Gas Usage: Twin engine vs. Single engine

VIPERxGTx2000

Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2007
RO Number
25813
Messages
16
I have a lot of questions since i'm new to the 30 foot boats. The most important question I have is wether a twin engine boat uses two times as much gas as a single does. My family is debating wether on getting a 28 footer with a single engine or a 30 with twin engines, the only reason we are debating getting a 30 is because of gas.

So here is my question: How many gallons per hour does a single sea ray sundancer 280 use vs. a sundancer 300 with twin engines? I believe the twins are 5.7L Mercruisers. I'm not sure about the single engine.

Thanks for everyones help, I have learned a lot from this forum.
 
I think no matter which way you go, gas will still cost you plenty. If you want to run full speed most of the time my guess would be you are better with twins, because for 28 + family the single may be too little. On the other hand, if you want to save gas and run most of the time at hull speed with an ability to go fast if necessary then may be the single is way to go.
My guess is that if fuel costs are a big concern for you, then may be you should get a smaller boat.
 
it takes a certain amount of power to move a boat at a particular speed. That power doesn’t care if it is one engine or ten. One engine may be lighter and have less drag but other than that the power needed will be similar certainly not 2X. Resale will be more important and IMO a single would be unusual and more difficult to sell. Then there is the boater’s rule: "there is no replacement for displacement"
 
A lot depends on the relative size and age of the engines. Twin 300cid engines are probably going to burn considerable more fuel that a single 454cid. If the engines are older and carburated as opposed to FI, the difference might be greater. How are you going to use the boat?? If you're going to do some extended cruising, there's nothing like twins for safety. Engine size makes a lot of difference. I one went from a 27ft with 2x3.8L v6s to a 28ft with 2x351 v8s. The v6s had to turn 3600rpm to cruise at 24mph. The v8s on a bigger boat would loaf along at 2800rpm to get 24mph, and actually burned less fuel. As a general rule, big engines that are loafing are better than smaller, or single, engines that have to work real hard. They'll last longer too. As mentioned, the twins might be easier to dispose of when the time comes to trade up again.
 
I've read several fuel consumption studies conducted using different engine sizes, and twins vs. a large single engine, in otherwise identical boats. The results were exactly what pdecat said. So long as the engines were equally efficient (i.e., FI vs. carb.), the difference in fuel consumption at a given speed was negligible. Bottom line is that it takes "X" amount of energy to overcome water and wind resistance at a given speed for a given hull, and you need to burn "Y" amount of fuel to generate that amount of energy.

What does cost more is the maintenance for the extra engine and outdrive. However, as someone that was new to twins last season, I found that what you get is incredibly improved maneuverability around the docks! I can do things with the twins that I couldn't dream of doing with my previous single engine setups.

In my opinion, that's well worth the extra money!

Silver Duck
 
I HAD A 2002 27' MAXUM WITH 454 BIG BLOCK USED 12-15 GPH AVERAGE 300 HRS. NOW HAVE A SIG280 CHAPERRAL TWIN VOLVO 4.3 225HP. BURN 8.5 GPH TOTAL SINCE NEW 185 HRS. A PERFECT MATCH OF ENGINE AND BOAT. CRUISE 3200-3300 RPM 28-29 MPH FULL FUEL 5 P.O.P.
 
my first post here was basically the same question back last year when I bought my first boat - got a lot of good avice to go with the twins, and couldn't be happier. I think a 30 footer with a single is apt to be underpowered. And then I think of the times I've been out somewhere and there's an issue with an engine, or you've dinged a prop or whatever, and at least you know you'll get home and not be foundering. I think this is one of the few issues in boating that, for a boat of a certain size (including 30 feet), is really almost a no-brainer. In my view.

Good luck

Orcbait
 
if you need X hp to move a specific boat at X kts, there will not be a big difference whether one or two engines produce the hp...

a twin has more drag but that's about it. the difference in cost will be maintenance... but for the extra maintenance you get the reliability of the twins...
 
Don't consider this as advice-just from personnel experiance. We once had a 25' Searay Sundancer (cuddy) with single 5.7 Mercruiser.
Got 2footitis and got 27'Sundancer with twin 4.3. By todays measurements it would have been a 30 footer.
I keep accurate fuel burn records. After a seasons running I discovered that gallons per hour were the same for both setups.
As stated by others you will probably be happier with the twins. Performance was excellent with both boats. Good luck.
Ron
 
Hello I have found the same fuel consumption as dumy. I went from a 26 Rinker with a 5.7 Mercruiser to a Sea Ray with the twin 4.3 . I found fuel consumption to be the same for both boats. The Rinker was a 8'6" beam and wieghted about 5700dry the SeaRay is 9'5" with a dry wieght of about 8500lb.
 
very interesting responses, I had one guy at a sea ray dealer double the stated gas usage on the 300 saying it was 22gph for each engine so 44gph, I knew he couldn't have been right.
 
Yeah ... no way that a 300 would burn 44 gph!

On another note, I find it difficult to believe that a Chaparral 280 Signature would get 8.5 gph. Your 8.5 gph is probably what you are getting all around (mixed speeds). GPH on a 28 ft boat with twin 4.3 litre engines would probably be at least 12 gph as measured at optimal cruising speed.

We had a 28 ft single engine carb engine boat (7.4 litre) which was getting around 12 to 15 gph at cruise speed (6,700 lbs). Now we have twin 8.1 litre engines (mpi) that get burn a total of 24gph at cruise speed (13,300 lbs). So we're burning twice as much fuel now, but in our case, our current boat is twice the weight, 2 feet wider and about 8 feet longer (with slighltly bigger block twin engines to boot).
 
I had a boat with a single 460 cobra that burned a lot of gas. Then I bought a boat with twin 454's that used less than the 460. My thought on it was the 4 barrel was opening on the 460 because of being undrepowered and doesn't open very often on the 454's.
 
scarry when dealers give you bad info like this, isn't it ? you got to wonder what else they're lying about... 44gph !!! my old 98 maxum 37, with less efficient vee drives used to burn 32GPH ** 20kts cruise...

also, you often see people runnign their boats at the wrong speed : barely on plane, bow sky high, pushing a big wake... that's the worst speed...

one big issue with small twin engine boats is engine cpt access. when you stuff 2 engines in there you end up with a lot of things becoming hard to reach and service.. from bilge pumps to plugs, belts, etc...

properly maintained single engine boats can be very reliable, sure things happen but with the right tools and spares, you're rarely going be dead in the water.ex... it's pretty easy to replace a prop on a stern drive in water...
 
Back
Top