Engine will not turn over??

Joined
Jul 2, 2007
RO Number
27141
Messages
14
I have a well cared for 2005 Bayliner 225BR that has provided our family countless hours of trouble free fun and relaxation. It has a 5.0 carbed Merc with Alpha1 G2. Last took it out 2 weekends ago and had no problems except the last time I went to start for the trip home I noticed the engine did not turn over immediately. I did not think much of it because when I turned the key again it started right up. I thought I just did not turn it far enough the first time.

Saturday, did all my normal prep, dropped her in the water, turned the key and NOTHING. Had my wife, 2 daughters, 2 sisters, their husbands and their 3 kids all waiting to head out for a day of fun (don't worry the boat is rated for 11 people and all the kids have life jackets on at all times). What a disappointment. We did basic troubleshooting at the ramp (fuses, connections, kill switch, neutral, etc...) and nothing. Every time I turn the key I can hear 1 click from the engine area but that is it. It will not turn over at all. I have experienced low battery before (not on this boat) and some times you hear click, click,click,click, etc...., not I am not getting that. Just one click.

Looking at my gauges, the battery gauge dives way down when I turn the key, so I know something is trying to happen, but it is not. All the accessories (lights, radio, horn, blower, etc....) work fine. Today I took the battery out and took it to Advanced auto Parts. They checked it and it is fine so the battery is definitely not the problem.

Please help! Any ideas?

Thanks
 
sounds to me like the starter solinoid did you check the wire to the starter as well as it can also come loose
 
I think the batter may be weak. Did you try jumper cables or jumper pack?
 
I had a similar problem a year ago. I don't have my manuals here, but there are two starter relays on most boat engines. It is an easy fix you just replace it. Apparently the contacts in the relay will get burned spots on them and they won't connect. Contact boatfix and they can tell you what it may be.
 
starter relay, solenoid or maybe a short in the starter. since the problem started gradually, i think that the most likely cause. It coudl also be a seized/hydrolocked engine that prevents the starter from cranking but i doubt it considering that you had intermittent warning signs. Check with a voltmeter if you get power to the leads going to the solenoid while the key is turned.

since you get a click on the starter, it's not the key switch

Sometime a tap on teh starter or solenoid (with a hammer) can get you going, otherwise jut pull the starter and get it rebuild at an alternator/starter shop. Dont' be tempted to use a automotive starter which is not ignition protected.

There is a good starter shop in south miami, off US1 next to the Uhaul before sunset dr. they rebuilt one of my diesel starters last year. that was thebest i found unless you want to venture to hia-low-ah :-)
 
With the key on,and ready to start, jump across the two large terminals with the handles of a pair of pliars.
It will start right up for you. Never mind all the sparks and noise.
If it does, go get another start relay.
 
Could be any number of things but stay with the basics first...go to the source: BATTERY. It could be as simple as corroded or loose battery cables. After checking cables, try to jump start it (eliminating a weak battery). From there I'd suspect starter problems like a solenoid or starter. While someone is holding the key in the start position, smack the starter with a hammer and see if it starts cranking. This indicates a bad spot on the starter armature which means new starter. Good luck
 
Thank you all for the replies.

- Blouderback, it is definitely not the battery . I had it tested and it is fine, plus yes I did try jumping it and same result.

- I am heading to the boat later this afternoon and will check solenoids and relays as suggested. Hopefully that is it as it seems an easy fix.

- If it is not those things I will check the starter as Pascal suggested. I am pretty sure the engine is not hydrolocked.

Again thank you all and if anyone has any pictures of solenoids or relays it would be very helpful.
 
Also before buying any parts, clean with a wire bruch and grease all battery terminals, starter wire connections etc.
 
Hernando,

The click you hear could be the starter slave solenoid. Try to jump by connecting red/pur and yel/red wire on the slave solenoid. That will energize your starter motor solenoid and consequently your starter motor. That slave solenoid has been my problem on regular frequency. Boatfix has that for $32.00.
 
The clicking you hear is the solenoid. It uaually happens when not enuff power is getting to the starter. Either from bad battery or bad connections. Since batt is good, do as Glenn said, remove ALL battery cables and clean them. Don't forget the ground wire to the block as well as the cables to the starter and solenoid.
 
You have a GM Delco style starter which has a solenoid on top that also engages the drive gear. That one MIGHT be bad, but it's usually the second solenoid described above, called "Slave" by many, that sits in the metal junction box atop your engine. The box with the pushbutton circuit breaker in it. They fail all too often and sometimes charging the battery will allow it to engage till the battery comes back down to a normal voltage. THAT's where I'd be looking, but check every connection including grounds first.
 
Just listen to the guy with the self-proclaimed Anchor and you"ll be nuts before it"s over.
 
Well here is the update.... I went out to the boat and cleaned and checked some of the connections with a test light. It appears the connections I checked are fine, but I still cannot get it to turn over. I was not able to spend as much time on the boat as I wanted as a typical South Florida afternoon thunderstorm was brewing and I did not want to get zapped.

DSCF3415_edited.jpg


Next problem is where is the starter solenoid and the starter? It was definitely not anywhere obvious and easy to get to.

DSCF3399.jpg
 
The little circled solenoid on the left in the upper pic is the one several of us are calling a culprit. Close to the circuit breaker as I thought. The circled item on the right is the ignition coil.

Engine starter, with Delco solenoid on top, is low on the after starboard side of the engine, below the exhaust manifold, near the rear motor mount. Opposite the oil filter low on the after port side.
 
Thanks for the reply JD. That is where I was afraid the starter is. How is any human (over the age of 5) supposed to get back there to test / replace a starter solenoid or starter?
 
I could trouble shoot that starter in a minute, but it would take a lot longer to learn that kind of PC expertise to put those photos in with the little circles and the writing.

You still havent jumped across the two large terminals on the Relay to see if the Starter will turn!

You can see all the corrosion in those photos. Thats what I was talking about when I said in another post : "be prepared to spend a lot of money..." about bying a boat in FLorida.
 
Thudpucker, by relay do you mean the slave solenoid? If so, I did "jump" them with a pair of pliers. Got sparks but no engine turn over.
 
There's a reason ALL the connections have to be removed and wire brushed and cleaned. There can easily be enuff of a contact(in a connection) to register 12 volts on an Amp/Volt meter or run a test light but not even close to be able to draw the high amps needed to turn a starter.

75% of the time it's a bad connection. 25% of the time it's the solenoid.
 
Back
Top