Ethanol suit in Ca

Riverratt

Member
Joined
Feb 25, 2004
RO Number
12842
Messages
542
Interesting:

Ethanol suit filed on behalf of boat owners in Calif.

A California law firm this week filed a class action lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles , alleging oil companies failed to inform boat owners that ethanol causes damage to fiberglass fuel tanks.

The suit seeks to represent a class comprising all owners of boats with fiberglass fuel tanks who filled their tanks with ethanol-blended gasoline from a California retailer. The suit also seeks to represent all persons in California who own boats with fiberglass fuel tanks that had to be replaced because of damage caused by ethanol-blended gasoline bought from a California retailer.

The lawsuit, filed by Kabateck Brown Kellner, LLP, names major oil companies, including Chevron and Exxon Mobil Corp., as defendants.

Chevron said it has not yet been served with the lawsuit.
“As such, we are not in a position to comment," said Lloyd Avram, Chevron media relations team leader.

Exxon did not return phone calls for comment.
According to court documents, Lawrence Turner, the plaintiff, bought ethanol-blended gasoline for his boat, which had a fiberglass fuel tank. Turner then discovered the ethanol in the gasoline began dissolving the boat's fiberglass fuel tank and caused damage to the boat's engine. The court documents said Turner was “forced to spend approximately $20,000 to fix the problems caused by the defendants' ethanol blended gasoline."

"The price of gas is bad enough, but selling gasoline that dissolves gas tanks is a new low even for the oil companies," said Brian Kabateck, managing partner of Kabateck Brown Kellner and the lead attorney on the case, in a statement. "The oil companies know this fuel is corrosive, but they're keeping consumers in the dark to pump up their profits. The cost to the consumer is thousands of dollars in repairs."

Bob Adriance, technical services director for BoatU.S., told Soundings Trade Only, “I think the attorneys do have a case. I think the case against the oil companies regarding fiberglass tanks has plenty of merit."

He added, “It's well known in the oil industry that some fiberglass tanks can be damaged by ethanol."

Ethanol attracts water. When enough water is absorbed by the ethanol-blended gasoline, the ethanol and water solution separates from the gasoline, with the gasoline floating to the top. This results in a layer of water with a high concentration of ethanol at the bottom of the fuel tank.

There are many underground storage tanks that are made of fiberglass, but these were developed specifically to withstand ethanol, Adriance said. The vast majority of fiberglass tanks on boats were not designed to withstand ethanol.

“Should the oil companies have know that?" Adriance asked. “I think the attorneys can make the case that they should have."

- Lois Caliri
Editor
 
as much as i agree with this,i believe all fiberglass fuel tanks made from the mid/late 80s onward were made with resins that are not affected by ethanol. So only tanks that are 20+ years old are affected.

that's probably going to be the defense used by the oil companies... the benefits outweigth the replacement costs on a few boats.

just playing devil's advocate.
 
If I were on the jury, I'd think the Oil companies were not under any obligation to consider what material a consumers fuel tank is constructed of.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

as much as i agree with this,i believe all fiberglass fuel tanks made from the mid/late 80s onward were made with resins that are not affected by ethanol. So only tanks that are 20+ years old are affected.






Depends on who you ask as to what the cut off date is. I have seen so called "experts" claim anything after 1985, then some claim that 1988 was the cutiff, and even others claim around 1992.

Even more so than the fuel tanks, is older fuel lines, which ethanol will make swiss cheese of in no time.
 
it will vary by builders but altogether a small number of builders have use fiberglass tanks... most use alum. which often after 15 years is also due for replacement anyway

same with fuel lines, they shoudl be replaced every 5 to 10 years, ethanol shouldn't be a big concerns there. if someone has 15 year old lines, they should worry regardless of gas formulation
 
What about the EPA wich has mandated the use of ethanol. The oil companines are only complying to the EPA.
 
Should be interesting. A member of congress had to have the same thing done to his Moppie to the tune of about 23-30K.
 
Pascal:

What people "should" do for maintenance on older boats, and what is "actually" done, is a huge disconnect.
 
Is replacing the Fuel Tank considered normal maintenance?
 
Okay....and I guess there's ALOT of other reasons to have to replace a Fuel Tank. It;s comments like this that are making me seriously consider NOT renewing my Anchor though and just going adrift. The question was wether or not a Replacing a Fuel Tank would be considered Normal and Routine Maintenance. Not wether to replace or to NOT replace if it has a hole in it.
 
When I had to have my engine block replaced in 1998, I had them replace all rubber with the upgraded product available at that time. $200 more well spent!
 
The oil companies will claim that is why they should be using methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE) instead of ethanol. And that the boaters are responsible for the pollution of the ground water supplies.
 
I believe virtually all boats will have to replace the tank at some time. I also believe tank replacement SHOULD have a MINIMUM of a 15 year cycle. Many boats require that decks, bulkheads, etc. be sawsalled out. That to me is not routine maintenance.
Al
 
MTBE HAS alcohol in it.

A better suit would be to sue the state to provide RED gas to boats. We DON'T use the highways so why should we pay ROAD taxes.
 
replacing fuel tank is not routine maintenance, jsut like replacing or rebuilding engines, generators, trannies and outdrives isnt' either.

but, like everything else in most cases they have certain life expectancy. 95% of boats have alum tanks and 15 years is probably the how long they last on average. a little more if they are installed correctly and kept dry and if you never had water in them... but unfortunately, it's not unusual to hear of tank failures before that...

So while it's a real shame to have to replace perfectly good fiberglass tanks that woudl other wise last the life of the boat, i dont' think this plaintiff is going to get a lot of sympathy...
 
Charlie that's a good thought. I think it's the right answer, and good reasoning as well.
 
Nissan 'voluntarily' replaced all the 1980s Z car fuel injectors and lines that dissolved and leaked fuel (and caught fire) when they had incompatible rubber with the new reformulated fuel. Nice little perk in my 10 y.o. Z at the time.
 
The law requiring ethanol blend has a get out jail free card for the oil companies. They are smart enough to know that when the goverment meddles in their gas formula to protect themselves. A similar thing happened when the California Air Resources board some years ago reformulated diesel in California. The result was thousands of damaged injector pumps for which the California taxpayer paid, and paid. I suspect that ultimately the lawyers in this case know that, and the taxpayers are going to get the bill on this one.
 
Okay....Now let me ask a question.
Let's assume you have a 50 gallon Gas Tank in your Boat......(aluminum)
You fill it up with Gas.....you use 45 gallons of it. Is there anything that a person could add to the remaining 5 gallons to preserve it till the next usage?
Also.....HOW exactly does this new E=10 Gas harm the engines? Is the water that it absorbs? And if that's the case....what's happening to all the car engines out there with this fuel in them? Wasn't this Ethanol Blend originally also supposed to be a bit less expensive to the consumer?
 
Back
Top