I couldn`t do it.....

mx8

Member
Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2006
RO Number
24359
Messages
600
.. I ashamedly admit it, I could not get the boat in my slip.
This Sunday we were out and the starboard engine (6BTA5.9 Cummins`) lost rpms, shuddered and stopped and would not restart. I suspected a fuel filter issue and I carry spares but it was pretty rough , getting late and we were only about five miles out so I decided to bring it in on the port engine. All went fine until until docking (surprise). I head in my fairway, the slip is on the starboard side. The fairway isn`t much wider than the boat is long, 50` fairway, 42 loa boat. I could get the stern to head toward the slip w/rudder and reverse but every time I would rudder over and use forward to try and square the stern up to fit between the finger and the piling, (18" wider than my beam) the prop walk, which I usually love to rely on, would move the stern out and in seconds the boat was perpendicular to the slip again. I had to resort to handing off lines to my dockmates, ( who use the event as yet another reason to never, ever, take your boat out!) Any suggestions on what I could have done?
 
Nothing wrong with getting a helping hand. I recently had a problem halfway between Naples,FL and Marco Island, Fl. The port engine tach dropped to 300 and the boat shuddered. I shut it down and went the rest of the way on the stbd engine. When I pulled in, the slip was on my port and I wanted to back in. I got in close enough to sit on a port piling. I handed off lines to 2 or three dock hands and they tugged while I slowly assisted with some backing until we got it in the slip. Didn't bother me a bit. As long as I got it in safely was all that counted not the method. I got a diver to check the running gear and he brought up a 6ft x 3ft piece of heavy poly plastic black tarp which had wrapped itself around my port prop. He also said no damage was apparant.
 
First of all, do not be ashamed. Sooner or later everyone encounters difficulty. As to docking a twin screw on one engine, I'll pass and let someone who's actually done it comment on that.
 
This demonstrates that practicing typical docking maneuvers with only the port, then only the stbd engine, is a good idea. Maybe while waiting for guests to arrive or such. Keeps you on top of your game, and it is better then being bored while waiting for someone......
 
I did 500 plus miles on one engine including the Erie canal locks.
Got quite good at it after a while.

Liz, I don't get bored waiting for my guests, I tell them straight out that weather check is 1100 hrs, boarding is at 1200 hrs and departure is 1230 hrs. Don't call to say you are running late, I won't be there.
The Admiral's relatives only had to stare at an empty slip once to get the message.
 
quote:

I had to resort to handing off lines to my dock mates, Any suggestions on what I could have done?





You don't need any suggestions, you did what you had to do to get your vessel into the dock by utilizing your dock mates. Great job...don't beat yourself up!!!

Now with that said, one suggestion I can offer if you still where unable to get into your regular slip is to find a space where you can temporarily dock (fuel dock, restaurant dock, protected bulk head, an empty slip, ect...) until you can make repairs.

I'm not sure, but I think the law of the sea gives the mariner 48 hours to make repairs before someone can kick you off their dock.

Adam
 
never heard that one (48 hour law)... most marina have rules about vessels being seeaworthy and able to leave on their own but no hard deadline

backing in a twin on one engine isnt easy and must be practiced once in a while. if your fairway is narrow and the conditions are tricky (wind), you're better off coming in bow in, even it means you have to reset your lines or if you have trouble getting off the boat.

I practice it once in a while... my slip is to port when i come down the fairway, so coming on starboard only is easy. I just need to time my turn right. on starboard i turn hard over startboard as my bow gets to the slip before until I'm at a 45 deg angle. The starboard engine goes in reverse and hopefull, if timed right the boat slides right in, being straightened out by the starbord prop.

if i only have the port engine, it's much harder. I start turning much sooner to have the boat better lined up so that i can back up as straight in as possible.

there is a trick to back up a twin on one engine... Leave the rudders hard ove towards the dead engine. if stbd is out, put the rudders hard over to stbd. I know it doens't make any sense but in reverse, a low speed and without propwash your rudders dont do anything at all.

as you start backing up, the stern will obviosuly pull towards the dead engine so you briefly put it in fwd gear with a short burst of power to use prop wash to kick the stern aside. The trick is to balance your sternway momentum and the short burst of prop wash so that it doens't stop the boat, just kicks the stern. the other trick is to have the rudders hard over and leave them there so you dont' wast time swinging the wheel back and forth while jugling gear and throttle. and again you rudders do nothing in reverse anyway.

that's not going to get you to back up in a straight line, more like zig zqg motion but it's as close as you're going to get.

of course how your boat react will vary depending on hull shape, prop and rudder size, etc...

also, I find it much easier to turn before reaching the slip (even with both engines) then back in a straight line.. than stopping in the fairway and then backing in while turning 90 deg
 
Hey, you got into your dock without damage to your boat or a neighbor's boat. Sometimes stuff happens, part of boating. It's all the more reason to wait for a calm day, no wind or current and practice on one engine. Different boats handle different ways. All the more reason to learn how your boat responds to slow speed, close quarter situations. Usually with diesel power, you can use the engine and rudder to compensate for the lost engine. When this problem arises with a gas powered boat, you have to be very careful your good engine doesn't stall when applying quick throttle movements along with the prop direction change. Sometimes when conditions warrant, an alternate plan, like bow in or different dock are the only safe choices, use it!
 
We have a single engine trawler, and Pascal's method of backing in on one engine is dead on. My boat backs to the starboard, so I leave rudder full port while backing. Reverse, forward, reverse, forward. Looks funny, but it works. We call it the "mainship waddle".

-Ron
'97 Mainship 390
 
Back
Top