Bob,
Good point. Knock on wood, I have not had any claims with NBOA or with BoatUS prior to that, so I cannot speak to their claims service. The policy is with American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida and is rated "A", and I am not aware of any excessive complaints about their claims service.
BoatUS would be my first choice for insurance, but after the 2004 hurricane season they doubled their premiums to about $2,200 per year for a 26' sundancer. It was not possible to justify paying double just to stay with BoatUS (I believe that CNA was their carrier), so I went to NBOA/American Bankers. BoatUS simply wanted to reduce their Florida exposure, as is their right, and they priced the renewals to cause people to leave.
Insurance continues to be a problem in Florida. In the event of a catastrophic loss here, it is arguably most important to have a carrier that has the financial strength pay. For anyone shopping for insurance here, be sure to check the ratings of the actual carrier.
There isn't a great answer for insurance here - just the "least worst" of your choices.