launch delayed- help with batteries needed

Cobalt 25

Member
exMember
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
471
Messages
361
Anyone for fried batteries?

Last December I trickle charged both batteries fully. Today (after powering up the seat to get to the engine compartment) when placing the clamp on the positive on battery 1, I noticed more sparking than usual. Then, when hooked up, the gauge on the charger registered zero, which it has never done before. It was then I noticed the positive post on battery 2 had melted into a pool of what looked like solder and was completely disconnected from the cable. Upon further inspection of battery 1, I noticed a small pool of "solder" at the base of the positive pole.

I put the volt meter on battery 1 and it read 12 volts. I put the meter on battery 2 and the needle went backwards. I also found that the Perko dual-battery switch moved freely to position 1 and Both, but would not move to 2.
Unfortunately I cannot be certain of what actually is battery 1 and battery 2. They both worked fine so I never bothered to actually figure out which was which. One was new in 2001 and the other about 2005.

Replacing both batteries would be financially painful but the big question is- what the heck happened and how do I prevent a repeat performance. Help!

Let me know if you need additional info...

thanks, Peter
 
at first glance.

it soulds like battery reversed polarity during the layup period. the battery switch may have acted as a fuse ad welded itself with the contacts being the weakest conductor. I would imagine the cables are rock hard now and also need replacing.

either way you need to look very closly now at all of your wiring.
 
I'll GUESS that one of the batteries developed an internal short and discharged, and that the other one tried to "charge" the shorted battery. My guess is they're both fried. Disconnecting them when you put the boat up for the winter would probably help prevent a recurrence of BOTH batteries going, but it probably wouldn't stop ONE from self-destructing.

However there MAY be a dead short somewhere else on the boat (causing the problem). I'd check it out thoroughly before connecting new batteries.

Consider yourself lucky you didn't have a fire... it take a lot of juice to melt a battery post!
 
Replacing the batteries might end up being the "cheap" part of this repair. There is a good chance that some other parts and wires might need replacing. This one might get interesting.

Ken
 
Whoa! I'm with Willie on a couple of counts. First, you're lucky you didn't have a fire. Second, I would also suspect a short. My first guess would be an internal short in one of the batteries. But, you could have a short on your boat.

You need to approach this very carefully. First, it sounds like the batteries are shot. Second, you need to determine if the switch is gone as well. It could be a victim of a short or it could be the source of a short (not liekly, but possible). Next, you need to check your wiring very carefully for any evidence of overheating or damage from excessive current. Check over your battery cables, main engine connecting cables and anything that is normally powered with the battery switches off (bilge pumps, radio memory, etc.).

From your description, I suspect you will need to replace the switch. After all of that is put right, connect one battery positive and then put a DC ammeter in between the negative cable and the negative post on the battery, and then turn the switch on to that battery. You should see a very short spike current and then a few milliamps. If you see nothing, your meter may have blown a fuse on a big current spike. If you see anything large, or a sustained current over a few mA, turn the switch off, disconnect the battery, and start looking for a short.
 
Thanks for all the input. You are right, Sublimetime, this is a good one.

That's because an idiot (me) reversed connections. When I went back to the boat tonight I discovered my stupidity.

Now that you guys know the cause, do I need to replace one battery, two batteries, the Perko switch? What tests should I run to determine what needs to be replaced? I did not think to check cables.

thanks, Peter

P.S. You are right about how lucky I was not to have a fire!
 
"do I need to replace one battery, two batteries, the Perko switch?"

Yes. All batteries, the switch, and possible some wiring.
 
Glan you found the issue. I was going to say I don't think it was a short circut. It sure as shxt would have burned up a 12 gauge wire or blew a fuse well before melting a battery connector. The only thing having a large conductive wire to do that would have been the starter.
You already mentioned the switch has difficulty in moving to position 2. I would guess its shot and put that in the budget. Pull it out and take a look at it, it will have to come if you replace it. I imagine you exceeded its capability and should be changed. As for the batteries, the one with the wrong voltage is shot. Charge the other one and see how it works or take it with you when buying the other battery and have then checked it out. As a side note: when using a new and old battery do not run them in the both position (unless you need both to start the engine). The new battery will start to behave like the old battery.
 
Bat 1 has melted terminal. It is toast. Bat 2 has reversed polarity. While it could possibly be "fixed", it's useful life has been greatly shortened ( or terminated ). Replace both.

The switch is no longer reliable; replace it.

Due to the fact that temps and current got high enough to melt lead ( the terminal ), the possibility exists that some wiring has been toasted. It needs close inspection, and replacement of annealed sections and sections with damaged insulation.
 
In my first post I started to ask if you had maybe connected a battery backwards but then thought nah ... that would be too obvious.

Radioactive is correct - both batts and probably the switch. If I have this right, and I well may not, basically what you did was connect the two batteries in series through the engine ground creating a 24 volt battery pack and then shorted the circuit through the switch. That could really fry some things, and definitely the batteries. These must be decent quality batteries - I have seen shorted 12V batteries actually explode when shorted.

On the cable checks, look at everything that is connected to the batteries all the way to engine ground, check the alternator and starter wiring too. Also, you need to examine any wiring that is connected to the batteries before the switch. What is not clear to me is what might have happened on the other side of the switch. My suspicion is that it should be okay, but you just don't know. Give it a close look and test everything that runs on 12V DC. If you find something that doesn't work, first look for a fuse or circuit breaker.

When you do get around to starting it, watch the alternator charging gauge closely to verify that it is charging properly.
 
Thanks, guys, for very helpful information.

I will keep you posted as to what I find.

Peter
 
Replaced both batteries and switch. All electrical units functioning properly, including VHF, GPS, and ammeter.

Had great first-of-the-season outing.

Will work on proper connectivity in the future!

Peter
 
Back
Top