Electric Boat???

jdshep

Member
exMember
Joined
Jan 26, 2006
RO Number
20051
Messages
241
A while back on a different forum i started a thread asking about the possibility of IPS with electric motors powered by electric generators. I thought this was a good time to start another as GM is showing a new electric car at Detroit auto show, they did that before right? Well this time they are smarter I think, maybe smarter then anyone else so far in the Hybrid business. Unlike all others GM is not making a all electric or a dual powered car. They are making a electric car with a 3 cylinder gas generator that is not hooked to drive wheels. The car can go 40 miles all electric or 640 miles with generator backup. Better yet this car can run many fuels and will charge in 6 hours on a std 110 outlet. Sounds like generator powered boats might be in our future soon.
For those that are happy with displacement speeds there is a all electric solar package on a 35 foot trawler that is quoted as doing 6 nts on sun power with small generator i thik it can do 14 kts.
Link to Island Pilot electric trawler
http://www.islandpilot.com/IslandPilot_Brochure_060906.PDF
So what do you think about the possibilities.
John d
 
I know there are several companies working on this. Most being Diesel electric types. The fundamental problem is still cost to retrofit. I think however it would be far less cost prohibitive in a new installation. One company was talking about $70k
 
One benifit is loading on the diesel is too low if you run your engine at 1/2 speed, where as a generator system would be easier to fully load. also generators could be placed anywhere on the boat giving you a bunch of space. Link to Norhaven on this subject:Nordhaven
http://www.nordhavn.com/constr_con/diesel_electric.php4
The Island Pilot can cruise in sunlight without using any fuel, now that is going to make some people very happy.
Island Pilot
http://www.islandpilot.com/IslandPilot_Brochure_060906.PDF
I don't do much crusing at trawler speeds, but if I went full time that would change, now my time on the water is limited and the wife always wants to get to a port so i travel at 25 mph 90% of the time.
Check out the links they are very interesting, and may point to what is coming.
John d

quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

what would be the benefit and why?




 
Maine Cat is building the first PT 38 which is diesel electric. They are claiming 15 knots with two 35 hp DC electric engines powered by 25 KVA DC generators (OSSA Powerlite diesel-electric )--I am not sure that I see the full value of this. I understand that there is no transmission and one can go from full foreward to full reverse almost instentanously--but I am not sure that it is worth the costs. The PT 38 looks like a most interesting boat--but don't know what the cost will be--my guess is over $400K.

I really wonder how cost effective the solar boats will be? What about a cloudy day. There is the cost of the solar cells, the cost of batteries and electric motors--plus the environmental issues with all of these may be as great as diesel emissions.

As I understand the GM car is at least 5 years away--but that GM was close to a plug in car several years ago and abandoned the project. I now that Edison International (Electrical Utility) had a number of electric plug in cars in their fleet.
 
There was also another company out of TX that was going diesel electric, thats where I got the $70k figure. Their test boat was doing 35k at top speed. This concept however seems better as they are achieving very substantial fuel savings and 15kts is not bad.
 
100 hp is the power typically used to run a mid 30s’ trawler at hull speed. 100 HP is 74.600 Killowats. So it requires 74.6 KWH to power that trawler each hour. That power must be stored in batteries or come from generator fuel.
A 200 AH 6V Golf car battery equals 1.2 KWH so you would need 74.6KW/1.2KW= 62 deep cycle batteries to produce the equivalent of that 100 hp engine and they would be able to produce that power for only one hour. The generator would have to provide all the power to run the boat after the first hour or in any combination of shared load you choose.
 
GM,
Says they could have this new car on the road by 2010 called Chevy Volt. All they need is better litium batteries rest of the parts are stock items. This is not a battery only car with very limited range (it has 640 mile range). The 100 mle range killed the EV-1 all electric. Also this is not a electric drive with a gas drive back up, it is the diesel train engine design, electric motors with a generator, but with added battery only ability for 40 miles it also has 120 mph top end so it is a real car. The 64 miles is on 12 gallons of fuel, more fuel and you keep going I guess. If you work less the 40 miles away and charge at work on std 110 outlet 6.5 hrs recharge then you can drive for pennies. i think EV-1 had to have a custom hookup nonstandard. Food for thought.
John d
As I understand the GM car is at least 5 years away--but that GM was close to a plug in car several years ago and abandoned the project. I now that Edison International (Electrical Utility) had a number of electric plug in cars in their fleet.

