Engine Size Preference?

jjones

Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2007
RO Number
27557
Messages
207
I'm looking at used boats. So far I am leaning to as near 26' as possible for where I enjoy boating. I could get by with as small as 25' but wouldn't care to go above 28'. I'm looking at small cruisers just to putt around and relax in.

I've heard a few say they prefer Volvo over Mercs. I have no experience with inboard boat engines and base my feelings about them from having used engines of the same size in land based vehicles.

So it looks like most of the inboard / outboards are either the 350 or the 454 GM engines. I've always had great luck with the 350 engines. But I've always found the 454 to be a real gas consumer. I'm not looking for great speed. And I don't want the boat to be underpowered.

I've been looking at the Rinker 266 and I like it a lot. I have also seen some Sea Ray 270 and Cruisers in the same size range that I like.

Given the choice in these or this type of boat what has been your experience with these engines and do you like one better than the other?
 
When you say "Inboard" I think you mean I/O? Also called "sterndrive". Inboards in your size range are usually ski boats such as Mastercraft.......

Your best bet is to drive the boat to see if it comes out of the hole quickly. If it doesn't, it might be underpowered. But other factors can cause it: dirty bottom or running gear; wrong size or damaged prop; no trim tabs; overloaded with gear/water/people. Eliminate these other factors and see if still doesn't pop out of the hole. Then it is probably underpowered.

I have a 350 V6 which is pretty good on fuel [6 gals/hr] but somewhat underpowered for my heavy boat. I've learned all the tricks to improve hole shot. Just one thing out of kilter can make a big difference! The best thing I did was get the trim tabs.

Is the Rinker a Merc or a VP? Rinker is a very good boat. If I had a choice, I would have gotten a VP, but my boat only came with Mercs.......
 
Thanks Flutterby, I meant inboard / outboards and have edited my original post to reflect that.

I was speaking of the 5.7L which I was thinking was a GM 350 block engine. But I could be totally lost here if it's not.

I'm finding Rinkers with both Mec's and VP's .
 
I've had a bunch of boats. There was a lot of good about them all.

I think (on the newer glass boats) I got the most use out of a 24' with twin Merc 140's (four bangers) Remember you can gear down a Mouse to pull a Freight train, so 4-bangers are OK. That boat went 31 Mph.
The newer 4-bangers are even better.
I think Merc's are the least reliable and most expensive POS you could possibly own.

The most those 4 Bangers ever used was 11 Gph, where the 327 Chebby could go as high as 13 Gph all by itself if you got into that 4-Bbl.
I borrowd a Truck that had a 454 which got 3 Mpg. BS on crap like that.
I personally think that if your designer thinks you need a couple of 454's, you really need a diesel!

When you spend some time on these boards you begin to see that the GM 350 is a great little engine. Also the Dirt Track racers and lots of other racers really like it.
The Merc part is what makes it bad.

For room in the Boat, I think If I ever have another large boat again, it will be a single engine in-board.
I like that open back deck for fishing. There were only a couple times, in all the years I had I/O's that I felt like all that trouble and expense was worth the benefit.
 
I have a 2006 Rinker 250EC with the Merc 350mag 300hp MPI motor and Bravo III outdrive and its just a fantastic power package. My previous boat was a 2002 Rinker 242 with a 250hp 5.7(350 CI)carburated with an alpha drive(single prop) and it was a dog getting on plane and it burned 30% more gas than the 350magMPI. Several things are at play here: for a 25' to 27' boat you need either a dual prop or a Bravo II prop for the better hole shot and better torque, I wouldn't get anything less than 260hp for a boat this size, and after having a MPI motor I would never ever get a carburated engine again. Both Merc and Volvo use the same GM blocks and its just personal choice. I go with Merc because there are more certified mechanics in my area and parts are a little cheaper and easier to get. Also, a dual prop will give you better handling in reverse as it negates the paddle wheel effect you get with a single prop. The single biggest complaint people have after they buy a boat is that its under powered.
 
In my opinion, you are best to have the highest HP your boat is designed for.
I fished offshore on a center console boat for years until I had a back injury.
The boat I bought came with the max. HP engine the boat was designed for.
I had several friends who went with undersized engines because of the cost savings.
Their boats actually burned almost twice the gas as mine did.
My cousins husband did the same thing with a bay boat. He ended up spending more
money buying a bigger engine. The boat ran good when new, with no load in it.
When he put in ice, drinks, 3 people and fishing equip., it was a dog.
 
<<...."The single biggest complaint people have after they buy a boat is that its under powered."....>>

<<..."In my opinion, you are best to have the highest HP your boat is designed for."...>>

Read the above 2 quotations and heed that advice. Yes, the big blocks burn it faster, but you'll also be going faster. Or, you can choose to go the same speed with the big block as you would with the small block, but you'll be a lot easier on the engine. It'll last longer, and the big block will resell for more.

There are cases where you'll get better fuel economy with the big blocks if the samll blocks have to be really pushed hard to perform.
 
Since all you want to do is putt around, you might look at direct-drive inboards. They're easier than a single prop alpha to park. They're also simpler and cheaper to work on, unless you hit something with the running gear.

