Electronics HELP!!!

David M

Active member
Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2005
RO Number
16492
Messages
7,393
I'm on information overload here concerning electronics. There are just so many choices and variables in those choices. All I want is a simple chartplotter that I can add to over time. Actually, I don't even really NEED that as most of my boating is in very well marked channels. It would be nice to have more than a digital LORAN/GPS unit though. Makes plotting the occassional trip out of the norm much easier.

I like the SITEX units. They are reasonibly priced but it only has NMEA 0183. Isn't 0183 like a buggy whip compared to NMEA2000?

I like the Garmn 4208. A bit pricey but has NMEA 2000, but is not CANet compatable.

Raymarine has more series than I have brain cells.

Northstar is the only Smartcraft compatible unit, BUT, Garmin is supposed to have a workaround to convert Smartcraft to NMEA 2000 signals.

AAAAAARRRRRRGGGGGGHHHHHHHH!!!!

HELP!!! Where and how do I start to narrow things down to the simplicity of parallel rules, a sextant and a chart.

TIA.
 
LORAN ? what the heck would you want loran for? what did i miss? can we throw in some 8 tracks and maybe a Betamax while we're at it?

you want simplicity? GARMIN! the best most user friendly interface and excellent charts. Saturday, I was on a sea trial with big twin Furunos and C maps i think... what a POS compared to the garmins. takes longer to figure out the menus, couldn't see some bridges ahead to find the clearance... yikes.

what kind of boat, for your 33 footer? keep it simple on a small boat : a decent plotter (doesn't have to be huge, a good 5" screen do jsut fine), radar and depth is all you need... i like to keep them separate to avoid wasting screen space.
 
David. We are in the process of buying an older boat that has Loran. Right now I plan on Raymarine C-series, one of the smaller displays and for now just GPS and the Sirus weather module. The boat already has an older radar and auto pilot but with the RM stuff if I choose to upgrade later I can.
Good luck
Niles
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

LORAN ? what the heck would you want loran for? what did i miss? can we throw in some 8 tracks and maybe a Betamax while we're at it?

you want simplicity? GARMIN! the best most user friendly interface and excellent charts. Saturday, I was on a sea trial with big twin Furunos and C maps i think... what a POS compared to the garmins. takes longer to figure out the menus, couldn't see some bridges ahead to find the clearance... yikes.

what kind of boat, for your 33 footer? keep it simple on a small boat : a decent plotter (doesn't have to be huge, a good 5" screen do jsut fine), radar and depth is all you need... i like to keep them separate to avoid wasting screen space.






LORAN is what was on the boat when I got it. It's a 1999. It had been on the hard since 2005 and was part of an estate sale. I don't have to tell you how exciting a chart, Lat/Lon, and a pair of binoculars made for an exciting trip home.

I'll keep looking at the Garmins. I had one on the Regal. I liked the fact I could bring it home, hook it to my PC and plot next weeks trips in the comfort of my home instead of in the heat under the canvas. I was also amazed at how much brighter the Garmin was compared to the rest on display at the boat show.
 
I use Garmin. I am waiting on the 4010 unit now. My main unit is the 4212. I have never heard of the work around for SmartCraft. Please let me know where you heard that or saw it.

Bill
 
What's wrong with LORAN? Excellent repeatable accuracy, easier to plot, easier to 'ride a line', et cetera. For precision navigation I'd rather use GPS, but LORAN is still very much useful.

Snob!
 
I've been using the Raymarine C-80 and am haooy with it. Accurate GPC/charts with radar and depth. Matches up nicely with the paper charts. No electronics breakdowns. And everyone's right - hang onto the Loran!
 
I recently switched from Garmin to Lowrance. User interface is similar, price was lower and the unit I bought had an internal hard drive and all maps I will ever need.

Mike
 
David,

Same boat as yours, but the '97 model -- Raymarine C-80 fits nicely and can be added to over time as you wish. I now have it all - GPS/chartplotter, fishfinder (depth), and radar. It interfaces nicely for DSC radios and works with the old Raydata too. Charts have proven very accurate and the unit has been totally reliable.
 
If all you want is a chartplotter use a laptop and a USB GPS. The charts are free, chart programs are cheap, you should be able to get the GPS antenna for about $50, used laptops are not hard to come by and have many other uses as well. In the future when you want to go with a all in one complete boat system the lappy will still have other uses.
 
I like the Lowrance units myself. Be careful if you go with Raymarine. I just bought and returned an A60 unit this weekend - I was lured by the sale price and the larger screen. Apparently there's an issue with WAAS satellites being decomissioned and recomissioned and WAAS no longer works on the A60! Probably why it was on sale! I went back to a Lowrance LMS527. Similar to what I have on my other boat and the interface is nicer than Garmin's (IMHO).
 
Just went thru the same thing. Liked the Raymarine C70 and you could add everything to it but it adds up. I ordered it and ended up canceling when I downloaded the owners manual. To many menus for me to get into. My brain is shot. Ended up with a Garmin 545s A little small but the owners manual was half the size of the Raymarine litterally. Also for the month of April Garmin is giving a 200 rebate if you buy the unit and upgrade to the G2 vision charts. Waiting for mine to come. Like you take occaissonal trips and I think this is all I need. Plus the money is right.
Al
 
NC,
"What's wrong with LORAN?"

