intake for the commode

dalehollow

Member
Joined
Jul 6, 2007
RO Number
27264
Messages
57
After not much water coming into the commode, I was told to replace the impelllar on the commode, when I took the old unit off I found the pump (2-3/4") diameter unit it was glooged with small materail suck through the line. Actualy in the pump

your suggestion as to solving this issue, I really dont want to go under the boat where the through hull pick up is from the lake and screen off. lastly is there a method for any of the debre that made it through the pump clogged the holes in the commode, which could restrict my bowl intake?

the 27$ impellar looks no better than the existing one, i guess im learning
 
Dalehollow,
On a boat, it's called a "head".
Ask you question over on the Marine Sanitation and Plumbing forum where Vic (the "head" expert) might see it and answer your questions.
 
Hey this is the hot new "head" of the future, all of the European manufacturers are installing it now.....

Commode.jpg
 
That would work for me if I could get it into the "head" room! My enclosed head is so small, I have to have my knees poking out of the doorway when I sit on the porta-potty. Oh well, better then a bucket!
 
please excuse my use of the wrong term for the ****ter, ill try not to be so thoughtless in the future, "is that graypu pon on your chin mate" ?
 
dalehollow:
cwms was just giving you the proper term for the (as you call it a ****ter)..He also gave you a good tip to post in the Marine Sanitation and Plumbing forum. Vic over there is very helpfull in regards to your type of question..
 
Carver2557,
thanks for the support.

FYI, I exchanged emails with dalehollow. He's thinking about taking out his head and putting in a household commode.
Let's not be too rough on him about this, but he needs to know why this is not a good idea.

There are so many reasons why this won't work...I can't think of any good reasons to do it.
 
OK a household toilet uses LOTS more water and will fill up your holding tank that much faster. And it probably won't flush through that little 1-1/2 inch line you have now which means you'll have to re-plumb the whole thing. Also a household toilet needs pressure water to operate so you'll have to hook it up to your pressure system (it'll waste a lot of water) or install a raw-water pump to supply it. The latter can still clog so you haven't accomplished all that much.

A simple strainer will solve the trash in the pump, just put it where you can get to it.

I'd recommend an electric head for convenience but it sounds like you already have one. If you have one of those noisy Jabscos you can remove the rubber impeller and install a separate pump down by the water line; it's a WHOLE LOT quieter and primes better too. You'll still need the strainer.
 
If household commodes were a good idea on a boat, the mfgrs would be installing them instead of more expensive boat heads. IMHO
 
A household commode is a gravity device and is just china with some holes in it and a water tank on top. It won’t pump waste to a holding tank. A marine head is a piece of machinery that is capable of collecting human waste and pumping it (sometimes uphill) to a holding tank.
 
ok i see the erro of my way, but for the record arent the new hosehold units down to a gallon and a half. I now understand the system better your right the household unit wouldnt get the **** to the holding tank, and if it would the pump out isnt going to well I apolgise for being a jerk
 
quote:

Originally posted by dalehollow

ok i see the erro of my way, but for the record arent the new hosehold units down to a gallon and a half. I now understand the system better your right the household unit wouldnt get the **** to the holding tank, and if it would the pump out isnt going to well I apolgise for being a jerk






No one said you are being a jerk and you haven't been one.
You sound like a boating newbie that just needs a little on the job training as far as boats go.
Sometimes we all get ideas that on the surface sound good, but with a little investigation, we realize the idea wasn't so good after all.
Anything you don't understand or feel you need some feedback, please don't hesitate to run it by us here on boatered. That's what we are all here for.
 
Back to the question--you can back flush the thru hull. I have done this with a garden hose from the dock. It is fairly easy to make an adaptor to put into the hose from the intake. Generally this is a 3/4" hose. If you are dealing with the 1 1/4 to 1 1/2" hose, that is the discharge hose, and an entirely different problem. Some folks like to put a cup of white vinager into the commode every month or so. Flush it thru the line to the holding tank.
 
OK, was the boat recently bottom painted? I've seen head intake screens completely plugged up by bottom paint so many times that's always the first thing I look for.
 
Now that we're back to the original question may I suggest a water hose from the pier. Wrap the nozzle with rags to provide a seal, stick the nozzle into the toilet and turn on the water. It has worked for me several times. Luck. Dale
 
Back
Top