Inverter recommendations

Thompson gunr

Member
exMember
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
RO Number
27420
Messages
300
I am looking to install an inverter in my boat to run some of my creature comforts while on hook. I do not have shore power so switch gear is not going to be a consideration. I will want to run (for short periods of time, one at a time) a microwave, coffee pot, blender, and the Admiral MAY want to run a hair dryer. (I will talk her out of that if possible.) I want recommendations about which inverter would be best in quality and capacity. Thanks
 
Not easy to answer so I'll give you my impression based on what you posted.

There are many choices for inverters- some good some cheap, few that are both. But, you really should think in terms of a "system", not just the inverter.

As important- is the battery bank your inverter will draw from. If your talking about some high draw devices (and you are), you really need a battery bank that's large enough to provide your total power demand (immediate current and total Amp Hours) with ony 50% of it's capacity. This can mean a fairly significant battery bank. Size,type and capacity should be determined before even selecting an inverter.

In the absense of shore power (I have to presume your never hooked up based on your statments) recharging a large battery bank fully is a concern... a smaller one less so. So recharging strategy needs to be considered as this will effect battery life... and the batteries are the only real consumable item in the system so you need to plan for routine, care and replacemnt.

Lastly- the inverter. If you want "any" device to work on board as if plugged in at home, you need to buy a good sine wave inverter. If you don't mind that some devices may not work as well (or at all) you can buy a cheaper modified sine wave inverter. In this lower cost catagory, there are good quality marine units like Heart/Xantrex and cheaper import ones that cost pennies per watt of output. I don't recommend the cheapies as many are of questionable quality end definitely not marine approved (although I've heard of guys that use them and are happy). From what you've posted, I would say you need a bare minimum of 2000 watts continuous... and with that, you are goinig to be limited to one load at a time on high draw devices.

Hope this helps.
 
Get yourself a Honda EU1000i and a couple CO detectors.
GenFun.jpg

IMG_2529.jpg

IMG_2534.jpg


The Honda will run everything above (one at a time) including the air conditioner.
http://www.geocities.com/jeff_nicholas/AirConditioning/Air1.html
 
I don't think I'd consider an inverter without either shore power or a genny. If you do get one you had best include a high power alternator so you can recharge from the main engine. Also consider battery isolators and adding battery capacity.
Consider a normal starting battery for a boat. If it's 80 amp hours, that means it can supply 80 amps for an hour. To get to 120 volts at 1 amp, you need 10 amps at 12v plus an efficiency of conversion factor. So the light bulb goes for about 8 hours minus losses etc..
Before you start buying anything add up the wattage and how long you intend to run it without recharging before you purchase anything. For a 120 watt light bulb, that would be 120 * 1 or 120 amp hours. Divide by ten and subtract that from your battery amp hours to see how long things can run. If you add batteries in parallel, you increase the amp ours. If you use 2 six volt batteries in series, you only get the individual amp hours.
 
To add to what Dan said if the battery is an 80 amp battery you should only draw it down 50% or you risk damaging the battery. So that 8 hours becomes 4 or lets say 3.5 due to conversion loss.

BTW - a coffee pot at 1500 watts pulls 12.5 amps at 120 vots so it needs 125 amps at 12 volts. Now your battery will last only 20 minutes or so and require several hours of running your engines to recharge it.
 
rommer, my Mr Coffee only uses 900 watts, and it takes 10 min to brew 12 cups. 900/6 = 150 watt/hrs consumed. at 110V that's about 1.5Amps. Inverter at 85% efficiency raises that to about 175 watts, at an average voltage of 11V ( high current draw, down rate battery voltage ) to = 16 Amps sucked from the battery. A type 29 ( Interstate SRM29 ) will yield 86 to 110 Amps total, depending on the rate of discharge, so figure 50 A total available.

Answer: After all that math slop means that one inverter, plus one type 29 battery will make three (3) pots of coffee before it needs a recharge...

--edit--

Note that adding batteries to the bank not only increases the total but reduces the rate of discharge per battery. So, one SRM29 will give 3 pots of coffee, while two SRM29 will give you seven!
 
"I will want to run (for short periods of time, one at a time) a microwave, coffee pot, blender, and the Admiral MAY want to run a hair dryer."

You do not state the actual consumption and time used, but here is a SWAG for ya:

Est one day usage:

1000 watt microwave ( actual about 1100 )_30 min/day = 550w
900 watt coffee maker, 2 pots of coffee___20 min/day = 300w
blender, wattage unknown. assume 1000w____10 min/day = 175w
1000w hairdryer ( small one )______________5 min/day = 100w

Total daily consumption = 1125 watt/hrs

Adjust for inverter efeciency at 85%. TDC = 1325 w/h

at 11 volts = 121 A

( Note: I have rounded, slightly, to make it marginally readable )

To ensure reasonable battery life, allow 50 A per battery ( SRM29 )

The above requirements would need a large enough inverter, 1100 minimum, plus three SRM29 batteries ( at 61 lbs each ) to provide the requested services for one day.

