IPS vs a rock

Looks like they got into skinny water and hammered the props against something a few time. A rock...maybe...I expect a few chunks of the blade to be missing if it was. Although I'm not sold on IPS yet, I think the author is being a bit harsh in their opinion of how the drive performed. Not shearing off and gaskets not sealing make me wonder what he thinks should happen...I still think the designers were a bit tipsy when deciding to face the props forward...It just looks wrong.. LOL
 
I have always been concerned about how to pull a IPS boat off after a hard grounding.

I'm sure the pods are very strong but the weight of the boat, the pounding from passing wakes and then being pulled through sand or rock must take a serious toll on the units.
 
A large collection of rocks - also known as sand or gravel. The weight of the boat held the drives in place as they drove onto the sand bar. My guess.
 
"Not shearing off and gaskets not sealing make me wonder what he thinks should happen..."

It should of happend

from Volvo
In the high-speed scenario, the leg and pod will shear off flush with the hull. The lower bearing carrier has been engineered specially to break at a point below the O-ring seal between the fixed and steerable parts of the drive. As the leg bends backwards, the vertical drive shaft simply pulls out of its spline. The inside of the transmission is now open to the ocean but no water can escape into the boat and the vital mounting joint between transmission and hull will remain not only intact but undamaged thanks to the energy absorption of the big twin O-rings
 
I'm not a big fan. My outdrive hits a submerged log, it blows a bypass seal and tilts up. I pay to repair the tilt unit. An IPS hits a log and it is supposed to shear off? I'm buying a new drive. Or if it doesnt shear off, I'm replacing a set of props. Or you have this scenario...

Scary...
 
sounds like the engineers at Volvo are going to need to do some more field tests or make better specs for mounting the drives. i'm sure its a very delicate balance between making the drive the sacrafical element and not falling off the moment it touches bottom.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Shadowcruzr

I'm not a big fan. My outdrive hits a submerged log, it blows a bypass seal and tilts up. I pay to repair the tilt unit. An IPS hits a log and it is supposed to shear off? I'm buying a new drive. Or if it doesnt shear off, I'm replacing a set of props. Or you have this scenario...

Scary...






Comparing an outdrive to an pod is a bit of a stretch. There's a limit to the size boat for which an outdrive is practical. An inboard's props are going to have major damage as well, which is a closer comparison. The Zeus system doesn't kick up, either.
 
Years back I remember a story of a Tiara with IPS drives that hit a sand bar and a similar thing happened. The drives didn't shear off and the impact caused serious bodily harm to the passengers.
 
looks like a crack across the hull ahead of the drives in pix 12:42
 
I would tend to point the finger at the boater rather than the boat. I lived in Thailand for 5 years and my wife, in fact is Thai. I did lots of boating while there and have witnessed first hand how 99% of the boaters there operate their vessels. Trust me when I tell you, they, for the most part, make sunday jetski riders look like granny in a canoe.

LOTS of rocks in Southern Thai waters and almost no markers of any kind. Hit a rock or whatever at WOT, which is about the only speed they know, and it will destroy the running gear. I don't care what kind it is. Plus, I would almost bet you this boat was being used for "For Hire" passenger carrying.

quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Bill1




 
It clearly is the numb nut captain who caused the damage and not the drive design. How much water does a shaft and skeg let in after a grounding???? Comparing with outboards makes no sense, the pod drives are designed to replace shaft drives and their drag through the water. You can compare outboards to surface piercing drives as both are mounted behind the boat and not underneath.
 
I remember asking the expert opinion of the machinist who helped me with my engine refit about the IPS/Zeus coneepts back in 2005 when they were getting all the media attention.

He said they would be a bad item for folks who boated in skinny water.

IMHO - "It looked good on paper"

RWS
 
I suppose as with a high performance aircraft, the pilot must be more proficient then the training aircraft he learned in.

With the IPS drives, the operator must be skilled enough to remain in navigable waters and keep a sharp lookout at all times for floating debris

Definitely not as forgiving as the old 70 hp Johnson! A small mistake will be very costly.
 
The article says "Luckily this boat is built with a watertight compartment enclosing the engines and drives. If the boat had not had this feature then it would have sunk before help could have arrived". This was a 47' boat down to what size boat would a watertight engine compartment be practical?
 
He makes one compelling argument, which is if you are going to be in a remote area, you stand a better chance of getting repairs and parts with a traditional shaft and strut system.
 
I delivered a 5260 Regal from Toronto to Duluth MN last September. It did make me a little nervous to note the warning on the Lake Superior chart about the large number of floaing logs and deadheads.

I was the first time I had run aboat with IPS and I gotta tell ya....its a hoot in some really tight marinas to whip a boat around like its on rails.
 
Floating wood, tree branches, firewood, pieces of dock board are are going to be encountered on rivers and near the mouths of rivers. No matter how careful you are, you will encounter wood strikes. I have hit plenty. When wood hits the front of on outdrive the stern of the boat gets pushed up as the boat attempts to get over the object like going over a bump. This isn't going to happen with a pod forward facing prop. The wood is going to get jammed between the prop and the hull. No way for the boat ride over it. And, the wood is sure to hit the props as it twists away. With an outdrive, there have many times when the wood has hit the drive and been deflected with no or little damage to the prop. I think we are going to insurance rates go up and expensive repairs on the Volvo pods.
 
It looks to me that the mountings for the drive let go. Look at how they are shiffed that is why it was leaking, that is not a Volvo problem but a weak installation. Volvo put the props upfront because the props work better in "clean" water just like a propeller on an airplane. These systems are for the bigger boats and you do not use the big boat the same way you use your small one, no beaching!! Hitting something is almost always bad news, look at Pascal he bumped bottom and now he has to have the props fixed.

Cor
 
"With the IPS drives, the operator must be skilled enough to remain in navigable waters and keep a sharp lookout at all times for floating debris Definitely not as forgiving as the old 70 hp Johnson! A small mistake will be very costly."

you're comparing apples to oranges... mistakes with inboards are also costly, you cant' compare IPS to outboard, but to inboards.

whoever put together this page is a complete idiot, a high speed impact on rocks with an inboard boat will rip the running gear and result in the boat to flood...

there is more to the story.
 
Back
Top