ICW Condition

"If traffic was to completly stop though our economy would plummit."
Dont get me wrong here, but how would our economy "plummet" all i ever see for commercial traffic going thru Little River are dredge barges and wood chip barges and alot of gambling boats,
 
Our wood chip habit would become very costly. LOL
I don't think commercial vessel traffic would stop, but if it did, then that waterway would be dredged pretty quick if it had an economic impact. Or the vessel traffic would be re-routed to another waterway. I saw how fast the rivers down here were cleared after Hurricanes Rita and Katrina. It can be done if needed.
 
The Gulf Coast ICW which runs from Brownsville TX to Carabelle, Florida is a very active commercial waterway system. There are a number of barges each day (at least 6 near where I live, more in Lousiania and Texas.) These barges carry mostly Coal, Benzine, Gasoline or diesel/heating oil. The GCICW connects with the river system and TennTom Waterway--Tennessee River, and other inland Waterways which go up to Great Lakes and Pittsburg (via the Ohio River), plus most of heartland America. The volume of traffic in some of the areas is considerable--not including the Mississippi River. However, the commercial parts of the Gulf Coast ICW is better maintained than the Atlantic ICW.

Although we speak of "Commercial" vs recreational...a 60 foot Hatteras going from New Jersey to Florida and Back each year generates a lot of commerace along the ICW during its passage.
 
I don't think you realize how much petroleum can be moved by one single barge! One jumbo tank barge can hold 30,000 barrels of product. Their is 42 gallons in a barrel of petroleum. You do the math. Yes the rivers can be cleared in a disaster but, In the process it takes a hell of a toll on the refineing industry. This is why the cost of Gasoline went up so rapidly after Hurricanes Rita and Katrina. As of now our economy is ran around the petroleum and chemical industry.The cost of stopping traffic on the waterways of the "United States" for an extended amount of time would not only effect chemical refinerys but it would effect manufacturing companys for various different products. Thier are many manufactures that use chemicals to make thier products. A big chemical that is used in a lot of stuff is Benzene. It is transported in mass quantities by barge daily. In my last comment I said that I didn't know the East Coast Waterways which includes Little River South Carolina. Product is also transported throughout the states by underground pipeline. Alot of that product comes from holding tanks that are filled from barges being pumped via water. If you think that our economy would not plummit do to the petroleum industry shutting down,then you are sadly mistaking. Product cannot be moved without petroleum to run the trucks and vessels that transport it everyday. Do we really want to depend on foriegn trade to have the things we need to survive? I don't think so! All im saying is that the ICW is and was origianlly designed for deep draft commercial traffic. "In my opinion" I don't think recreational traffic has a right to complain about the depth of the channel. Commercial vessel companys are the main source of income used to maintain channel depths. Vessels are taxed for every mile traveled on the ICW.
 
"I don't think recreational traffic has a right to complain about the depth of the channel"

I guess it depends on how deep your channel is;-)

Nixon was once asked what an acceptable level of unemployment is. He smiled and said I guess it depends on whether you have a job.
 
I don't think 12 to 15 ft. is considered deep draft. That is actually considered shallow.
Recreational vessels can complain about ICW conditions if you pay taxes. Our taxes pay for dredging also, not just commercial traffic taxes.
The cost went up after Katrina and Rita because of refining capacity shut down along the Houston Ship Channel, Mississippi, Sabine and Calcasieu rivers, pipelines from offshore platforms that parted and over 100 offshore platforms damaged or toppled. ICW conditions and barge traffic would have been considered minimal compared to the rest of the damage done during those storms.
 
OK Im done with this issue obviously we have a bunch of one uppers in this forum. I think I know what Im talking about. I work 240 days our of the year on a vessel on these waterways. My livelyhood depends on these issues. 12 to 15 ft. is not considered shallow. Look at the Rules of the Road set by the Coast Gaurd and you will find that a vessel with a draft that limits where it can navigate has the right of way in a narrow channel depending on the situation. Most channels are only maintaind at 12 ft. or more. How is that not deep draft?
 
" OK Im done with this issue obviously we have a bunch of one uppers in this forum"

one uppers? what part of DISCUSSION forum dont' you understand?

as a "pro" you should know there is no such concept as Right of Way in narrow channels and that the ROR are not SET by the USCG...
 
Depth is relative. 12' is too SHALLOW for most ocean-going vessels, even barges. However it's plenty DEEP enough for the vessels designed for it; and deeper than it needs to be for most pleasure boats.

Regardless of the ROR and who wrote em, any yachtsman who wants to play "rules" with a tow is a Darwin candidate.
 
"Regardless of the ROR and who wrote em, any yachtsman who wants to play "rules" with a tow is a Darwin candidate."

goes without saying...
 
