generators and public docks

greenstreak

Member
exMember
Joined
Mar 8, 2004
RO Number
12942
Messages
320
Tell me if I am wrong or right. This has happened twice at Hontoon Island state park here in Florida. This weekend I get there and dock. A few minutes later a rental house boat from Holly Bluff Marina was docked there running their generator cause it is a 50 amp service and our dock service is 30 amp and the rental boat did not have the adapter cord. I go up and complain to the ranger about it. He said he told them they couldn't run it at night time. I said then I am suppose to set there and smell the fumes. He did nothing. The ranger told me I should move away from them. The next morning they were running it again. I complained to Mike(park manager) and he said he didn't see anything wrong with them using it to fix breakfast or make coffee. I told him I would not accept that for an answer, that I will notify the state parks office about this situation. Then he was trying to change his answer to this saying that he might look into buying a cord for those rentals to use in the future. (That cord costs $419). When he finds this out he won't buy it. Am I wrong to complain about this?

Thanks
Art
 
if they're just running it for a short time, that's no big deal. All night long for AC, yes... dangerous.

happens all the time around here, at parks with no shore power, never seen anybody complain although there is always a breeze so you never smell anything...

if it's a common issue with the rentals, then write to them to tell them it is dangerous and remind them they'll be responsible if someone dies because of CO poisoning
 
Tell the rangers about boatfix. The adapters aren't half that much.
 
adrift--So you mean it is ok with you coming to a dock that has electric hookup and the boat next to you runs his genset and you have to sit there and smell it?

Art
 
Art if they are running it for short periods what is the problem? I agree with Pascal all night would be a problem. You did say it was a public park or is your park? While I would find it annoying I'm not sure you have any more rights than they do? Regards Bill
 
Hey Pascal--That is a good ideal about writing to Holly Bluff marina about this problem. I understand marina's that don't have electrical hookup that a person would expect to see gensets running and it would be his choice to stay there. This is a state park with water and electric hookups, so everybody I have talked to that goes there says they don't want to sit there and smell fumes.

Thanks
Art
 
adrift

running a genset (especially gas) at the dock is dangerous, most marinas or parks have rules against that, so it's not a public dock / your problem issue.

as i said, around here it is a common practice for people to run their gennies when tied to the wall at the local state park. on a busy sunday afternoon you're going to have boats rafted up 2 or 3 deep, gennies humming. Not ideal, but common. i dont' think you can expect them to shut them down... to be honest, i've never smelled genny exhaust not that it makes it safe.

now, at a park with shorepower where nobody else runs the genny, it's not unreasonable to ask the one boat with genny to shut it down once they've done whatever they had to do.

it's not a black or white answer, it depends on the location, wind, etc...

now, if you CO detectors goes off... then it's another matter !
 
Hey Charlie---I checked boatfix and this adapter is $352. It is a 50a Y-cable to 2 30a. this is a very expensive adapter.

Thanks
Art
 
Nope the BF price is $216.

Y ADAPTER $360.97 $216.63
Save $144.34 HARVEY HUBBELL INC. 64CM54M / HUB64CM54
 
I would think that the problem is yours and not the boat that is running the generator. If he can't plug in to the shore power, then the only alternative is to run his generator until his batteries are fully charged and his electrical needs are fulfilled. I have done this at parks where there are no electrical hookups, but only for a short period of time and never after sundown.
It would not bother me if some other boat did the same thing.
 
hey Jim--- Everyone keeps referring to places that don't have electrical hookups. This isn't comparing apples to apples. We have electrical hookups. What if 6 more boats pull into the park and have the same problem with no adapter cord? All I am saying is there has to be a rule in place for this. I have been at other marinas that have told me I couldn't run a genset there. I had to use their hookups. I had no problem with that.

Thanks
Art
 
Charlie--You have the wrong y connector. It is the one that has a 50a female with 2 30a male connectors. hblyq230/hubyq230 List $823.29 cost $355.74 I was going to buy one and donate it to the state park, but not at this price. I am going to talk to the park and I will split the cost with them.

Thanks
Art
 
Not sure about down there but up here a "gift to Government" gets double deductability against capital gains.
Don't split it with them, give it to them and get receipt for the gift. Maybe they will write it at list price.
 
When I'm boating, if I don't like my neighbors, I just go somewhere else. That's the nice thing about boats vs houses/apts/condos, you don't have to put up with neighbors if you don't like them.
 
hey Jeff--You always anchor out somewhere, so you can move anytime you want and drop anchor again. It isn't that easy at docks. I didn't realize there where so many people in boating that really don't give a dam about their life or their families lives. A few minutes of co can be deadly. I never saw a time limit on dying from co. It is the volume of co that kills. It is very dangerous at docks cause the co gets trapped under the docks and can filter into the next boat.

Art
 
Hey jim-- So, you are saying it is ok if someone in your family dies from another boat coming into the dock without proper hookups and runs their generater when their was power hookups? That is why I go to docks with power, assuming people can't run a genset there. I guess it would be your fault for allowing your family to sleep during the day.

Art
 
Art
I assume your boat has at least 1 CO detector? Did it go off?
If his GenSet is running and NO CO is going your way there should be no issue
If your CO detector goes off and he will then not shut it down-than you can claim he is assaulting you with a deadly poison – Hell claim he is a terrorist- but if there is no CO coming your way, grin and bear it or move
 
Art - perhaps I'm being a bit selfish here but you could keep the adaptor yourself and 'help' anyone with this issue who docks next to you. At least this way you know you are getting the result you are looking for. Works out better for everyone if the adaptor is available - I'm sure they would rather not run their genset either.

- Vic
 
Back
Top