Live Aboard/Cruiser?

Rugger8

Member
exMember
Joined
Dec 4, 2006
RO Number
24444
Messages
231
ok everyone, I would like to get everyone's opinion on what boats to consider for a potential liveaboard/long distance cruiser. In terms of timing, I would probably not be buying for 2-3 years and perhaps longer depending on lots of factors. But I would be looking for something that could be piloted solo, but with very good seakeeping capabilities. I currently have a Regal 3560, which is great, but probably not capable or spacious enough for what I am looking for. I would think 45'-55' is probably the right size boat for this type of endeavor. Also, while I would certainly consider slow trawlers, I do appreciate some speed, ie. 20+ knots. Given that I want to go far offshore, to Galapagos and South America, good range is a necessity. So, please give me your opinions on sportfishers, trawlers, motoryachts, etc. that you think might make sense. I want to start looking now at boat shows, so that in 2-3 years I can make a more informed decision on a used 3-5 year old boat at that time. All comments are welcome.

Oh, I almost forgot, also looking for reasonable fuel efficiency.

Thanks,
 
yeah... i don't think a Regal will make it to the galapagos !

if you need range and passage making capability, your choices are fairly limited: nodhawn, selene, etc... older boats will increase your options too.

speed and economy and sea worthiness are hard to combine... pick any 2. if you want all 3... be ready for $$$$$$$$$$

first thing you MUST do if you are really considering long distance cruising is subscribe to Passagemaker Mag.

your budget, both purchase and operating, is the critical element here... if you want long distance, a trawler or LRC is what you need... that will get you almost anywhere... but if you want 20kts, even occasionaly, you will need a big budget, both initial cost and operating.
 
Given the distances you want to travel, even though I'm not a blo-boater, I'm voting for a motor sailer.
 
Rugger8,

No of fence to the throttle jocks but consider something like our boat. She has all the comfort you could ask for, is easy to sail single handed and has unlimited range.

SeaQuestOEBackinthewater.jpg


Anyway just a thought

SeaQuest OE
A Lagoon 570 Catamaran
 
A sportfisher to cruise from Haverstraw, NY to the Galapagos and South America? I'm new to boating, but I've been on 45' sportfishers before. No way they'd have the range for that and no way you'd want to stay on them for that long either. Well, maybe they'd have the range for South America actually because you could stop more along the way. I agree with Pascal, cha ching!
 
Read, read, read. Manyy other people have done this. Many have written of their personal saga. There is an almost endless amount of opinion available.
You will likely settle on 42-ft plus to combine liveaboard plus long distance cruising. Look into sail if you are serious about long distance cruising.
 
oh darn TP... did you have to rub it in with your lagoon !!! :-)

i love that boat... even in smaller versions like the 42, 46, etc... they've really made them practical boats... like flat uncluttered side decks ! i hate those narrow side decks you see on many other cats...
 
ok, thanks. Not sure I am ready for sailing yet, plus, how do you dock that thing? It does look pretty impressive though!

Pascal, I did just start buying Passage Maker, which I think is a great magazine. I have been looking at both the Selenes and Nordhaven's, which both seem pretty nice. My problem with the Selene is that they are typically one engine, which given the distances I will be traveling seems pretty risky.

As for the fuel, I would like the capability to have the speed if needed, but from my understanding if I drive at displacement speed the fuel economy is similar to a pure trawler anyhow, at least based on other posts I have read here.

Should I focus just on the "true" passage makers like Nordhaven and Selene? I would have thought quality boats like Hatteras, Viking, Bertram would be suitable for this as well, assuming I stay near shore and pick my travel days accordingly. Again, I am early in this process, so all ideas are appreciated and please excuse my ignorance if I ask a stupid question.
 
PascalG,

Thank you, here are a few shots of the inside.

SeaQuestOENavStation1.jpg


SeaQuestOEPortBirthlookAft.jpg


SeaquestOEGalley.jpg


All of the photos were taken before we filled our home with "Stuff"

SeaQuest OE
 
the first thing you need to do is set realistic goals and decide on your cruising grounds. many guys think they want to cruise far away places then fall back on more realistic goals.... you don't need an offshore passagemakes for the great loop, the bahamas and even the caribbean. the skills required, and the risks, are also in a differnt league so while we all may have dreams of true long distance cruising to exotic destinations, it doesn't always work out.

the compromises you will face for true passagemaking may not be worth it... do you really want to drive a big truck year round just to tow your boat once a year ? probably not. by compromise i'm mean design : low CG, smaller windows, portuguese bridge, large fuel tanks, redundant system taking space and $, etc. etc. etc.

it's one thing to do the loop, cruise the bahamas... it's another to get down to south america, cross the canal, etc...

so set realistic goals and then decide. if you eliminate the true offshore needs, then jsut about any boat will do, even a sportfish if you want occasional speed and a cockpit.

TP... i really like those lagoons... my girlfriend loves cat and has always dreamed of living aboard a big cat.... we went to the boat show in feb. specifically to look at cats and the lagoons ended up at the top of the list. along with the PDQ, very nice boat/quality too.

one day... for now.. I'm stuck with 7000lbs of steel in the bilge instead of a big stick ! :-)
 
Marlow makes boats that might satisfy most of your wish list. Fairly serious money though.