---

Then ya gotta charge it. It will likely take about 150 A/h to fully charge the bank...
 
Bill

One key point that you are overlooking is that the higher instantaneous current draw will cause a significant decrease in capacity. Drawing current at a rate higher than the available amp hours produces lots of heat.

The following snippets are from http://www.chem.hawaii.edu/uham/bat.html While I don't agree 100% with the ratios used the article does a decent job of showing how high current draw will reduce capacity by more than a little!

"Most batteries are rated in electrical capacity for a discharge rate of 20 hours. A 20 amp/hour battery should provide one amp of current for 20 hours before being fully discharged. It will still show a voltage, it will no longer be functioning correctly and if rechargeable, it will be in serious need of a recharge."

"A standard small car battery is about 45 amp/hours. That means that it will supply over two amps for 20 hours. A battery should not be discharged at a higher current draw, or asked to deliver more amps than its amp/hour rating divided by 10 in order to get maximum capacity out of it. In the case of a 45 amp/hour battery that would mean it should not be asked to deliver more than about 4 amps for best service."

"It is quite reasonable to discharge a battery at its amp/hour rating divided by six, or four, or maybe even three. So a 45 amp/hour battery could be used to power something that demanded 10 or 12 amps. But do not expect it to last four hours. These higher demand currents will cause extra loses in the internal resistance of the battery to go up, and the total capacity before the battery is fully discharged will be less at these higher rates. More power is lost heating up the battery for instance.

So, if you divide a battery's amp/hour rating by the current load you are going to put on it, you can estimate how long it will last. If you divide a battery's amp/hour rating by 20, you will find out how much current it can deliver and still live up to its capacity rating. If you divide a battery's amp/hour rating by four, you can estimate the maximum current you should expect such a battery to deliver and still have a reasonable life expectancy before it is fully discharged."
 
BTW - not disputing your math but the use of smaller capacity batteries changes the rules a bit.
 
rommer:

I thought I covered that: "A type 29 ( Interstate SRM29 ) will yield 86 to 110 Amps total, depending on the rate of discharge,"

Sorry I was unclear. Yes, a high rate of discharge very definitely has an unfavorable effect on the total capacity available for use. Those numbers are derived from the stated 5, 15, 25A discharge rate tables. Each battery brand/type will have it's own numbers, and there are many choices. I used the SRM 29 from Interstate simply because it is the one I am familiar with. I personally prefer to design the system so that the individual battery is loaded no more than 15A draw ( 10 % to 15% of total available capacity ), which seems to me to be a reasonable compromise of capacity and rate. For the boat I'm working on, the house is 6 to 8 SRM29, and keeps the individual rate fairly low.
 
I'm in the same position as the OP, with the exception of already owning a Yamaha EF-1000 generator (1995). I just installed, last week, a 2000 watt (4500 peak) pure sine wave inverter and 2 group 27 batteries (115 amp/hour each). My plan is to finish up in a week or two. My plan is to have 4 batteries total. I am using a battery switch and will have 2 batteries on each side of the switch. Depending on my usage I will pull power from only 2 batteries at a time. I normally only stay out on Saturday nights. If I feel I will need more power, I will pull from all 4. The reason for pulling from two is that it's easier to take two home to fully charge than taking 4 home. I have a 40 amp portable charger as well as a 15 amp marine charger. My objective is to run the inverter at night to power a tv/dvd/Xbox360 for a few hours. I will run the little genny in the morning to make coffee, recharge the batteries somewhat, and to top off the hot water (the genny does put out enough power for the water heater). I feel confident that my setup will work since I am not a big power user.
Things like a microwave, coffee pot, hair dryer demand a lot of power. The good news is that these items are not run for long periods of time and if run off the generator will not consume any battery life. My generator is small and needs at most to pulls on the rope to start it so it's not a big deal to start it. I use an extention cord from the generator to the shore power connector. I have a switch in the cabin where I can choose between the inverter or generator to supply power to the boat. I don't cook in a microwave; primarly use it to thaw things out. I don't use a hair dryer. I do use a coffee pot but may switch to one I can heat up over the alcohol stove. Having the inverter providing 110v at the flick of a switch is well worth the hassel of taking batteries home or hearing the low rumble of a generator.
 
quote:

Originally posted by JeffNick

Get yourself a Honda EU1000i and a couple CO detectors.
The Honda will run everything above (one at a time) including the air conditioner.
http://www.geocities.com/jeff_nicholas/AirConditioning/Air1.html






Jim, I looked at your website. If I wasn't impressed with that a/c unit install, the windbreaker/Michelin Man picture sure did it!

Some darn ingenious ideas you've brought to life there.
 
