those sahara arent' that good, I had one that lasted a few month in my tender. get rid of it and get a rule with sep. swithc.
as to your bilge pump, the switch should keep the pump going even fully up! makes no sense otherwide, think about it. if you get a real leak the switch kills the pump?
yo cant' fix those switches, just get a new one. If you really want to be cheap (and maybe have to explain it all to your insurer) put a stop on the switch to stop it from going to high... ok in a bind, otherwise just replace the switch!