"bleach is a much stronger products than those"
Bleach and magic erasers are completely different products, the fact that one does or doesn't work does not preclude the other one from working. I've had stains that bleach wouldn't touch that have come out with magic erasers in a fraction of a second. I've never used the magic erasers on rigid seats though, only on cushioned seats. Probably won't work, but there's no way of knowing unless you try.
Anyway, sounds like you know nothing's going to work, so it's time for a new seat!