Here we go again...

baull

Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2002
RO Number
7674
Messages
61
Coast Guard suspends search for second man in boat accident
The Associated Press

CHARLESTON, S.C. --
The Coast Guard has suspended its search for a man, who was lost when the boat he and his brother were in starting taking on water and capsized.

The search for Daniel Phallan, 29, was called off Saturday night, the Coast Guard said.

"We used every available resource to try and find him," said Lt. Cmdr. Eric King, a search and rescue coordinator for the Coast Guard in Charleston. "Our only hope is that others can learn something from this situation so that it doesn't happen again."

Rescuers were able to find William Phallan, 31, Saturday morning about 11 miles east of Winyah Bay. William Phallan was taken to the hospital, where he was listed in stable condition.

The brothers had gone out in a 16-foot boat Friday evening, the Coast Guard said. The men used a cell phone to call for help when their boat began taking on water and became disabled four miles east of Murrells Inlet.

Rescuers say the older brother stayed with the boat, which made it easier to find him. William Phallan said he and his brother were wearing life jackets when the boat flipped over and that he lost his brother in the high swells during the night.

A combined total of 700 square miles were searched for a combined total of 35 hours for the missing men, the Coast Guard said.

The Coast Guard recommends that all boaters have a VHF radio and signaling devices when on the water.

(or maybe DON'T GO INTO THE OCEAN IN A 16' BOAT)
 
I don't think that the problem was the size of the boat.
 
Yes, Bob, you are correct, it is a very smart idea to go out in the ocean on a 16' boat, especially right after a major storm passed and the water was still rough.

I hope you make your attempt to get to Block Island next summer on your bow rider.
 
Don't be a retread. Even you admit that the mere fact that the boat was 16' was not enough to make it dangerous.
 
Boats and guns don't kill people.... STUPIDITY DOES.
And there is no cure for STUPID.
Manny
2060 Fisherman Trophy.
 
They don't all float. All the more reason to wear a properly outfitted (STROBE LIGHT, retroreflective tape, STROBE LIGHT, whistle, STROBE LIGHT) PFD.

We don't all float. Well, we do, but some right from the start, others not for a day or two, and some not for a month. Guess which one of those three get a chance to try it again? Or, more to the point, which two don't?

Point being, just wear the damn PFD. Makes you much easier to find. Think you can find something the size of half a cantaloupe floating on an overcast night? Now how about a high intensity white light flashing at intervals of 50-70 times per minute ttached to an international orange block of foam laced with retroreflective tape wrapped around something the size of a full cantaloupe? This stuff's not as easy as it's made to look.
 
Bob is partially right...

stupidity is the cause of this accident, for not realizing a small boat didn't belong in the ocean when a hurricane is just off the coast.
 
If the size of the boat matters, then why did the 729 foot Edmund Fitzgerald go down? I guess it was too small to be out on Lake Superior.

All I'm saying is that size doesn't matter. At least that what I've always been told.
 
quote:

All I'm saying is that size doesn't matter. At least that what I've always been told.





Why do you continue to try and hurt people Bob? Don't you realize that your advice is dangerous? It's one thing to try and be funny or a class clown it's another to be irresponsible and reckless.

A person died and you come up with a joke about size not mattering. Real nice.
 
Sorry if I've been taken the wrong way here. My point is that the operator of this boat made several mistakes, but the fact that he went into the ocean in a 16' boat was not one of them, as baull stated at the end of the original post.

Mistake #1: no VHF radio on board.
Mistake #2: no signalling device(s) on board.
Mistake #3: going out too far without a backup plan.
Mistake #4: leaving the boat after it capsized.
 
disaster can strike any boat, regardless of size and conditions but what you need to realize is that when you're out in 3 or 4 footers at night in a 16' outboard powered, low freeboard boat, the odds of something going wrong are much higher.
 
No Bob, you said, "My point is that the operator of this boat made several mistakes, but the fact that he went into the ocean in a 16' boat was not one of them" That was his first mistake, going out in a boat ill equipped to handle the prevailing conditions at the time. Unfortunately one of them paid for the mistake with his life. The fact that you can't understand this is irrelevant.
 
The fact that you (and others) can't understand that a 16' boat is NOT inherently dangerous in and of itself is rather annoying.

The boat was not ill-equipped, as you say, the operator was.
 
What part of "going out in a boat ill equipped to handle the prevailing conditions at the time" equals "can't understand that a 16' boat is NOT inherently dangerous in and of itself"?

Even you in your desire to go to Block Island said many times you would wait for a perfect day with perfect conditions. They made a bad decision and it cost them a life. Had they taken a larger boat with higher freeboard or waited till the storm had completely past and the conditions calmed down the results most likely would have been different.

BTW - if you find opinions differing from yours annoying feel free to ignore them or go elsewhere. Don't forget this place is called BoaterEd, not Bob's place.
 
Poor choice of words on my part, it's not annoying, it's just frustrating.

YOU, or me, or any of the other folks on this board who like to haze me would not have had that problem on that boat. We would not have gone out, or we would have had the proper hailing/signaling equipment, or we would have gotten the boat back into safe waters when it became disabled, or it wouldn't have become disabled because we would have done the proper maintenance and/or pre trip checks. IT'S NOT THE BOAT'S FAULT!

P.S. If I ignored all the differing opinions, it would be kinda boring. That's what these forums are all about, discussing opinions and sharing experiences.
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

we would have had the proper hailing/signaling equipment, or we would have gotten the boat back into safe waters when it became disabled, or it wouldn't have become disabled because we would have done the proper maintenance and/or pre trip checks. IT'S NOT THE BOAT'S FAULT!





Please explain to me how having the proper signaling equipment makes a boat more seaworthy????

To bad you feel your being hazed. Have you given any thought to the disrespect you show those with more experience and knowledge than you?

I'm not going to debate this with you anymore, I'd rather talk to a rock.
 
Having proper signalling equipment on board might have saved the fellow's life. I win.
 
WIN.....Someone is missing or dead..and you win?

quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

The fact that you (and others) can't understand that a 16' boat is NOT inherently dangerous in and of itself is rather annoying.






Uh,,,,,,Bobby, most here understand this without even thinking about it; sorry YOU can't understand that most understand. Don't know why that would be annoy or frustrate you, could it just be you?

quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

IT'S NOT THE BOAT'S FAULT!






Thanks for settling that…..my boat will be glad to hear as we are in therapy together.

Prayers for the missing man......
 
Bob, once again, you are showing you utter lack of understanding of "safe boating". No matter what equipment they had on board, under the conditions, they should NOT have gone out in that size boat.

I have a 38' boat - I won't go out in those conditions. I believe that the safety of my crew and myself far outweighs the dangers inherent in venturing out in conditions that my boat can't handle.

No, it's "not the boat's fault" - however stupid a statement that is. The boat did not start up on its own and drive them out there. The captain made a stupid decision and it cost a human life.

We try to use our collective knowledge to help prevent others from doing the same. You, on the other hand, seem to relish in the thought of pushing your boat to, and beyond, its limitations. Your comments could result in someone losing their life.
 
Back
Top