Fuel for thought

Michael Koch

Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2005
RO Number
17011
Messages
11
With the price of fuel, I have been looking at Hydrogen generators. From what I can find out they work best on carb. engines. They will work on fuel inj. but you need additional equipment. 02 sensor.
They need to produce at least 3 L. per min. of HHO. Some of the units will produce that and more. 3.7L per min. Milage increase is 30% to 60%. So if your engines are using 1 gal per mile, then an increase of .5 is possible. On a 200 gal boat that is and increase of 100 miles. The units that only need water added and no cleaning are what a person would look at. Also amp usage. Nothing more than 20 amps 15 would be better. Some units as they heat up use more amps. Also you would have to look at the amount of heat the unit puts out. If it is a plastic unit it can become hot enough to melt the plastic. I know Hydrogen is very explosive, but remember it will not go into the bulge, (lighter than air) Also if you run your engines at lower RPM this will keep the engine cleaner also they will run cooler. It works on Diesel as well as gas. The cost would be around a $1000 for both engines.
I put this out there to see what everyone thinks?

I have a friend who has built a Hydrogen Gen. Was at a farm show and there was a booth set up selling them. He went on the internet and found info on building his own an gave it a try. It did produce HHO, but not enough. .75 L per min. He had cut a few corners in the construction. This unit also produced a lot of heat, and as the heat went up so did the amp draw. If you google Hydrogen Generator or go to you tube, there seems to be a lot of people out there working on this. I have no idea if a HHO gen. is at the point where it has become something that can help. I have seen some HHO gen. use a pulse system to produce more HHO gas than a steady current system does. The pulse uses less amps and runs cooler I believe.
I have more questions than answers.
 
"They need to produce at least 3 L. per min. of HHO."

HHO = dihydrogenmonoxide = H2O = water. So you are saying that you add water and electricity and it produces water, which you inject? ( water injection has in the past served a useful function in gasoline internal combustion engines ) or is this something else?

I honestly don't know what you are discussing, but it sounds like you believe the marketing department, rather than actual sound chemistry, physics and engineering. IMO. Nothing is for free, and this sounds a lot like a perpetual motion machine.

Without far more info, that is about the best I can do.
 
HHO or Browns Gas requires more energy to generate than it produces.
There are several companies hawking this add on for over the road diesel trucks.

Smoke and mirrors if you ask me.
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

WTF?




And this post helps how?

Is this different than being “intrigued” with the idea of a bilge blower turbocharger?

One who gives rude replies to others who appear serious, cannot claim insult when others are rude to them for same.
 
from the wikipedia entry that covers the subject, "The HHO trademark is associated with an unproven state of matter called magnegases, and a discredited theory about magnecules,[12] which is the basis for a number of fraudulent claims, and third party water-fuelled car scam attempts."

This entry leads me to skepticism...
 
Bill,

I share the skepticism.

I did google "Hydrogen generators" and found lots to read. Can't fault a guy for hoping :)
 
There are a lot of discussions about separating hydrogen from water then burning it with oxygen. Yes it's that simple you separate the water then burn the products to make water again. Sort of like pumping water up a hill then running a generator to make power as it falls back. Both have the same result. You put energy into the first step and get it back from the second. How much energy?? the exact amount you put in or less if there are conversion losses. These hydrogen scams all promise the impossible; an almost instant creation of a higher energy state with better than 100% result. This is another perpetual motion scheme
All energy cycles are cyclical, you first create the higher energy state then burn the result and get out the stored energy. The time between the creation and use determines whether or not we see the creation cost. If we don’t see it the creation cost the higher energy state just seems to exist, its “free” in our reference time frame. If we do see the creation cost as with hydrogen then that cost is always equal or greater than the energy released when we burn the product. “Free energy” such as coal or oil or nuclear comes from high energy state creation processes that took too long to be meaningful to us so we don’t see the creation cost just the distribution cost.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Estimator

quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

WTF?




And this post helps how?

Is this different than being “intrigued” with the idea of a bilge blower turbocharger?

One who gives rude replies to others who appear serious, cannot claim insult when others are rude to them for same.








I sincerely apologize to all who I may have offended. I meant to say, "Gee this sounds quite interesting, but I am somewhat skeptical. Can someone explain this in more detail?", but I was in a hurry and figured that "WTF" would get my point across just as well.
 
Just start drilling the ANWR and off the coast of Florida. Simple solution to use our own oil.
 
