Led all around help

hackalar

Member
Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2005
RO Number
16331
Messages
215
I bought a new all around led light to replace the old two bulb on the boat. Question is.. It only has two wires vs the old one has 3. Anchor and travel. Can I wire the two positive on the boat to the single positive?
 
You bought the wrong light. :(

If you had two lamps, each wired separately, for anchor and running, then you need a LED fixture that will offer the same feature. While you -can- wire the fixture so that either switch ( sw position ) will cause it to light up, you will be presenting the incorrect lights while running...

You need the correct fixture. What you need is a "masthead fixture" rather than an "all-around white" fixture.
 
Just so I'm clear. The light I am removing is a single fixture with two bulbs in it. Would it not be ok to replace with a single led with 2nm output?
 
Does anybody sale a masthead fixture that is led that doesn't cost 400.00?
 
If the boat was originally wired for two independently switched bulbs then it was wired as a "masthead light".

In the "anchor" position, one bulb would light and offer 360 deg viewing.
In the "travel" position, the other bulb would light up instead, and it would have been "blinkered" so that there was only a 225 deg field of view. ( OR the travel lamp had a 135 deg view, and the other had a 225 deg view, and when in the "anchor" position, -both- would light. Different method, same result )

---

See the RoR Rule 21 and 23 for details... but some vessels may use either a single all-around light when running ( this doubles as an anchor light ) OR, when running they may use a "split-lighting" method, where the masthead presents the forward 225 degrees, and a light on the transom fills in "the hole" presenting 135 degrees from the transom.

--

"Would it not be ok to replace with a single led with 2nm output?"

See the Rules comment above. you may be an "option boat, but if you change the masthead light to an all-around ( when running ) you will need to disable the transom light. Personally, I greatly prefer the "split method" to the sing all-around. YMMV. Check the RoR to see where your boat fits in the rules.

Mostly, the "right" answer it trade in the all-around for a masthead and upgrade it that way. Switching is, imho, a move backward, and would involve more work, or would leave a hole or a dunsil in the transom.
 
Thank you so much for all answers! I will trade back in and get the direct replacement. My boat does not have the transom light. I wish it did.
 
Hmmm, hold on a sec...

If you have no transom light ( and no "pole mount" built in on the aft coaming ) perhaps, even though you had multiple wires exiting the fixture, you -may- have been using it as an "all-around" for both switch positions ( and the fixture simply used two bulbs under all circumstances. Some do ). In which case, you have the correct light!

you may need to do a little more checking on the boat, and I need more info...

--

If the boat is less than 20 meters ( 65 ft ) then we can pick either option.

In what way did the lights function prior to you removing them?

If the two bulbs were lit in either switch position, and the fixture presented 360 either way, you were using the "all-around" option. In which case, you can likely wire the two hot leads together and use the current new fixture.

You will NEED TO TEST to make sure that the Red/Green sidelights only operate while the switch is in the "travel" position, and that you are displaying an all-around white in either travel or anchor switch position.

---

Part of this mess comes up because boat mfgrs use "standardized" wiring harnesses for many similar models. The wiring harness "pre-wires" the boat for any of the possible combinations. Easier to build, more difficult to service/maintain.

( My boat, when delivered actually used both a two-part masthead fixture AND a transom light. ie: wrong. It certainly had the harness for either... )

Mostly, YOU need to decide which of the two options you will use. If you already do not have a transom light, then I would choose the "all-around white" option. If you DO have a transom light, then you need the proper complimentary masthead fixture. Do not mix systems. Remember the true reason for carrying proper nav lighting is so that you can be identified at night by other vessels. The fact that the "gendarmes" might ticket you if you have it wrong really is not all that important ( relative to the proper lighting's safety function ).
 
Low-draw navigation lights are not that critical of an issue for powerboats. The engine and alternator are operating and suppling power while nav lights are in use. Nav light draw for boats under sail is always more of a consideration. So is a low-draw anchor light for most boats.

Here are a couple of solutions that will cost you under $50 each.

1. If you have a 360 degree (all-round) masthead white light bulb that serves as anchor light you may replace it with a drop-in LED array. These are made as specific retrofits for marine incandescent and halogen bulbs. The best marine LED arrays offer similar or greater light output and color temperature as the OEM bulbs and feature constant current operation over a wide DC voltage range (like 10-30VDC). I recommend Marinebeam for quality LED replacement of navigation or anchor bulbs.

2. If a LED replacement bulb is not available for your light model yet or you just want to do it quick and dirty for under $50 (like I did), a lot of power and sail boats at anchor do just this...

Get the Davis Instruments Mega-Light model with the lamp hook and 12-VDC plug. I also suggest the aftermarket Marinebeam LED replacement bulb. Leave your masthead and other nav lighting as is and turned off while overnight at anchor.

