Holy crap, GPS error!

Freddy

Member
exMember
Joined
Nov 14, 2001
RO Number
6704
Messages
260
GPS directs driver onto train tracks
VANERSBORG, Sweden (UPI) -- A Swedish driver who trusted his onboard GPS navigation system more than his eyes wound up driving on railroad tracks in a snow storm.

The driver followed the directions he got from his GPS system and steered his car onto the rail tracks Friday. The gadget told him there was a turn in the road, but the reality is there was no turn there.

"It was a Norwegian GPS, but there have been several of these kinds of accidents where drivers have trusted their GPS more than the road," said police spokesman Stefan Gustafsson.

There was almost 4 inches of fresh snow on the ground when the drive made his wrong turn, the newspaper said.

Officials halted all rail traffic when the driver alerted authorities he was stuck. It wasn't clear how far he had traveled along the tracks.

Copyright 2007 by United Press International

This news arrived on: 11/19/2007

[:-cowboy]
 
better headline....

GPS can't save stupid driver !
 
OK, this case was stupid, but there are some subtleties with GPS's that might impact boaters (although you probably won't be directed onto a railway line)

Be aware that certain GPS's (better not say the brand) use the Magnetic Variation value from the Satelite Fix rather than from a waypoint database when creating a Route or Navigation Plan.

This means that if you create a ROUTE (or a Flight Plan in the case of aircraft) when the unit does NOT have a GPS fix , then Magnetic Variation will NOT be applied, and the Bearing between wypts will be actually DEGREES TRUE but flagged on the screen / printout as DEGREES MAGNETIC. The user does not get warned about this. In my part of the world, variation can be around 18 degrees, so this can leed to some significant errors.

Now this is a minor inconvenience for boaters, but it effects flight plans for aircraft in exactly the same way - I found out the hard way ! !
 
I’m not sure if this will apply here, however……..automotive chartplotter GPS systems are different then boating chartplotter GPS systems.

Boating GPS systems do their best to give your real location.

Automotive systems try to ‘snap’ you onto a existing road.

Going thru construction zones will with the automotive GPS on can expose this. I was on hwy 94 heading south thru Gurnee IL, north of Chicago last week. The GPS snapped me onto the frontage road. This continued until the frontage road took a turn away from the highway.

If the railroad track was close to a actual road it can snap you to a incorrect location. If there was fresh fallen snow, hiding the tracks, you’d be easily convinced.
 
It's sorta like being in the twilight zone. My eyes say follow the water but the GPS says drive the boat like a land rover. My boat GPS always indicates my boat has taken the land route rather than passing under the bridge in Venice,FL everytime I pass through there.
 
"This means that if you create a ROUTE (or a Flight Plan in the case of aircraft) when the unit does NOT have a GPS fix , then Magnetic Variation will NOT be applied, and the Bearing between wypts will be actually DEGREES TRUE but flagged on the screen / printout as DEGREES MAGNETIC. The user does not get warned about this. In my part of the world, variation can be around 18 degrees, so this can leed to some significant errors."

That is a unit dependent function. Not always true. More advanced units will apply variation to the route.

As to auto GPS's again it is a unit dependent function. I have a Magellen 4020 that is entirely GPS dependent. The GPS on my Lexus uses a combination of GPS and tire rotation to affix it's position accurately, very accurately I might add. And yes, when you change tires you must recalibrate it.
 
Magnetic variation from the satellite fix ??????? What are you on about ????

Oh yeah and like the way whenever somebody stuffs up it's always the GPS's fault, yeah right! "GPS Error" Wrong term, poor excuse!
 
Back
Top