I have Star Insurance thru NBOA. 40 days after storm I had a check for full agreed value of boat plus personal property plus full haul-out costs. In addition they paid a $13K seatow bill. I couldn't be happier.
For the new boat, NBOA is quoting me rates from the same company with no increase except I am lowering my deductible and increasing my value. Star says since it was not my fault, they don't hold this incident against me and it seems the rates are not going up.
I think insurance companies have alot of money and this storm, though big, is a drop in a bucket compared to all other boats they insure and pay nothing on. This is what insurance is for. In my case there is no deductible for total loss. I hear some others are still waiting for checks!
Now with that said, if this storm ran coast and did what it did to NorthEast all the way from Florida up, then I think we could be looking at some insolvency!