We traversed the ditch from Ft Lauderdale to Norfolk last July and it is in dire condition. One set of destroyed props while still in Florida IN THE CHANNEL on a 4.5 foot draft boat... in the 1000 miles of the ICW, we saw exactly ONE working dredge, that at the south end of the Alligator-Pungo canal, where it was barely 5' deep. The ditch will soon be a mud flat without a LOT of help!!

Delaware Jim
 
Jim would running at high tide ease some of the concerns?
 
Georgia is supposed to have funds now to work on the ICW in our area, I have not seen or heard of any work going on yet, there are areas in Ga that you have to be careful in but for the most part it is still passable, for how long who knows, there are some ares that you should time for half tide or better for ease of travel.
 
Dan

yes, it helps to play the tides. In georgia for instance, Hell Gate and Little Mud River are probably the two worst spots. a couple of weeks ago, southbound, we left savannah at 7am to get to hell gate above mid tide (before 10am) and Little mud river on the rising tide (after 3pm). We were a little early but made it, just. Depending on the time of the tides, it can be a challenge to get it right and with low tide around midday, we did most of the running on that trip over skinny waters...

Jim, where did you hit something in FL? One bad spot i foudn was around Ponce inlet and New Smyrna Beach.
 
quote:

Originally posted by rdblan82

OK Im done with this issue obviously we have a bunch of one uppers in this forum. I think I know what Im talking about. I work 240 days our of the year on a vessel on these waterways. My livelyhood depends on these issues. 12 to 15 ft. is not considered shallow. Look at the Rules of the Road set by the Coast Gaurd and you will find that a vessel with a draft that limits where it can navigate has the right of way in a narrow channel depending on the situation. Most channels are only maintaind at 12 ft. or more. How is that not deep draft?






Not even close, hot rod. Are we talking 'vessels constrained by their draft', and in reference to Inland waters, or are we talking ColRegs waters?

Either which way, whether under the auspices of the Inland Navigation Rules or the International Regulations for the Prevention of Collision at Sea, no mention of right of way is made in reference to all but very few, specific waters. Also, as Pascal mentioned, the USCG is not a legislative body. They don't make the law (NavRules), but enforce them.

Please, this is a friendly forum, with a stunning volume of exchange of ideas, mostly prompted by new boaters and others seeking to improve their knowlege. There is very little 'one-upping' here, and you don't often see things getting personal. When they do, it's usually a miscommunication and resolved quickly. But like I said, a lot of new boaters and those looking to learn come here for answers, and they haven't been around here long enough to know who can generally be relied upon to provide accurate, sound advice, so when someone presents as a professional mariner, they have immediate credibility to new boaters, and anything that follows a remark indicating one is a professional, is taken as reliable fact. Thus, many of us here are sensitive to inaccurate information posted by 'professionals'.

Haven't seen you around these forums before, so welcome to BoaterEd! We really are all friendly people, even the Grumpy ones among us.

Pascal - "as a "pro" you should know there is no such concept as Right of Way in narrow channels and that the ROR are not SET by the USCG..."

You're starting to sound just like the GTBC!
 
Hi Dan,
We had the trip planned to travel during periods from a morning rising tide to afternoon dropping tide. However, a week stuck in Daytona Beach getting props repaired fouled up our plans completely. When the props were "destroyed", I was about 2+ hours before low tide in the middle of the channel with the depth finder reading a steady 7 feet (the digital finder updates about every 2 seconds) - was running just above idle - about 1000 rpm at 8-9 knots. Hit a shoal while it was still reading 7 feet. Boat draws ~4.5 feet...

Delaware Jim
 
Jim
Doesn't your boat have a keel? I would have thought you would push up a bit before hitting.
 
I just have to say that I have not posted any innacurate info. I have a copy of the ROR and have studied them in order to receive the officers licence that I hold. I use the term Right of Way to not confuse. The proper term is stand on & give way vessels if a vessel can not opperate outside a narrow channel due to thier draft it is considered a vessel restrained by its draft. Which in turn gives it the athority of the stand on vessel unless a vessel is restricted in its abilty to manuever due to the nature of her work. Sorry for the bit of hostility but I am certain that I know what I am talking about.
 
delaware if you draft close to 5 feet and are running 7-9mph the stern had to squat a bit i would think your running with less clearance than you think...........shallow water does some strange things to big boats i learned that in nj when testing a big boat with yanmars its struggled forever with tons of black smoke trying to get on plane in 8 feet of water must be some kind of suction or drag..... get in deeper water and it slid on plane no problem
 
My boat does that Kevin if I'm in less than 5 feet of water she will struggle to get up on plane anything over 5 and she pops right up on plane. This is over a soft bottom area of the Bay. The boat's normal draw is 3'6".

Bill
 
Back
Top