Insurance

Remsberg

Member
Joined
May 24, 2006
RO Number
21391
Messages
79
It's renewal time and I'm shopping my policy on my 300 Sundancer and wondering if anyone can provide a recommendation. I have looked at Boat US, Progressive, United Marine but thinking there must be some boat specialists out here some of you have had good experience with? Hopefully this does not breech any forum rules...if so I apologize.

Thank You!
 
I have Inamar Recreational Marine Insurance, they are part of ACE insurance. I pay for a Yachtsman Policy that also covers major engine repair. I case of a failure, I pay the deductible and for the broken piece. Inamar picks up the rest of the rebuild or new engine. I have not had any claims since I started with them so I cannot tell you anything about that part of their business. I pay the premium on how much insurance I would like - not necessarily the value of the boat. That way there is no argument about replacement cost, etc.... If they total the boat, you get the value you insured it for.
 
The Florida market is still all screwed up. I had Inamar till last year, when they dubbled the rate so ended up going with Great Lakes (Loyds of London). My insurance is up for renewal mid next month and have not found anything better at this time.

Cor
 
I am on my third year with NBOA with no complaints. They are local in Sarasota - on North Trail.
 
WastinAweigh, "no complaints" ! Any claims??
Been with BoatUS for 20+ years; "NO Complaints"...... no claims either !
 
Bob,

Good point. Knock on wood, I have not had any claims with NBOA or with BoatUS prior to that, so I cannot speak to their claims service. The policy is with American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida and is rated "A", and I am not aware of any excessive complaints about their claims service.

BoatUS would be my first choice for insurance, but after the 2004 hurricane season they doubled their premiums to about $2,200 per year for a 26' sundancer. It was not possible to justify paying double just to stay with BoatUS (I believe that CNA was their carrier), so I went to NBOA/American Bankers. BoatUS simply wanted to reduce their Florida exposure, as is their right, and they priced the renewals to cause people to leave.

Insurance continues to be a problem in Florida. In the event of a catastrophic loss here, it is arguably most important to have a carrier that has the financial strength pay. For anyone shopping for insurance here, be sure to check the ratings of the actual carrier.

There isn't a great answer for insurance here - just the "least worst" of your choices.
 
As I have been shopping I have also gained a little insurance education. I'm sure most of you know these things but it sure doesn't hurt to spread learnings since likely someone new to boating can benefit and, as several have mentioned, a lot has changed in insurance especially Florida boating insurance. So here are a few things I have learned / relearned:

1. Some policies have a named storm exclusion so if a hurricane or T.S. wipes out your boat you have no coverage. Yikes!
2. Most policies now have a separate, much higher deductible for named storm damage. Often 7-10% of your boat value!
3. Understand the difference between replacement value and agreed value. No, you don't get a new boat like the one you lost and maybe not even the cost of your boat's book value if you are not careful. And "book values" are very different from carrier to carrier.
4. Like any insurance you can "buy down" your premium by increasing your deductible or reducing your coverages though if you have a note on your boat your lender will have something to say here.
5. Where you keep your boat matters! Not just geographically (where) but how (wet, dry, rack, trailer, etc.)

Lots to digest but the message is the fine print is worth reading. If it's too cheap to be true it probably has some hidden surprises.
 
I like Progressive. They have reasonalbe rates, no strange restrictions in the policy, and a great web site. Granted, I've never had a claim so I don't know how they perform there, but so far, so good.
 
Remsberg,

To add to your list:

How far offshore are you allowed to go? In the past I have been quoted as little as 5 miles. You can't clear the Boca Grande channel with that. On the west coast of Florida I think 25 miles is a reasonable minimum.

Good luck finding a renewal with less than a 10% deductible for named storms for a boat.

You also want to look at your spill liability, as that could very expensive very fast if your boat sinks.
 
Progressive it is. They have a $5K deductible for most events including named storm damage. I have used them in the past on my smaller boats and they are easy to work with though, like many of you, I have had no claims. Still a $600 / yr. savings over my renewal company and slightly more expansive coverage.
 
Ace of Inamar. Been in Florida 4 years no increases.No claims either.
 
Going with SeaInsure this year. They are affiliated with SeaTow.

I have increased laibility coverage, larger coverage area and am paying just slightly less than I did with National Marine Underwriters.
 
Insurance is great until you make a claim and need them to pay.

Bottom line is you get what you pay for. If you pay cheap, you most likely will get cheap when you need them.

I don't like Progressive because of the owners politcs. He is not a person I want to do business with.
 
Back
Top