Hydraulic thrusters

HarlenW

Member
Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2007
RO Number
25699
Messages
473
A 20 y.o. boat I am interested in has a hydraulic bow thruster. My questions are:

What maintenance issues exist? How often are repairs needed and is the 20 year age of the system a concern?

How difficult and relatively costly would it be to add a stern thruster?

Those of you who have used hydraulic thrusters please your experiences.

Thanks.
 
Oh let me be the first.

HARLEN. If u were a real capt u wouldnt need a bow thruster
Harlen u should invest that money in capt's class.
Harlen us should sell ur boat

Ok now that we got the b/s out of the way we can answer the mans question .

Rob
 
We have a hydraulic bow thruster on the 86'. Works off a PTO off the port main. Works well, hoses are the big maintenance item on the inside, outside there is maintenance every few years, take apart, put in new seals etc..., put back together. Zincs and cleaning/anti-fouling when needed

My thought is they are better in the long run, no batteries to manage, only problem is if that main is not working you loose power to the thruster. Some yachts have elaborate valving systems that can use PTO's on either of the mains to run it.
 
lol classic Robski... :)

I have experience with electric bow thrusters and hydraulic stern thrusters. The stern thruster is installed on a twin-engine diesel MY and is nearly useless on such a vessel. With twins and no bow thruster, a stern thruster is of little benefit. That changes however in a single-engine setup, or when paired with a bow thruster. (you can get away with less power at the bow if a stern thruster is also used)

The good news about stern thrusters is their cost. They're simply mounted on the transom, so they don't require glasswork.

The hydraulic unit that I've run is powered by a hydraulic pump mounted to the generator. So it obviously requires the genny to be running, but it's been 100% reliable and unlike a an electric unit that can overheat and shutdown when you need it most, the hydraulic version can be run indefinitely.
 
Hydraulic systems work well, but require considerable maintenance. The fluid must be kept clean and free of moisture. The shuttle valves are subject to wear and pitting. The hoses fail and blow fluid all over the place. Seals wear and leak. The hose connections corrode and leak. Heat is generated during use and must be dispersed. Running the hydraulic pump off of the main engine is not always a good idea, the generator drive engine(s) make more sense. If you use the main engine to power the hydraulic pump, the thruster output will be limited by the RPM's of the main engine. If the mains are at idle and you are trying to maneuver with the thruster, you will have to increase the RPM's of the mains to get sufficent power out of the thruster. By using the generator drive engine(s) that run at a constant speed (RPM) the power output of the thruster will be constant. Of course you have to size your generator drive engine(s) to take the load demands of the hydraulic pump. Some units use a hydraulic power pack unit with an electic motor driving the hydraulic pump at a constant speed.
 
The hyraulic units do not "time out" (thermal relay) as the electrical units tend to. You can put a lot of HP into a hyraulic thruster. I also prefer the hyraulic pump be on the genset, so that you can manuever the with the mains, (walk the boat sideways--or at least the stern in)--with the engine at idle--which may not give enough flow for thrusters.

I have run a boat with both bow and stern thrusters--it is cheating! You can just push the boat sideways into the mooring area, with virtually zero fore and aft clearance!
 
On the 86' the main runs the thruster just fine, no problems. LKeith is correct about the hoses and the chance for failure. When they blow, they blow. It makes a huge mess. Seals have to be watched like he said. We just change them out every 2-3 years.

One issue we were told when outfitting the thruster was that if we used the genset PTO, it could effect the voltage output when you went to use the thruster, not good for the air conditioners and other equipment with compressors and motors. THe A/C units are always running so that was a concern. Not having direct knowledge that this is true or not, just commenting on what I was told.
 
Back
Top