Guns & Boats

JLC

Member
exMember
Joined
Sep 8, 2005
RO Number
18971
Messages
753
If you live in CT and have a permit to carry.....
and you have driven to your boat.....
and you have your gun with you.....
and you want to take a ride in your boat....
and you know that 10 minutes out of your slip you can be crossing into RI or NY waters even by accident......

Do you leave your gun in your car or take it on the boat.

From Mystic Ct I can be in RI or NY waters in 15 minutes or MS waters in an hour.

Whats the deal with pistolas on de boats?
 
Only carry rifles/shotguns on board, then you don't have to worry.
 
I guess my question really is.... do you leave your gun in the car or take it with you.

Both are equally bad in respective ways.
 
I always take it with me, we will talk about it later.
 
I would take it. Then again, to me, it matters not which state I am in.
 
If you don't live in Yankee land, it is not an issue.
 
I boat in the same waters, theres no need for a gun in Fishers Island sound. Maybe if you think theres pirates off Watch Hill...
 
The one time I saw a gun pulled on a boat it was on the Ranger V out of Sheepshead Bay Brooklyn. People were snagging each others lines and one AH pulled a gaff on someone. A rifle came out of the bridge ready to go.
End of argument.
 
quote:

Originally posted by GeeBee

If you don't live in Yankee land, it is not an issue.






Yeah buddy. Atlanta is one of the safer cities in the US....Ranks up there with Jax, Miami, DC and anywhere in Jersey.
 
Sounds like a loaded question. (pun intended :-)

I think the only question is whether or not the gun needs to be unloaded and separated from the ammo. US Code allows for transportation of firearms through all 50 states. I know I read where that means the gun in the trunk and the ammo in the glove box. However, I can never find the answer on is how that applies to boats (and by "boat" I mean one that qualifies as a second home). I've asked the USCG, and there's no federal law against being armed. I've asked local law enforcement in MD and they have no clue. Heck, a firearm is an approved USCG signaling device when fired every 60 seconds after all!
 
Didn't matter if I took it or not.. I keep one in each 8-)...
 
Richiela there's no crime in those states? Why would the various boating police agencies need guns if there was no risk at all? Fish and Game carry guns why to defend themselves against a fish or wild deer near the waters edge? Wow I might actually move there if the taxes weren't as bad as where I already live. Boats have never been broken into while the owners are inside sleeping? How about when you get off the boat more like if you tie up and are back on land your logic again says that no crimes are committed near the water? Carry permits are not easy to come by in Conn. but are far harder to get in New Jersey where I had 6 over a 12 year period. If you leave the gun in the car I would make sure it was locked away and you have a car alarm. Having a carry permit and having the gun stolen is a real problem up here in the NE anti-gun portion of the US. Being in LE years ago I can tell you most police officers like the idea of well trained armed citizens. Just a quick story on the NJ turnpike about 10 years ago a NJ State trooper was shot at wounded and outgunned a truck driver from the south passing through noticed the gunfight came up with an AK47 and blew the 2 perps away but you will never read about this story anywhere because of this hero who technically in NJ would have gone to jail for a minimum of 15 years (carrying and possession of a fully automatic weapon) he saved a State police officer's life and ended 2 dirt bag's. The incident was washed the man was escorted (proudly by the NJSP) on his way out of the state and that is it. I chose not to carry a gun anymore mostly due to liability reasons and the oppressive hoops you need to jump through here in NJ where the criminal courts love to make criminals out of it's citizen's right to abide by the 2nd Amendment.
Bill
 
Dave, not talking about the relative safety of the land you are in, I'm talking about the ability to carry a weapon.
 
Kurt, I called and asked Maryland State Patrol about brionging mine on a trip there. They said you had to be on the way to a range, or to a repair shop. Otherwise, not legal to carry a handgun into Maryland at all. Loaded or unloaded. Concealed or no. Ammo seperate or not. Did I get an incorrect answer from them? Called the Attorney General's office and basically got the same story. Sounds like maybe they don't want to tell callers the truth.

So you're saying it's legal to carry a handgun in all 50 states in your car? So long as ammo and gun are seperated. I have an SUV, so no trunk. What would be the legal way to carry gun and ammo in that circumstance (in a state that does not allow concealed carry)?

JB
 
The authorities will check you for firearms. If you do not have one they will issue you one.
 
quote:

Originally posted by mixman

Sounds like a loaded question. (pun intended :-)

I think the only question is whether or not the gun needs to be unloaded and separated from the ammo. US Code allows for transportation of firearms through all 50 states. I know I read where that means the gun in the trunk and the ammo in the glove box. However, I can never find the answer on is how that applies to boats (and by "boat" I mean one that qualifies as a second home). I've asked the USCG, and there's no federal law against being armed. I've asked local law enforcement in MD and they have no clue. Heck, a firearm is an approved USCG signaling device when fired every 60 seconds after all!




Kurt you are also in a fairly regressive state when it comes to carry permits, had a few there as well. I agree with you I have been told in New Jersey a boat by N.J. law even know federally it qualifies as a 2nd or primary residence for some, again it is considered a motor vehicle. I then have asked about documented vessels and in NJ they still look at these as motor vehicles. The people that live and travel in RVs have the same issues. The gun laws are actually horrible in our area, but if you have the money and connections its surprising who has carry permits it is a matter of public record in NJ probably most states if not all. Regards Bill
 
quote:

Originally posted by jb2c

Kurt, I called and asked Maryland State Patrol about brionging mine on a trip there. They said you had to be on the way to a range, or to a repair shop. Otherwise, not legal to carry a handgun into Maryland at all. Loaded or unloaded. Concealed or no. Ammo seperate or not. Did I get an incorrect answer from them? Called the Attorney General's office and basically got the same story. Sounds like maybe they don't want to tell callers the truth.

So you're saying it's legal to carry a handgun in all 50 states in your car? So long as ammo and gun are seperated. I have an SUV, so no trunk. What would be the legal way to carry gun and ammo in that circumstance (in a state that does not allow concealed carry)?

JB





Careful with the term unloaded if you have a semi auto legally means the magazine must be unloaded meaning not a single bullet in the clip not even if the gun and clip are separated. The AG is wrong in Md. you can be passing through. SUV owners again have problems I would assume the pistol would need to be in a locked box out of reach of the driver and the ammo in the box in a different area.
Bill
 
quote:

Originally posted by vriceflyer

The authorities will check you for firearms. If you do not have one they will issue you one.





Careful I hear you have to join ACORN to get a carry permit or the Black Panthers.
 
The demographics of Mystic, Stonington, Noank and Watch Hill are mostly older well to do folks. Average age is close to 65. Very old family lines.

I can't think of a time when a gun was needed on these waters.
 
Back
Top