IPS vrs Thruster's

kbradatzke

Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2006
RO Number
22986
Messages
70
I am looking at moving up to a flybridge in the 34-36 range. My question is how does a boat such as the Merdian 341 ( with bow and stern thrusters) handle for docking against something with the IPS drives. We have looked at a new Merdian , but have also seen a 2006 Carver with IPS . Of coarse the Carver is 4 longer and more money . Is it worth it?
 
comparing ease of docking between twin inboards is like asking if it's easier to write your name with a pencil or a pen. irrelevant... twins are the most easy boats to dock even without thrusters.

you need to look at what matters... extra space, IPS benefits incl better fuel economy, engine room accessibility, deck accessibility and safety, etc... ease of handling is a non issue on twins.

are they both diesel ? I know the IPS has to be since no gas IPS are on the market yet, but it the meridian diesel ?
 
There is a learning curve when jumping from a single engine to twins (as It appears to be your case, still driving the SR single?) Once you feel fine with your inboards (as you will) you will see that neither IPS/thrusters are needed on that size boat (as Pascal stated)
 
Also keep in mind, that the Carver 36 SS is avaiable in gas power that has bow and stern thrusters standard. I agree though...especially on the Carver, that the thrusters are not needed, but are welcome in some situations.
 
Probably going to get ribbed for this one but I cant resist....If you need bow and stern thrusters on a boat under 70-80 feet, you probably shouldn't be captaining a boat of that size just yet!
 
Carver370, Thanks, you said it for me. Seems people today just want to jump into a boat and drive away, docking is only one thing you need to learn, they don't want to learn that or any of the rest of it either.
 
I have run 74 Hatteras' that dont have a bow or stern thruster without any complications. I am a broker and I am constantly asked if this 35 foot boat or 32 foot boat for that matter has a bow thruster....I did a sea trial on a 420 Sundancer yesterday and it was equipped with a bow thruster, the buyer asked why I wasn't using it and I told him I never have used one before and I'm not starting any time soon!
 
kbradatzke,

That's a good question and many here have asked about the difference in handling a twin screw vrs IPS. If you NEVER used an IPS and have used twins only you might have a small learning curve. If you only used a single I/O and try twins you might have a small learning curve. MY point is you can learn them all easy enough.

Bow and stern thrusters with twins are minimal help at best and in high wind and current useless.
Some say pod drives have limits in high wind and currents.
Twins only have been proven solid with the right training and time.

One thing for sure is the price. The Pods will cost more.

Both boats are good and it comes down to your taste etc .
 
IPS is another improvment over previous systems. It is not necessary, just as an automatic transmission is not necessary in a car.
For those so dead set against IPS or thrusters etc I'll point out that real boaters can dock under sail alone.
 
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Boater may refer to:
Boater (hat), a type of hat
Someone involved in the recreational activity called boating

So someone who docks under sail must be involved in a REAL recreational activity
 
No one has answered your question so I will.

The Meridian 'docking on command' feature works well. It should move your boat as well as the IPS's will, just differently.
I have found that keeping the throttles a bit above idle on a Meridian and just bumping it in and out of gear works the best.

Both systems work great, make your decison based upon what you can afford.

Make sure you can handle the Meridian without needing the thrusters, you don't have to dock pretty just safely.
If they should fail you won't be helpless.

As a side note my 42 came with both bow and stern thrusters, and everyone is right, I do not need either.
HOWEVER, when I screw up (and I have) it sure is nice to be able to lay both sticks full over.
Yeah I know I can use the engines to pull out and try again, but its a lot less hassel using the 'cheaters'.

Jim

2004 SR 420 DA
 
quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

IPS is another improvment over previous systems. It is not necessary, just as an automatic transmission is not necessary in a car.
For those so dead set against IPS or thrusters etc I'll point out that real boaters can dock under sail alone.




I totally agree. Are we not 'real' drivers nowadays because we have automatic transmissions, don't have to hand crank engines to start them, have push-button or automatic 4x4?

Who cares? Does having the increased confidence that thrusters or IPS might provide in particular boat handling situations preclude a person from knowing ROR or being a good boater? Gimme a break.

