ur call then tune to a regular VHF channel.

2) when u send or recive a postion request it comes accross to the radio as as lat and long #'s . NO icon appears on ur GPS .

3) and this is the most upsetting . A DSC distress call also does not appear on the gps . U have to plot the lat and long #'s .

so other then making alot noise when activated. this DSC thing is crap. THE CG and local MArine guys in there 1960 era boats dont have DSC radios .... so what the heck....

Very disappointed ... I thought this was going to be an awesome attribute. sadly im mistaken

Rob
 
i am interested in this as well...is there an expert on this???

i will add another, i am under the impression that it is not fully cabable in most of the united states. there is supposed to be some kind of roll out in the future
 
DSC has been in the commercial world for a long time (only broke into the recreational world when the technology became less expensive). It is part of the Global Maritime Distress and Safety System (GMDSS) and its main purpose has always primarily been for distress signals, both sending and receiving. One advantage is that the DSC reciever is a separate unit (tuned to VHF Ch. 70) that constantly is on alert for either a general (all-ships) calling or ship specific (using an MMSI number) calling. It doesn't depend on the main VHF transceiver. A lot of commercial DSC units are stand-alone with their own antenna and are interfaced to a standard VHF radio. Further advantages are that it does not require voice communications (diminishing the language barrier problem when dealing with foreign vessels), can be directly interfaced to a GPS, doesn't require user attention once activated, gives clear and error-free messages (assuming proper info is fed), keeps automatic logs of all sent and received calls, and with the push of one or two buttons, can be relayed to all ships within range.

Most DSC calls sent and received by ocean-going vessels are on the MF/HF band - very rarely on VHF, although the equipment is there. One useful area where it can be used on VHF is if you're desperately calling another vessel (to make passing arrangements, for example) and their volume is turned down, or they're not on a channel you think they would be. Most AIS units display the MMSI number of a large vessel (assuming that it's input manually by the other ship) and you can simply punch in the number and send them the call with a working (voice) channel to switch to.

It was never intended to open the door to "private" or scrambled communications, although if you digitally call another vessel and select a seldom-used channel for voice comms, you can avoid the "followers" that may overhear your hail on 16 and then switch over to eavesdrop. The point is that you shouldn't expect privacy over the marine VHF band - save those conversations for cell phones. Honestly, IMHO, aside from distress purposes (which requires someone else to actually have a DSC unit), the advantage of such a system to recreational boaters is small, although all modern units are now equipped with it, so you don't have much choice when buying a new radio.

Also, Standard Horizon (and possibly other manufacturers) do offer interfaces between their DSC radios and their GPS chartplotters. If you receive a distress call, it will plot the received position onto your chartplotter.
 
KPMD,
When u read the articles in the boat mags u get the impression that this was the best thing since electricity was invented. Its just not the case.. Of the 5 people who i tried my radio experiments with none of them were able to get a icon on the chartplotter... And the radios ran the gamet...

icoms, raymarine etc...

The installer for my dealer knows of no Radio/ plotter combo that will plot a position on the gps.

Rob
 
My Standard Horizon plotter shows DSC positions on the chart plotter--using the SH chart plotter and SH radio. There is some confusion about class D radios in the US--a radio which scans channel 70 is classified as a class D in the US. A true class D reciever has a separate "watch stander" reciever full time on channel 70. The Intregrated Standard Horizon CPV350 Chartplotter/VHF Radio has both a dedicated reciever on channel 70 and is a chart plotter, so the tech does not even have to hook up the NMEA output and input to the chartplotter and radio.

I have a second radio interfaced with a Lowrance chart plotter, and it does not show the position of the DSC signal. I haven't followed thru to see if I didn't set up the reciever properly or not--but the position is properly sent by the transmitter from this GPS.
 
Rob, I think your installer needs a refresher. My little Garmin 478 will plot the position on the GPS. When receiving a DSC, it will open the DSC page automatically, show you the call and present you with a menu of 3 options: Save as Waypoint, Show on Map, or Delete. This is from a Standard Horizon gx1500 VHF radio. If the 478 does that, I have to think their better models will too.
 
If you do a little MORE homework you will find some DSC VHF/ chartplotter combinations will display a chart icon for the polled vessel as KPMid notes above, but very few offer this feature as of yet. DSC is a very great added feature for emergency communication. If your boat is taking on water or on fire would you rather be calling for help on the radio & explaining the emergency and your boat & position, or would you prefer to be able to use that time to fight the emergency or ready emergency safety equipment? In the case of some other vessel sending a DSC emergency alert, their Lat/Lon position will display on your VHF with no listener hearing or transcription error. That's a good thing. There are also different levels of DSC offered in different radio models.

Please don't post as if this was IM.
 
I would think this raymarine CERTIFIED installer would know his stuff....