I need to pay off my credit card bills for hair restorers and enlargers before I can consider this. Of course, when the money comes in from Nigeria...

Bruce, well stated fundamentals. Too bad it hasn't been applied to corn-ethanol production.
 
quote:

Originally posted by RichC

I need to pay off my credit card bills for hair restorers and enlargers before I can consider this. Of course, when the money comes in from Nigeria...

Bruce, well stated fundamentals. Too bad it hasn't been applied to corn-ethanol production.






Here we go again. Trying to shove logic into anything coming from the beltway.

You got the Nigerian money e-mail too? I know mine is real because the author has a middle initial.
 
Recently it has, sort of. The politicians and liberal media with heavy support of the corn lobby didn’t want to understand the full cost of ethanol. Folks like to ignore the total start to finish cost of their favorite "free lunch" process. They avoid the hard work of actual details and focus on faith claiming opponents of the latest save the planet scam are somehow the ignorant ones. The full cost analysis was ignored for years as ethanol became a matter of faith rather than economic business analysis. Now that the unvarnished truth has finally become obvious the ignorant and uneducated Pollyannas in congress and their media friends are running for the hills. Then they jump on some new free lunch idea such as hydrogen and hoping, with much supporting evidence, that the uneducated masses will forget their recent failures and follow them to the next feel good idea.
Ever wonder why Archer Daniels Midland, ADM, is so well subsidized and boon docks Iowa the first primary??
 
I've read alot of post that had "WTF" in them, but not one reply saying it was rude until now. Sorry, I know this doesn't add anything to the org post
 
The fallacy of all this was demonstrated on air last night with a very sincere person saying that the proteins of corn are not used, only the starches, but could not say what all the byproducts are used for.

Conversely the amount of ethanol that can be derived from potato crops and from sugar cane are far higher, just look to the vodka and rum industries.
Caribbean islands that cannot sell sugar could sure benefit from selling ethanol, and the byproducts could be burned to produce steam and electricity that supports the manufacture of the product or pumped into the local grid.
I have been on these big sugar plantations and toured the sugar factories. They are already doing most of the work on site and could easily add ethanol production to the mix.
There is no end to the closed sugar factories down there due to the lower demand for sugar.
 
Take a look at you tube site. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jcy3JbGjQwo&feature=related
The friend I was talking about who built a hydrogen generator, is now looking at becoming a dealer for these Hyd. Gen. He is not building them, but will purchase the units from another company, backed by a warranty, and satisfaction or your money back. I sure hope he is not being taken for a ride. He is going to put one on his Diesel truck and car. I will let you know how things turn out. Flimflam or fact.
 
My Dad always said, "There's no such thing as a free lunch", and my high school physics teacher, Mr. Finkbinder, taught me that energy can neither be created or destroyed.

Basically, he'll be able to free up the Hydrogen in the water, but it will take as much (and probably more) energy to do it. The net effect will be zero energy "created".
 
From Wikipedia:

Lawsuit
In 1996, inventor Stanley Meyer was sued by investors to whom he had sold dealerships, offering the right to do business in Water Fuel Cell technology. According to The Times, Meyer claimed in court that his invention "opened the way for a car which would 'run on water', powered simply by a car battery."[1] The car would even run perpetually without fuel since the energy needed to continue the "fracturing" was low enough for the engine's dynamo to recharge the car's battery.[1] His car was due to be examined by the expert witness Michael Laughton, Professor of Electrical Engineering at Queen Mary, University of London and Fellow of the Royal Academy of Engineering. However, Meyer made what Professor Laughton considered a "lame excuse" on the days of examination and did not allow the test to proceed.[1] The Water Fuel Cell, on the other hand, was examined by three expert witnesses in court who found that there "was nothing revolutionary about the cell at all and that it was simply using conventional electrolysis".[1]

On the basis of the evidence the court found Meyer guilty of "gross and egregious fraud" and ordered to repay the investors their $25,000.[1]
 
we have expermented with a few engines on pure hydrogen we basicaly used a propane system tweeked a few issues may keep it out of marine use a bit off on mixture and it will backfire with a lot of energy blew the intake hose off and its very hard to see a hydrogen flame i don,t think we will ever see a pressurized fuel system in a boat the resulting bang when things go wrong is way more powerful than gasoline (note we had a hydrogen fire at a tank fitting you could only see heat waves and feel heat could not see a thing in day light)
 
Back
Top