Plug one end of the Mega-Light into the 12V socket on your bridge. Hang the business end of the Mega-Light off the radar arch or someplace high enough that it will be seen for 360 degrees.

The Mega-Light will use its built-in photosensitive switch to turn the light on at dusk and off at dawn. Keep it plugged in as long as you are at anchor if you like.

I hard wired our Mega-Light.

http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=130105
 
My 30' boat came with a masthead light with two bulbs; one for 225 and one for 135. Strangely, there was no way to get 360 degrees of coverage in an 'anchor' mode without having the running lights on. I rewired it so that both bulbs would come on at once and thus provide an anchor light as well as an all-around (as per ROR for vessels under 12 meters). It sounds like your masthead light is similar? Regardless, I fully agree with yzer. Try and find replacement LED bulbs for your existing fixture. I just upgraded from two LED bulbs that weren't performing as I wanted to some extremely bright ones at $10 each. If you can let us know what type of bulb you need to replace, I'm sure yzer and I would be happy to help you find the LED equivalent.

yzer - a photo sensor is a great thing on an anchor light, isn't it? I installed a "Night Watchman" sensor a few years ago and love it. The best money I ever spent.

(note, this photo is larger than the actual unit, which is only about a wide as a quarter)

Nightwatch.JPG
 
I agree. It's great to be sitting on a neighboring boat enjoying a cocktail at sunset and seeing your anchor light turn on by itself.
 
My boat is a 1995 Silverton 361 express. The curent fixture is old dirty and bent (like me) and needs replaced. We like to spend hours at anchor and thought it would be good to go to led. However we never spend the night on anchor. We are on the Tennessee river and am not sure if it's legal to do so? Have never seen anybody stay night on anchor around here.

I'm going to boat today and will check the lighting and switch out to see how it acts.
 
quote:

Originally posted by yzer

I agree. It's great to be sitting on a neighboring boat enjoying a cocktail at sunset and seeing your anchor light turn on by itself.






It's also nice to have it go off in the morning so you're not the dork of the anchorage come Noon time :-)
 
I do not see any data at the Marine Beam sight about RF interferance. Using Pulse Width Modulation will create RF and interfere with radio reception. They also say they do not have a housing that would eliminate condensation or water on the LED circuits.
 
quote:

Originally posted by solar

I do not see any data at the Marine Beam sight about RF interferance. Using Pulse Width Modulation will create RF and interfere with radio reception. They also say they do not have a housing that would eliminate condensation or water on the LED circuits.





That is an excellent question, SOLAR.

The Marinebeam LED array I purchased has the "proprietary current-control technology" to which you refer. At this time, my only experience with the light is the test run I did at the marina last weekend. I will have the opportunity to anchor out in the boonies and away from marina RF sources in a few days.

I'll be able to test the Marinebeam for RF interference against a VHF marine radio transceiver, cell phone, depth sounder, digital TV, broadcast FM radio and AM radio 100 khz through 30 Mhz. I don't have radar, though. I'll report back on the findings.

From "Idiot's Guide: What You Need To Know About Buying LED Cluster Lighting For Your Yacht" available at the Marinebeam website: Marinebeam states their products are CE approved and that "Care must be taken in the design of these switching circuits to avoid any RF or EMI. The introduction of LEDs into the automotive and cell phone sectors has produced robust designs and filtering methods for reducing EMI and RF issues below the strict European Union (CE) thresholds."

I'm not sure exactly sure what that means but Marinebeam seems to be aware of the potential for PWM and RF conflicts and have designed for it. But, I'll give it a test.

Sealing: I haven't looked into this. The Marinebeam LED array bulb replacement I purchased fits into a watertight enclosure. It's sealed by an 0-ring and silicon grease.

The Marinebeam LED bulb I bought is brighter than the living daylights considering it's size. It's amazing.
 
quote:

Originally posted by hackalar

However we never spend the night on anchor. We are on the Tennessee river and am not sure if it's legal to do so? Have never seen anybody stay night on anchor around here.






I'm on the Tennessee at Hales Bar (30 river miles downstream from Chattanooga) and we do a fair amount of anchoring. It's more river than lake down here, so spots are few, but there are a couple that get used.
 
Are the areas marked? Or do you just get out of the main channel?
 
No, areas are not marked. We use a couple of coves downstream of the gorge, or the non channel side of an island upstream of the gorge.
cloudyweekend.jpg


Here we are in the cove. Main channel is all the way to the backside of this pic, at the base of the mountain running left to right (downstream)

dusk1.jpg


Same place, rotated about 90 degrees. Channel is now off to the left running perpendicular to view. Ready to hunker down for the night.
 
Back
Top