One of my dock neighbors has a bow thruster on his new 340 DA. It's like training wheels. He never uses the thruster anymore. He likes knowing it's there, but does not rely on it. Now, when he goes to sell that boat, don't you think he has a better chance of appealing to a wider buying audience with that feature? Of course he will.

It only take one bad mishap at the dock on a large boat to sully one's affection (be it the captain or admiral--or both) for the boat or boating altogether. If that can be avoided, for some, via the use of thrusters, then why discourage it? Yes, learn to operate without them, but they can be mighty helpful during the learning curve.

To the original question-- I picture IPS on a scale. 1-being docking a large boat with a single screw (something along those lines) 10-being pushing a button, and then sitting back with you arms folded while the boat automatically docks itself (doesn't exist yet, but if they can do it with cars, it's gotta be a matter of time). If thrusters are a 6 on that scale, IPS is an 8. It automatically controls the props and thruster(s); you just tell it where you want to go.
 
Pascal,
IPS is now available in 8.1 gas engines. Many manufacturere are just starting to offer it. I am assuming price should drop drastically compared to the diesel engine.
 
Gary, yes, Gas IPS are about to be available but since the oroginal post mentioned a 2006 IPS equipped Carver, he must me looking at a diesel. Just wanted to make sure we're comparing apples to apples and not comparing the price of a gas inboard with a larger diesel IPS...
 
I can't offer any technical advice regarding either system as I have no experience. But as to JimPend and Carvers point, I don't see any mention in the posters question about him "needing" either system or having any expectation of "just jumping in". He asked a simple question about what system whas likely to be more useful and if IPS was worth the extra money.

Every now and then the aire of superiority comes up from posters here who like to pretend they are better or more deserving of being boaters because of there superior skill. It sure gets tiring.

I guess until we can all dock a 100ft boat while standing on our heads spitting wooden nickles, we have no business being on the water.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Prospective

I can't offer any technical advice regarding either system as I have no experience. But as to JimPend and Carvers point, I don't see any mention in the posters question about him "needing" either system or having any expectation of "just jumping in". He asked a simple question about what system whas likely to be more useful and if IPS was worth the extra money.

Every now and then the aire of superiority comes up from posters here who like to pretend they are better or more deserving of being boaters because of there superior skill. It sure gets tiring.

I guess until we can all dock a 100ft boat while standing on our heads spitting wooden nickles, we have no business being on the water.




+1
 
quote:

I totally agree. Are we not 'real' drivers nowadays because we have automatic transmissions, don't have to hand crank engines to start them, have push-button or automatic 4x4?

Who cares? Does having the increased confidence that thrusters or IPS might provide in particular boat handling situations preclude a person from knowing ROR or being a good boater? Gimme a break.

One of my dock neighbors has a bow thruster on his new 340 DA. It's like training wheels. He never uses the thruster anymore. He likes knowing it's there, but does not rely on it. Now, when he goes to sell that boat, don't you think he has a better chance of appealing to a wider buying audience with that feature? Of course he will.

It only take one bad mishap at the dock on a large boat to sully one's affection (be it the captain or admiral--or both) for the boat or boating altogether. If that can be avoided, for some, via the use of thrusters, then why discourage it? Yes, learn to operate without them, but they can be mighty helpful during the learning curve.





Austin - you beat me to it. Great response and great point about the resale value.
 
An interesting note about IPS is that it does not in fact integrate the control of thrusters - it precludes them. Even the largest IPS boats, such as Lazzara's 75 LSX, can perform with thruster-like agility, with IPS alone - they don't have bow or stern thrusters.
 
quote:

Originally posted by SLW

An interesting note about IPS is that it does not in fact integrate the control of thrusters - it precludes them. Even the largest IPS boats, such as Lazzara's 75 LSX, can perform with thruster-like agility, with IPS alone - they don't have bow or stern thrusters.




Great point and thanks for the clarification.

Paul
 
If I were shopping I'd get the IPS. That and I'd go for a Carver over a Meridian.
 
Back
Top