I currently have a pair of SRM29 batteries. It looks like by what everyone says, I will need at least 3 which will mean a different battery selector switch and also the cost of the inverter. I liked the idea of having silent power on demand which was why I was steering myself away from a generator. I am like others on the site, I like having the peace and quiet while on hook. The silence and getting away from it all is one of the reasons I boat in the first place. I guess it just meand more $! I currently have a high output alternator rated at 160 amps. There is a larger 200 amp model available too. Maybe I will step up and get that one too. My actual appliance useage will be small. We generally are on hook from Friday night to Sunday morning. During that time we only use the stereo and a few lights at night. The majority of my cooking needs are handled with the grill. The microwave will be about the most used item on the inverter. Maybe there can be a different way to boat that involves changing on hook locations nightly. This would allow more charge time on the batteries and would help if I get the 200 amp charger.
 
160 amp alternator should be good. I believe batteries should only be charged at 1/4 their amp/hr rating. 100 amp/hr battery should be charged at 25 amps max. An exception would be AGM's. They can take a much heavier recharge rate. If you know the manufacture you should be able to find out how much the alternator will put out as the engine idles. Keep in mind the alternator's rpms will be much higher than engine rpms. To find the ratio measure the diameter of the alternator pulley and the crank. Divide the crank measurement by the alternator (should be between 2 and 3 times). Multiply that by engine rpm and you have the alternator rpm.
 
"...which will mean a different battery selector switch "

Actually, not necessarily. Place the three house batteries, in -parallel-, on the same switch to create a "~300A 12v house bank".

Keep other items, off of the house bank. ( ie: each engine gets a battery < bank > plus the house <bank> . Two engines, three banks. )
 
Bill isn't that where the isolator comes into play? Separate the house bank from the cranking battery?
 
The isolator keeps the "loops" separate. It all depends on how it is wired. There is my way and many other ways of doing this. One of them is a good way... :) <really big grin>

--edit--

Maybe that was a bit ?rude?

Separate your loads into eng 1, eng 2, and house ( if elaborate, house for A/C, house for 12v DC ).

Then hook the loads to their intended bank. At this point, all is separate, and nothing gets charged!

One decision is will one or both engines charge. I'll discuss one ( it is easier, but two is similar )

Each engine will charge it's own battery <bank>. That leaves us with how to charge the house.

If using a combiner, connect the combiner between an engine bank, and the house. When the charger is active, and the start battery is near charged, the combiner will connect the two banks, allowing the house to get charged. ( Yes, there, are, in detail issues with this, but that is another thread ). In many cases this is the desirable method.

If using an isolator ( bank of large diodes ) The charger is applied to the in side and there is one out for each bank ( in this case, one eng, one house ) The house never connects directly to the eng bank and vice versa.

One issue with an isolator is the voltage drop across the diodes, about 0.7 V ( about 8% ) This is enough that neither battery will -ever- fully charge. Thus the sense wire. The sense wire is connected tothe alternator, and tells it "how hard to work". If it is on the alternator side, then the battery voltages will below. It must be connected to one of the output legs ( causing the alternator to output 0.7 V higher and overcome the voltage drop ). Still, you have to choose which output leg ( remember each leg is isolated from the other ). The usual choice is to sense the house side. Not alternators have a regulator that easily allows this, though many do. Read The Fabulous Manual. In this case it is important.

Whew. I need a NiceCuppaCoffee.

--edit, again --

You will notice I said nothing about switches.

If done as above, you will have a simple heavy duty on/off cutoff switch for each bank. ( preferably, each battery ). There is no "1-2-All" switch used/needed. There are -many- variations you can use to achieve the desired results for special situations, but it can ( read that "will" ) get complicated.

Here is a link to one mfgr's isolator wiring diagram <PDF>. Most are similar.
 
I have the Honda generator.

Can anyone tell me where to buy the connection from the generator to the shorepower?

Thanks
 
Why would you want to connect your gen to shore power? Unless of course you plan on selling power back to the utility company. :-)
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Bill1

Why would you want to connect your gen to shore power?





He's probably talking about a cable to run from the genset to the shore power plug already on the boat.

Like this one: http://www.marinco.com/scpt/ProdPage.php?loadItem=104SPP_Marinco Shore Power

or this: http://www.marinco.com/scpt/ProdPage.php?loadItem=83A_Marinco Shore Power

I believe there are also 30A (the boat locking kind) to 15A (regular household plug) cables with the appropriate connectors already on each end. If the boat has built-in AC wiring then using the pigtail adapter with their existing 30A shore power cable would be the simplest. That way they wouldn't have to carry another cable solely for the genset (just the pigtail). That and using the longer shore power cord would give them the option of moving the genset to a better location to avoid CO fumes.

Personally I think the whole use of a genset like this is a bad idea. But plenty of folks do it and their stupidity hasn't killed them... yet.
 
Back
Top