As well as the guys who were testing this with me over the weekend.

So now i cut and paste to My dealers installer and see what tune gets sung now ....

Thank you all for the feed back...

Sandy i havent a clue what "Please don't post as if this was IM. " means . If the radio works as people said it should then obviuosly my saying its pretty usless is incorrect.

Rob

Rob
 
Rob, this is probably obvious, but don't forget that in order to show the position on GPS, the VHF signal "out" has to be connected to GPS "in". If you only have it connected one way, the GPS will provide the location for a VHF DSC call, but the radio can't talk back...
 
Joe ,
I was poking around underthere... U cant see sh**#! If i remove the chart plotter as sad as this sounds, it scratches the blk fiberglass finish around the plotter...

So I looked at the book reached my hand underneath and it appears all the radio inputs and outputs are being used ( meaning theres a wire plugged in.) I just cant tell on the back of the plotter.

I emailed the installer and Raymarine. Troubling thing to me is there is nothing in the manual so i may be out of luck...
Rob
 
quote:

Originally posted by Robski97

Sandy i havent a clue what "Please don't post as if this was IM. " means .
Rob





Sandy is referring to your abbreviated words in your posts. On forums, we usually spell out everything as if we are talking, not Instant Messaging....... things like "u" instead of "you", etc.

The CG is rolling out "Rescue 21" which requires DSC one district at a time. The first one was around Miami, FL. The most recent was Seattle, WA. I think the deadline is 2009 to have all districts up and running.......
 
As mentioned, Standard Chartplotters will post an icon when interfaced with a Standard VHF. I'm glad to see Garmin getting into the act as well. However, the primary use of the DSC is safety - automated distress calls. There is also the added feature of calling another boat directly without tying up a hailing frequency. The vast majority of CG boats do have DSC radios and most stations as well.
 
Well then i guess a whole lot people are doing things wrong ( installation wise )

Humm last i checked I didnt get a copy of Sandy rules... Someone furnish me a copy kindly...

Les would i get that at boat fix or was that with my subscription stuff....

Rob
 
Rob, I look at Rescue 21 as a great safety feature, it has to start somewhere, one district at a time and one boat at a time. It has really picked up speed and is operational in many areas. The same goes for VHF radios and chartplotters integrated for DSC installed in pleasure craft. I think Raymarine tech support will tell you what your system is capable of and how to get there if it is possible.
 
Not all VHF radios have NEMA out to a GPS.

What model VHF radio do you have?

And I agree with Sandy...the IM syntax is pretty annoying.
 
Nothing about marine VHF radio and DSC was ever meant to be "private" Rob. Why did you think it was?
In an emergency you wouldn't want it to be private. Even the voice scramblers are not really private.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Robski97

Humm last i checked I didnt get a copy of Sandy rules... Someone furnish me a copy kindly...

Les would i get that at boat fix or was that with my subscription stuff....

Rob






Not a rule that I know of , Rob. It was just meant to be a courteous request from a fellow Offender who finds conventional "English" easier to read to respond to, but then of course you didn't ask a question. Sorry about the capitalized MORE. That came out a little stronger than intended.
 
I guess i wasn't clear in one of my posts when i said " If the radio works as people said it should then obviuosly my saying its pretty usless is incorrect. "

But who reads the small print ...

Bill I was under the impression from what I read That Placing a private call was indeed a private call. Again goes back to my interpetation from what ive read... HYPE vs reality.

In any event no reply as of yet from Raymarine. So we will see

Rob
 
Rob,

Digital calls can be made two different ways - an 'All Ships' call, normally for safety or distress reasons and a station to station call (one vessel calling one other vessel). The latter requires that the sender know the MMSI number of the station he is trying to call. This digital call will only be heard by the station with that MMSI number (every station has a unique number), assuming it is within normal VHF range. When setting up the call, you designate a working channel. After you press 'send', and the message is received by the other station, their unit will usually give an audible signal and display that it has received a message from station 123456789 (MMSI number) and the nature of the message (General or Distress - most DSC units give different audio alarms for a distress or general message to attract your attention differently). Depending on how the receiving stations's radio is setup, it will either display the working channel that was sent or automatically switch to it. The sending radio will usually do the same thing. At this point the digital portion of the process is complete, both radios are on the working channel and you pick up the handset and talk like normal. There are no different provisions for selecting the working channel to talk on. Pick any working channel that you would normally use (68, 69, 71, 72 etc). Channel 70 has been designated as the channel on which the digital signals are sent - no voice comms are to be transmitted on this channel.

In short, yes - a private DIGITAL call (sent to a specific MMSI number) is private and will only be heard by the station with that unique number.

However, the VOICE comms after the call are on normal VHF channels and anyone within range can pick those up.

I hope that makes sense!
 
Back
Top