I wonder if anybody has done a test comparing efficiency at hull speeds. I would think the greater drag of the inboard running gear might not be a factor at hull speeds. I would also think the straight inboard would be more efficient at lower speeds by swinging larger diameter props. However, the difference between the two might not be significant at engine speeds that low. BTW this is pure speculation. Sorry for the thread hijack.
 
I pretty much have to agree with blueflew, except I run a Volvo with the Duo Prop. It is kinda like the age old debate over which truck is better, Chevy or Ford. Both are good, which one do YOU like?
My boat is a 24ft. that came with the 280HP fuel injected engine. My neighbor has a 28ft with a 260HP Merc. with a Alpha drive. Night and day difference. His is a dog with fleas. Without trim tabs, I don't think you could get it on plane. His fuel consumption is twice what mine is.

Now let me address the question a little differently, It is not the horsepower that is needed on a boat, it is torque! The larger the engine, the more torque it produces. The length of the boat, along with the weight, should be the deciding factor. A 25 ft. bow rider would be fine with a 300HP with a Bravo 3 or a Duo Prop. A 28ft. or longer cabin cruiser would be better equipped with a 454/496/502 big block engine. It takes more torque to get the larger, heavier boat to perform as it was designed to.

Ken
 
For single engine in the size boats you are considering, it is a must to have duo props. Also the beam will add to the drag. And anything weighing more than 6000lbs should have a big block.

I guess I said the same thing as mud...
 
Maybe....I used a John Deere tractor (430) with a Two cylinder engine turning 2800 Rpm.
That's it. 2800 Rpm.
Idle's at 2800 and works at 2800.
It'l plow all day on Seven gallons of Gasoline.

It's a long stroke torquer!
If you could somehow get that kind of stroke in a small block, you would get better power for the same fuel consumption of the performer engine.
What's that you say? No hole shot? Hey boy, you aint lived till you've done a wheelie sitting up there on that tractor.

Someone tried to sell me the 502 conversion for my Ford 460. That has a stroker crank (I dont know how they do it either) but the Rpm's are not limited.
What you want for power and fuel efficiency is the long stroke slow engine with the Hi Torque cam.
No! I dont know which engine that would be.
 
As the old saying goes, "There is no replacement for displacement."
 
If I was looking for a new boat in the 26' range I would try to find one with a pair of outboards. I am not sure if they are making these in the non=fishing category.

Why outboards? First, I love redundancy. Mainly because the whole boat is much simpler if you do not have an engine(s) buried under your feet. You do not have to crawl around in tight spaces to do repairs. Winterizing is very simple. You do not way where you are. Flushing after salt water use is much simpler. You physically separate the fuel tanks and the engines. No raw water filters to have to keep clean. I could go on and on.

Today's top of the line outboards are probably more fuel efficient than either straight inboards or I/O's. I/O's are more fuel efficient than straight drives.

G
 
I'm listening to all this great advice and I really appreciate it all. Thank you.

I'm not going to get in too big a hurry to buy the next boat.

I actually had a 26' with twin 225 Johnsons but it was a fishing rig center console. Now everyone in my mob wants something to lay around and be comfortable in. So far all the best choices seem to be way up North. I'll keep looking around.
 
Hah! You KNOW that's gonna mean something over 28' and twin engine. That's the difference between young and able to brave the elements and older when all your parts need more comfort.
 
Last boat was around a 27'-28', 6000+ lbs. It had a Bravo II with 7.4 carburated. My friend owns it now. It runs like a champ. It is used on an inland lake and performs very nicely. Yes, it would be even better with a DP or Bravo III, but there are no performance issues with it. That would be a whole other story with a small block.

Paul
 
Had 24' Wellcraft with Mercruiser 7.4 Bravo I and now have Monterey 248 (which is 26') with Volvo 5.7 gxi dp. Power is fine with 10 people on board but certainly no watersports. With 6/7 people watersports are fine. Top speed I would guess is upper 40's as I don't have a gps. The speedo shows 53 mph with 2 on board and 1/2 fuel but I think that is not accurate. I write with regard to fuel efficiency. My larger Monterey is quite a bit faster on plane than the Wellcraft with the 7.4 and the fuel consumption is very very much better. I don't keep precise stats but after the 7.4 I feel like I am not using any fuel by comparison. I am usually out with 6 adults on board and cruising on the outside in South Florida. Top speed very similar with both boats.
 
quote:

Originally posted by spd

Had 24' Wellcraft with Mercruiser 7.4 Bravo I and now have Monterey 248 (which is 26') with Volvo 5.7 gxi dp. Power is fine with 10 people on board but certainly no watersports. With 6/7 people watersports are fine. Top speed I would guess is upper 40's as I don't have a gps. The speedo shows 53 mph with 2 on board and 1/2 fuel but I think that is not accurate. I write with regard to fuel efficiency. My larger Monterey is quite a bit faster on plane than the Wellcraft with the 7.4 and the fuel consumption is very very much better. I don't keep precise stats but after the 7.4 I feel like I am not using any fuel by comparison. I am usually out with 6 adults on board and cruising on the outside in South Florida. Top speed very similar with both boats.






Thanks. That is helpful.
 
Back
Top