[/quote]
 
Bruce,
Check out the two links, especially Nordhavn as that is a really big boat. I know little to nothing, but these guys see something so i will listen.
John d
 
640/12=53mpg. About what a VW diesel rabbit was getting in 1980.
 
Just read some Nordhavn again 72 foot 110000 lbs 9.5 knots 2 mpg on electric, that is amazing (I think). see Nordhavn link above.
John d
 
Bruce can that VW go the first 40 miles on 25 cents of electric? I am sure the VW would be a better choice for many reasons, but tree huggers who work under 40 miles from home are going to want zero emissions they can get with the Chevy Volt electric. I like the idea better for boats, works for ships and trains next small boats, by the time it is here I will be ready to slow down from my 25 mph normal cruise.
John d

quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

640/12=53mpg. About what a VW diesel rabbit was getting in 1980.




 
Well today you can buy the Duffy electric boat http://www.duffyboats.com/
and The ELCO. http://www.elcoelectriclaunch.com/launches.htm
ELCO has been in the electric boat business for OVER 100 years.

I know of one sailboat with solar panels and an electric auxiliary.

For a pleasure boat that could sit in the marina for a week charging it's batteries and then blow it all in a few hours; it's feasible. Compared to a gas engine, though, it's still not cost-effective; but some time in the not-very distant future it probably will be. (Maybe sooner than we think if W bombs Iran...)
 
I think these electric boats are more like the golf cart application, nice but very limited where as the Nordhavn can go around the world getting great mpg and island pilot could do a lot of boating without using any diesel.
John d
 
Bruce, I think a sub 40' trawler at hull speed use far less than 100hp... i know that my 50k lbs 53 footer gets 7 to 8 kts (just under hull speed) with only one engine (325hp) running 1400 rpm. i haven't looked up the power charts but i'm sure that's closer to 50hp then 100...

I think pure solar power is still a dream, or an unpractical experiment. diesel electric though is probably jsut around the corner. Benefits ? many... on my boat, i could fit a second 18kw genset in the genset room under the galley, fit electric engines in the ER and probably recover one of them as an extra stateroom and most of the second one as well ( I have split ERs with 6' headroom and doors into the central companionway). I'd also get far less noise and vibration...

we're not there yet, but i thing we're getting close. it's not for every boat but for the go slow crowd, it's exciting technology

look at ouboards... until rcently they were close to 5k ... look at the price of the electric boats mentioned above (duffy or elco, or the Ray outboards). Now you have Brigs n straton selling an electric outboard for under 2k (fresh water only for now)...

and this : http://www.ecyclemarine.com/eCycleOutboard.html converts a 9.9 yamaha to electric for $2395

or torqueedo... they have 2 versions. 6hp doesnt seem like much but they produce more torque than a 6hp gas outboard...

http://www.torqeedo.com/en/hn/products/cruise/product-description.html
 
many on the engines forums have experimented with running on salt water without sucess.
 
pascal: you may be correct at 50 hP though wind and waves would add to that. Nevertheless, if we accept 50 HP then you could get 2 hours out of the batteries but that doesn’t really change the conclusion that batteries will not successfully power a boat except for the canal cruisers like Duffy that you mention. I dont imagine much interest in a trawler that can go 16 miles and then needs to plug in at a dock.
 
I recently chartered a 41' sailing catamaran with electric auxiliaries (2X12hp) and a 17kw generator. Lagoon, part of the Beneteau group and a maker of catamarans, just came out with a 42' sailing cat powered by electric motors--no diesel even as an option. This looks to be the wave of the future, and it has arrived in the sailing community. Full displacement cruising trawlers could well be the next to benefit from diesel electric propulsion. I spoke with the Island Trader sales reps last fall, and their electric trawler looks interesting.

There are a number of economies gained by switching to diesel electric, not the least of which is a new way of thinking about interior space. Here is a paper that summarizes the efficiencies: http://www.ossapowerlite.com/tech_library/fuel_efficiency/fuel_efficiency.htm

One last thing to keep in mind. Electric motors are being sized between 40% and 70% of a diesel engine in the same application. There are a bunch of reasons why you can get away with this (Pascal nailed a big one), but suffice it to say that you can get equivalent performance from an electric motor with 70% of the rated power as a diesel. The cat that I chartered had an option of 2X30 HP diesel engines. With 40% of the diesel's power, I found the boat cruised at about 7 kts, comparable to her diesel sister. I'm looking forward to next year's charter on an electric Lagoon 420.

Brett
 
Back
Top