Great Lakes Storms

bsteven43

Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2007
RO Number
28678
Messages
76
Being a boater now, I pay a lot closer attention to the weather and sea conditions on Lake Erie. This is the marine forecast for the next two days ...

.THIS AFTERNOON...SOUTH WINDS 15 TO 25 KNOTS BECOMING SOUTHWESTAND INCREASING TO 35 KNOTS GALES. RAIN SHOWERS LIKELY. WAVES 2 TO3 FEET BUILDING TO 5 TO 8 FEET..TONIGHT...WEST GALES TO 35 KNOTS INCREASING TO 40 KNOTS. CLOUDY.A CHANCE OF SNOW OR RAIN SHOWERS OVERNIGHT. WAVES BUILDING TO 10TO 14 FEET..TUESDAY...SOUTHWEST GALES TO 45 KNOTS BECOMING NORTHWEST. RAINAND SNOW SHOWERS...MAINLY EAST OF LORAIN. WAVES 12 TO 16 FEET..TUESDAY NIGHT...NORTHWEST GALES TO 45 KNOTS BECOMING NORTHWEST ANDDIMINISHING TO 35 KNOTS. RAIN AND SNOW SHOWERS LIKELY. WAVES 12 TO16 FEET SUBSIDING TO 10 TO 14 FEET.

12-16 feet is the highest I can ever remember seeing on Lake Erie. Does it get worse? Can the ore boats move across the lakes in these conditions?

Does Michigan or Ontario or the others get bigger seas? I'm going to walk out to the Fairport lighthouse area to check it out.
 
quote:

Originally posted by bsteven43

12-16 feet is the highest I can ever remember seeing on Lake Erie. Does it get worse? Can the ore boats move across the lakes in these conditions?






Yes, the big ore boats can handle big seas. The Edmund Fitzgerald and the Arthur Anderson were navigating in 35+ foot waves when the Fitz went down. The Anderson made safe port. It was conjectured that the waves could have been as high as 50 feet.

The great lakes are inland seas...don't let the word "lake" throw you.
 
Lake Erie especially gets a siege or water slopping from end to end. water levels can drop 4 feet in the west end when all the water gets blown to the east.
 
We usually get forecasted seas of 17-19 feet on Lake Michigan in the fall to early winter at least once. Who knows what really occurs as the weather stations are moved to the hard for winter storage.
 
If I recall correctly, the wave period (steepness) is of shorter duration than in ocean water.
 
I have boated on the Great Lakes for almost 40 years and have seen lots of high waves. Never have seen any that were over 20 feet in significant wave height. I have been to Cape Hurd when the storms of November were creating huge monster waves which crash ashore at the cape. They are in the range of 15 to 18 feet in height with the highest recorded wave ever on the lake measuring 21 feet. They are a sight that you never forget and never want to be out in a boat in those conditions.
The highest wave ever recorded on Lake Superior was 26 feet.
 
I've seen 10-12' seas on Lake Michigan. They are an amazing sight, but very scary. I certainly wouldn't want to be out on my 32' express cruiser. Frankly, I've been caught in the middle of Lake Michigan when 5-6' confused seas were developing and I was sweating like crazy.
 
Its been pretty-well discussed I'm sure that the frequency or profile or whatever of the waves on Lake Erie are such that you seldom see people out in anything more than 3-4 footers. Very few pleasure boaters around my marina will leave the slip if the forecast is worse than 2-4's. I've got a 41' Viking convertible right next to me, I'd like to see him out in the 10-12s.
 
I've sailed the Great Lakes and most of the rest of Canada's coast line for over 10 yrs and I never actually "feared" for my life till I got to Superior. We crossed from Tunder Bay to the Sault in December in a gale that saw us with a following sea of about 15-18 footers and winds approaching 60 knots. We began to make ice on the superstructure and developed a list of about 30 degs when the Cap'n decided to run for cover in Batchewana Bay. Most of us who weren't on duty were in our bunks in our gumby suits with our life jackets propping up the sides of our mattresses to keep us from rolling out on the deck. The bunks faced fore and aft and I can remember the door curtain on my cabin swinging out more than 45 degs as we pitched over the waves. Once we got inside Batchewana Bay the boys were sent out to hammer off the ice. I remember the engineer saying he estimated we had over 600 tonnes of ice on the decks and at 700 tonnnes our stability would have been so severly affected we would have been in real danger of capsizing. This was on a 2000 tonne icebreaker! The North Atlantic off of Labrador in the tail end of a hurricane didn't scare me that much! I'd have to say Lake Erie is the worst for "ride" in a blow. Once off of Nanticoke we had to turn to in a storm for a Search and Rescue call and once outside the harbor you could feel the ship bottom out when she plowed down in a trough!
 
Click on lakemichigancam.com right now and you can see what the lake is dishing out right now. Not a good place to be.
 
