Garmin GPS

ALKA2710

Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2007
RO Number
25407
Messages
670
Just installed a Garmin 545s and used for the first time this weekend. Problem is the track is not right. It shows my boat in the marsh when I am a good 75 ft away. How acurate should it be and is there some type of adjustment i can make to correct this.
Al
 
I'll bet a glass of tap water that the problem is not the GPS, but the chart.

Part (1):
Most charts are comprised of data accumulated over time, and the "non-essential" data ( meaning that it does not affect commercial shipping ) is rarely updated. The base charts for my area, from which the digital chart chips are derived, contain data from pre-Civil War soundings.

Part 2:
Yes, there is "error" in GPS data. Though there is always error, how much is determined by a number of things, including the number of satilites "in use", atmospheric conditions and several others. WAAS and DGPS reduce these effects, and an error of less than 3 meters is common. But you should expect errors of +/- 10 meters. ( +/- 33 feet ).

---

All in all, the perceived error is most likely in the chart, not the GPS, but in any event, being off by 75 feet should not be considered to be an indication of an equipment problem, but much more likely a) being within bounds, and b) possibly because your unit cannot see enough satellites at that time or c) the base chart contains more errors than you ever imagined.
 
Agree with Bill, but make sure that you have WAAS turned on.
 
What mapset are you using? Blue Charts? The basemap?

I have found basemaps to be less than accurate, but the Blue Charts are usually dead on.

Al

aka FlyWright
 
As well as making sure WAAS is enabled in your menu settings, check to see if your chartplotter menu settings match the chartware datum source, most likely "WGS 1984". That said , Garmin's Mapsource, as most other chartware, does have a few glitches. A friend's Garmin 182C w/ Bluechart Americas often shows him cruising along on the hard when he is safely in the narrow Menemsha Creek channel. This can be tad disconcerting in dark of night or soup of fog.

Many/most?GPS chartplotters have menu user-settings available to correct for offset, but I would fear correcting for one small locale may create perceived or displayed error elsewhere.
 
Al, the "base maps" I am referring to are the official NOAA nautical charts. In your area, especially if you travel in an area of valuable commercial traffic ( and/or high maritime population ) those charts may, in fact be more accurate. In most areas, esp. those with little or no large vessel traffic and relatively low population, they simply draw accurate channels onto very, very old charts. They then label it "official", and the digital chart companies create the digital versions from -that- data. Sure, each brand of digital has it's own strengths and weaknesses, but if the source data is 150 yrs old, and you are talking about a swamp ( which changes rather fast, actually ), then there are, and will be, many, sometimes large, errors.

Two quick examples, from my area: If you travel the center of the Jourdan river, from the mouth to I-10, about 1/2 of your trip will, according to the chart, be overland. ( the river has changed course over time ). Another is traveling through Cat Is channel: You can, in fact, travel a straight line from Pass Christian harbor, to Freemason Is. But the chart will show you crossing over the swamp. For the past 30 or so years, the swamp has receded, and the entire rout has plenty of water ( which around here, means 6' min at lower of low tide ). And any GPS-based chartplotter will faithfully show your overland travel...
 
where are you located? you sig says Freeport, is that freeport bahamas? if so, I 've seen 100' chart errors there.

before messing with the offset, make sure you are using the right datum. I think it's not the same in the bahamas. check the charts and set it right in the plotter
 
Lots of knowledge on this site. I boat out of Freeport Long Island and am using the Blue Water Vision G2 charts for my area.
Al
 
My guess the chart. It costs money to resurvey/update an area and while ship channels and harbors are pretty high on Uncle's list, a lot of the places WE hang out are not. Some haven't been updated in 20, 30 or more years (before GPS or even Loran)
 
I have the 540s. Similar specs. This is from the manual.

gpsaccuracy.jpg


We're using the G2 chips which seem pretty accurate. There are a few areas when zoomed in <50' it goes wonky where there's data overlaps. We added the external antenna which helps a lot with satellite acquision. I've seen avg 9 sats with excellent signal strength.
 
I agree, it's most likely the charts. My 188C plotter/sounder frequently shows me on land, when I am quite comfortably in the river channel. I was pretty dissapointed after spending so much money. I first purchased the BlueChart CD and data card programmer. This I found didn't cover the Erie Canal, Mohawk River, only the Hudson River. I then purchased the pre programmed data card that covered the Erie & Champlain Canals. I was really excited as it showed the correct buoys, and depths just like the paper charts. The only problem was the chart error. The display is real nice, and mostly accurate, but the depths are mostly wrong, and due to the fact that the river ever so slowly changes course and marshes fill in, or wash away, I sometimes see these obvious errors.
 
I agree with Pascal, check your datum. I'm not sure what Garmin uses, we correct all C-Map chart datum to WGS84 in the Americas.

Next, check to be sure you have the most current chart data Garmin has released for that area, possibly a new chart edition has been released with corrections. Once again, I'm not sure how often Garmin updates their data, but we update our data internally in real-time (NTM's, new chart editions, etc.) and release fully updated worldwide C-Map NT, NT+ and MAX libraries to the public twice annually.

If you're still finding a 75' offset (which is a lot if you're WAAS enabled) you should report the error to Garmin. Once again... not sure how they handle it but we would compare it to the paper charts to confirm where the error originates. It's more likely the paper chart is at fault, but if it's an error we have made (rare, but not impossible) then we fix it!
 
Back
Top