At this time, finding a current LORAN receiver is difficult. Also "the powers that be" keep legislating in such a way that the LORAN system ( at least in the US ) is constantly on the "endangered list". And there is the problem: maintainability and longevity.

I agree that LORAN is a desirable system, with strengths and weaknesses different from GPS, making it a useful adjunct to GPS and other more traditional ( Hear that Jim P? ) methods.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

I use Garmin. I am waiting on the 4010 unit now. My main unit is the 4212. I have never heard of the work around for SmartCraft. Please let me know where you heard that or saw it.

Bill






Bill,

Apparantly Mercruiser is taking a lot of heat for their proprietary software and none of the marketing hype they throw at it is making that go away particularly in the NMEA 2000 arena. A fellow I met at the RIC boat show tells me he can get a GArmin 4208 to talk to and display Smartcraft info. I don't know if Merc gave up their code or it was a different standard or what, but he says it can be done.

I don't know if I would be violating BE protocol so I e-mailed you the information.

Labor is comparable to other installers in the area. Component prices are 15% higher that BF so I have a lot of thinking and negotiating to do.
 
I went through the same thing and finally decided to stick with Lowrance. Here are my reasons;
1. Raymarine has too many modules and was too expensive for my budget
2. The screen resolution on the Garmin did not appear as good as lowrance
3. Lowrance has a simple plug and play NMEA 2000 network which was a breeze to install and understand.
4. Lowrance fuel flow meters cost only $50 each and were very easy to install
5. Displaying overlay data on the lowrance is extremely customizable. You can choose different gauge syles etc.
6. Lowrance tech support is very good and they repaired one of my units out of warranty at no charge
7. Updating software on the lowrance unit is very easy
8. Lowrance units accept many NMEA 2000 compatible devices/sensors. I dont know how they deal with smartcraft but the unit software will diplay engine data i.e. RPM's, Temps etc.
9. Lowrance is about to release HD radar at an affordable price
10. Lowrance has built in sonar capability and reasonably priced transducers

IMHO, if your budget is tight then I recommend going with Lowrance or Garmin. If money is no object then go with Raymarine. Below is my current setup. I have a Lowrance LMS-337 and a LCX-37C

lcx37c1.jpg
 
quote:

Originally posted by steffco

If all you want is a chartplotter use a laptop and a USB GPS. The charts are free, chart programs are cheap, you should be able to get the GPS antenna for about $50, used laptops are not hard to come by and have many other uses as well. In the future when you want to go with a all in one complete boat system the lappy will still have other uses.






I've looked into that. The biggest issue is daylight visibility. I am searching for a used MilSpec Panosonic Toughbook. Shy of Davy Jones, those things are about bulletproof.
 
quote:

Originally posted by jbacchi

I went through the same thing and finally decided to stick with Lowrance. Here are my reasons;
1. Raymarine has too many modules and was too expensive for my budget
2. The screen resolution on the Garmin did not appear as good as lowrance
3. Lowrance has a simple plug and play NMEA 2000 network which was a breeze to install and understand.
4. Lowrance fuel flow meters cost only $50 each and were very easy to install
5. Displaying overlay data on the lowrance is extremely customizable. You can choose different gauge syles etc.
6. Lowrance tech support is very good and they repaired one of my units out of warranty at no charge
7. Updating software on the lowrance unit is very easy
8. Lowrance units accept many NMEA 2000 compatible devices/sensors. I dont know how they deal with smartcraft but the unit software will diplay engine data i.e. RPM's, Temps etc.
9. Lowrance is about to release HD radar at an affordable price
10. Lowrance has built in sonar capability and reasonably priced transducers

IMHO, if your budget is tight then I recommend going with Lowrance or Garmin. If money is no object then go with Raymarine. Below is my current setup. I have a Lowrance LMS-337 and a LCX-37C

lcx37c1.jpg







OK...So now there is another player in the mix.

I have not seen one side by side with a garmin to compare resolution, but I trust you at your word.

The prices are better. Seems to have the same features and stuff.

Question. The Lowrance seems to only come from BF with a T/M (transom mounted?) transducer and an antenna.

Can't I use my current transducer or do I need to drill more holes?
 
Your exisiting transducer will not work. I expoxied my lowrance transom mount transducer to the inside of my hull with no issues. The only thing I lost was the abilty to read water temp but thats not a big deal to me. Which unit are you looking at?
 
"If all you want is a chartplotter use a laptop and a USB GPS. The charts are free, chart programs are cheap, you should be able to get the GPS antenna for about $50, used laptops are not hard to come by and have many other uses as well. In the future when you want to go with a all in one complete boat system the lappy will still have other uses."

have you actually tried it? forget a used laptop.. you need a display that's bright enough... and these are expensive.

even in an enclosed pilothouse (50, 60 footers) a standard laptop or standard monitor is useless and near impossible to read when the sun is shining. been there, done that, switched to the Garmin!

on an open express, it's not even worth trying!
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

have you actually tried it? forget a used laptop.. you need a display that's bright enough... and these are expensive.

even in an enclosed pilothouse (50, 60 footers) a standard laptop or standard monitor is useless and near impossible to read when the sun is shining. been there, done that, switched to the Garmin!

on an open express, it's not even worth trying!




I agree
I use laptop & Garmin software & charts in the Pilothouse and it works great but forgetaboutit on the bridge or on an express- there you need a dedicated unit- Garmin would be my choice- very easy to use and the charting is great
 
Back
Top