I've only boated on Lake Erie specifically the western basin.. I know it can get wicked in a hurry. My grandfather was a commercial fisherman and had to go out daily to tend to the nets. He had a few stories to tell. Back then, when it was rough out, the only boats he would see would be an occasional Lyman.

As for the Arthur M Anderson - we saw her in port at the Sandusky Coal Dock a couple summers ago when we were out in the dinghy.. gave me chills to think she was out with the Fitz the night she went down.

bsteven43, we only live a few blocks from the lake.. I'll have to take the wife over to the Rocky River Pier to check it out.. She used to live across the street from the Pier when I first met her - we could hear the wind/waves crashing in from her apartment that was way at the back of the complex.

As for big waves in Lake Erie, my brother brought his 311 Formula back from PIB to Toledo in some pretty nasty stuff several years ago.. he said that near West Sister he was standing on the tail and the rear stern cleats were under water.. and the waves were still coming over the bow.. he'd get into bursts of bigger waves like that and then they would diminish for a while. He said then as he would break over the top of one, it would pull the props out of the water.. hard to maintain power when the props are sucking air.. Needless to say it scared the sh*t out of him for a while.. and it was the last trip of the season for him. It took several weeks to dry out the boat inside his building. He considered it a lack of judgment on his part.. said he should have known better than to attempt the trip to begin with. The waves were in fact much higher than predicted that day.

Truth be known, I think it took him all winter to get over it.. I think it put a pretty good scare into him that is for sure.
 
Lake Michigan forecast is for 10-14 foot seas on Tuesday, November 6.
 
Part of the problem with the great lakes is that they aren't very deep (compared to the ocean) which means the wave energy bounces off the bottom as well when the weather gets nasty.
 
quote:

Originally posted by glenncal1

Part of the problem with the great lakes is that they aren't very deep (compared to the ocean) which means the wave energy bounces off the bottom as well when the weather gets nasty.





Lake Michigan is pretty deep averaging about 300 feet with portions that are well over 900 feet. I doubt much wave energy is hitting the bottom once you get offshore. Superior is even deeper. Erie is the shallow one.
 
That was F-U-N!

I had some business at the club last night and was excited to see that I beat the squall line. The lake was basically a mill pond. 2' or less. I pulled my car up to the beach at a 5pm: Just in time for the show. The squall line passed at about 5:10 with some rain and 35mph sustained wind. By 5:30 waves were rolling 3-5s. By 5:30 waves were at 6-8s. By 6pm, the waves were around 7-9s. I checked the weather station inside the clubhouse. Average sustained winds were 35mph with gusts up to 45.
By 7pm waves were easily over 10' and N-A-S-T-Y.

The above is the reason Lake Erie is a very dangerous place to boat. It kicks FAST because it's so shallow and the waves are close together (killer for smaller boats.)

It was a heck of a show!
 
Hi Mark,

Wow, that would have been neat to see... it kicked up pretty good here last night. What beach did you witness the show??

I agree w/you.. Lake Erie may not have the BIGGEST waves, but it's got to be up there with the ability to get Wicked the quickest.. hence the name ERIE... I could almost imagine that had the Fitz been in the western basin, that even on the bottom that maybe parts of her superstructure could have been still above water?? Was just a thought anyway.. :)

no doubt, she would have bottomed out many times in a storm like she was in.

I’ve never boated in any of the other Great Lakes.. I think they all have a personality of their own.. each to be respected and never taken for granted.

Today
Southwest gales to 40 knots increasing to 45 knots and becoming west late. Rain and snow showers. Also a chance of thunderstorms this afternoon. Waves 8 to 12 feet building to 12 to 16 feet.
 
quote:

Originally posted by DogDaze

Hi Mark,

Wow, that would have been neat to see... it kicked up pretty good here last night. What beach did you witness the show??

I agree w/you.. Lake Erie may not have the BIGGEST waves, but it's got to be up there with the ability to get Wicked the quickest.. hence the name ERIE... I could almost imagine that had the Fitz been in the western basin, that even on the bottom that maybe parts of her superstructure could have been still above water?? Was just a thought anyway.. :)

no doubt, she would have bottomed out many times in a storm like she was in.

I’ve never boated in any of the other Great Lakes.. I think they all have a personality of their own.. each to be respected and never taken for granted.

Today
Southwest gales to 40 knots increasing to 45 knots and becoming west late. Rain and snow showers. Also a chance of thunderstorms this afternoon. Waves 8 to 12 feet building to 12 to 16 feet.





I was right at the mouth of the Chagrin River - East side of the lake. I've been on the lake in 7-9s when I was a kid. That's why I don't venture out if there is the threat of any fast moving weather over the lake. My boat can take it, no doubt, but I can only find religion so many times in my life. [:-crazy]
 
Back
Top