Nancy
 
You are limited to only one type of boat or perhaps two, if you want the range and don't want to go with a motor sailor. One is the traditional "Trawler", or an ocean going Cat. All of my ocean cruising has been sailboats, motorsailors and trawlers. A good motor sailing boat is the best of the lot. We cruised over 40,000 miles in a 62 foot motorsailor, and over 35,000 miles in a Cal 46--both are older but well built boats, which will sail at 150 to 200 miles a day, or power at 150 to 200 miles a day. Just within the last few days, 3 Nordhavn's crossed the Atlantic. The fuel "mileage" was extremely disappointing--it was from 1.2 to 1.6 miles a gallon. We got 6 miles a gallon on both of the motor sailors--at about the same speed--and boats which were more seaworthy. (Then add in the sails--where we crossed the Atlantic with only 50 galllons of fuel used for the generator, plus maneuvering at each end of the voyage)--same for trips to Hawaii and the S. Pacific.--anywhere you have the tradewinds.

There are very few motor boats which have the range (fuel capacity) to do the long runs)

A friend is currently doing a circumnavigation on a Choy Lee 50-and did a trip to the Gallapagos with no problems from Equidor and then up to Mexico. (He carries 1600 gallons of diesel, and runs at 6 knots) There are relitatively few boats which are true long range cruisers (at least 2500 mile range). Hatteras made a 42, a 48 and a 58. Kadey Krogen made a 42 and 48, with a 44 currently in production. Nordhavn makes a number, Selene makes a number, Marlow is at the upper end size wise.
Choey Lee made a 50/52, a 58 and a 61/66 Long Range Cruiser. Defever has designed a few Long Range Cruisers--but most are marginal on the range that you would need for the Galapagos.

There are a couple of resources you need to tap--the Passagemaker forum, the Trawlers and Trawlering Forum, the Passage making under power forum and Seven Seas Cruising Association (although primarly a sailing organization, lots of good information there). Passagemaker magazine has some good articles, but remember that much behind the gloss is selling products.

There are also a number of skills you will need to master: weather prediction and routing, seamanship and heavy weather boating, diesel mechanics, electrical systems--both high voltage AC and DC systems, watermakers, navigation--not just chart plotting, use of radar, etc.

The other type of motor vessel you might consider is a power cat. There are a very few which have the range, and even they do not have the range to go more than a displacement (or trawler like speed)--of 6 to 8 knots if you want to cross oceans. Whirlwind IV came on its own bottom from New Zealand to the West coast US and around to the East Coast and to the Great Lakes. Malcom Tennant's web site has a goodly amount of information on both power and sailing cats.

I think that you are missing a lot by not wanting to be involved in sailing-- Yes, you have to learn some new skill sets for sailing, but if you truely want to cross oceans or even go to the Caribbean, you will have to learn a lot of skill sets. Passagemaking is far more than pushing a few buttons and casting off.

The other mind set you may want to re-explore is single handing a boat on a passage. Yes, people do it, but there is a significant risk. The risks are primarly of being run down by commercial shipping or fishing vessels. There is also the risk of fatigue and that of not being able to do repairs. There is also the confusion and dillusion which often comes with fatigue and no other people to interact with.
If you have a system on a passagemaking boat, you need to either be able to repair it, or do without it.

I would also re-consider the age of the boat--there are a lot of very good older boats which are very capable of passagemaking. For example the Nordhavn 46 will run in the $440,000 range, and the newer 47 will cost in the million dollar range. If you want to spend considerably less than this the next step down, that I can think of, is one of the Hatteras 48's for $248,000, or a Choey Lee 49/50 for $250,000. On the other hand, a Cal 46 is an excellent older motor sailor, and probably propornately to the number built have the most offshore miles for 80 to 100,000 dollars. There are a number of even smaller pilothouse boats, which will make the voyages safely, but probably not sail as well. Yes, there are sailing cats which are quite capable of ocean passages, but for single handing, I would really suggest against that type of vessel.
 
Diesel Duck. Do a google search for George Buehler. If you can't afford to buy one, build your own.
 
If you want range and comfort, go for a sailboat. Stability is an important factor and you get that with the sails.
 
Hey Jeff, if you haven't already found the Living Aboard forum, that is another great site that gives L/As lots of good info. Good luck to ya!
 
Hey Jeff, if you haven't already found the Living Aboard forum, that is another great site that gives L/As lots of good info. Good luck to ya!
 
thataway4,

I beg to differ our Lagoon 570 single hands very well, of course it was set up that way from the begining and we have added a number of things on order to make SeaQuest OE easier to handle.

Rugger8 unless you have a $hit load of cash a motor sailer, mono hull sailing vessel or Catamaran is the only way to travel the world by sea.

SeaQuest OE
 
I was going to live-aboard.
I shopped for a year or more, and even after I made the decision not to do it, I still kept my eye open for a good opportunity.
If you have not lived aboard, you better do a lot of visiting with the other live-aboarders. Experience their living conditions. Soon you start to see some of the things that would be listed as a Pain in the...!
In the end, after only a few months you will have clutter and loose stuff all over the boat. Its really very difficult to throw good stuff out simply because you dont have room for it, but you have to be like that or your stuff will bury you.

You see Tiger Paws grand and bueatiful boat. His is a poster for the good guys, for sure. But they dont all look like that. I never cared much for that Sailing stuff, but thats the best way to go. Theres a couple guys on this Forum that make the seas their homes. (thats not for me, but they have wisdom and experience that you need)

Dont be in a hurry to make a decision. You have lots of time yet.
 
Back
Top