Loran vs GPS

Brian

Member
Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2000
RO Number
64
Messages
334
I was reading how congress has extended funding one more year for the Loran system. Does anyone here use it and how does it work. With the new GPS system seems to be much more reliable. Is it?? The article talked about terrorists knocking out our Satellites and taking down the GPS system. Is it a case of overreaction or really feasible.
 
very feasible but few people have working loran so it probably doesn’t matter. I wonder if deck officers and pilots are still required to remain proficient in celestial navigation for the same reason???
 
Bruce - for high tonnage tickets with Any Oceans endorsements, celestial nav is still tested. When I tested for my 100 ton with Towing and Near Coastal (up to 200nm beyond the boundary line) endorsements, celnav wasn't tested.

To answer the original question, Loran is still quite useful. A lot of commercial folks, especially fishing vessels, still actively use Loran-C. I personally think it's much easier to plot than Lat and Long - pretty much the same process, only it doesn't use straight lines and uses a different, and simpler, number system.
 
The older Loran units would just give Lat and Long. The newer GPS' give you a map with a pointer (that's your boat).

When I used Loran, I found it had better repeatability when looking for small rocks or crab floats. I did have more problems with
my Loran getting interference. I had to shut off the unit and restart it if I ever saw warning lights flashing.
 
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<wooo hoooooooo My new abchor has arrived!!!
 
Loran uses radio waves sent out form a tower (chains 9960 and 8970 in the Great Lakes). Your loran unit receives these waves as TDs (Time Differences) from the tower. I.e. the time it takes the wave to reach your vessel from a tower. Your unit needs two tower waves to triangulate your position. Loran is VERY accurate and the repeatability is great. It can be effected by weather though. GPS is getting better with accuracy. It amazes me the government degrades the signal but allows businesses to create software and hardware to correct for the degredation. Stick with GPS, it'll get you home safe every time.
 
John, Selective Availability has been shut off for years now. SPS and PPS signals now have equal accracy.
 
The chance of someone knocking out our GPS satelites....extremely small. Those things are up many thousands of miles.
 
I've looked but cannot find a LORAN unit currently being manufactured.

Who is making LORAN?
 
Loran-C (the current system) is defnitely NOT as accurate as modern GPS. I have firsthand experience regarding this (differences in position of almost 10 miles). What Loran is good at is getting you back to the same spot every time (repeatability). Commercial fishermen, in particular, have capitalized on this for finding their gear. Basically, it has an error, but the error is relatively constant and if you can figure it out, you can offset your fixes to be more acurate, but what's the point when GPS is simpler, more reliable and works anywhere. A lot of large vessels these days do not have a Loran reciver or don't regularly use it (my last two ships didn't have it at all), as GPS has pretty much completely taken over.

As for Celestial Navigation, it indeed still is a BIG part of the USCG license exam for deck officers. I'm not sure at what stage it "kicks in" (apparently not at the 100 ton if it's not on Any Oceans), but a 3/M Unlimited definitely requires it (the 3/M license I get also counts as a 100 ton Master). Celestial is really not very difficult (rather, it's time consuming and only accurate up to a point), but really is only necessary for deep-ocean sailing. To become proficient enough to be accurate enough to use it closer in is impractical and unnecessary. If you are within sight of land (either visually or by radar), you should be using terrestrial navigation methods (of course, doing celestial for practice or for fun is different). Most celestial operations carried out on merchant ships are for checking the accuracy of the gyro compass (azimuths, amplitudes etc). Still, it's a lot of fun to learn and it's pretty amazing when you work it all out and then compare it to a GPS fix.

Radioactive,

The only manufacturer I'm aware of that up until recently made a unit, was Furuno (LC90Mk2). It is no longer made.
 
You will probably be able to pickup old stock and used LORAN units for years (until the signals are shut off). I have LORAN now but plan on discarding it the next time the internal battery fails. My hope is by that time there will be hand held unit or mid-sized unit I can use for boat the boat or my car. That way I double my chance of losing it.
 
My son who is a pilot in Alaska has both GPS and Loran on his commercial planes. Of course, they like to have a lot of redundancy up there!
 
quote:

Originally posted by Radioactive

I've looked but cannot find a LORAN unit currently being manufactured.

Who is making LORAN?






RadioBill- Since Furuno stopped making the excellent LC90 MKII, I believe Sitex is the only mfgr to presently have a LORAN (actually the new enhanced e-LORAN) receiver/sensor antenna that couples with several of their GPS control/display units or charing software.

http://www.si-tex.com/html/e-loran.html
 
If terrorists or others were able to knock down our sattelites, the last thing you would be worried about is going boating.
 
The article about the loran was in the latest issue of Boatus magazine. They talked about china testing and being able to knock out a satellite. So as a backup to GPS keep the loran system up and running. Someone mentioned the satellites were "thousands" of miles up. I think at the best a few hundred miles is a better number. Anyone know???? Or is that classified info?? You are right the last thing we will be doing is boating if that happened.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Brian

The article about the loran was in the latest issue of Boatus magazine. They talked about china testing and being able to knock out a satellite. So as a backup to GPS keep the loran system up and running. Someone mentioned the satellites were "thousands" of miles up. I think at the best a few hundred miles is a better number. Anyone know???? Or is that classified info?? You are right the last thing we will be doing is boating if that happened.






In order for a communications satellite to remain over the same spot on earth for it's working lifetime, it has to be many thousands of miles up. I think they call it a geo-syncronous (sp) orbit. Pick a spot on earth and the satellite will always be directly overhead. That is the only way these satellites can work, they have to be stationary over a particular spot on earth.

If you are talking about the space shuttle or the space station, yes, they are only a few hundred miles up. They also circumnavigate the earth in about an hour and a half.

Edit:

I googled and found out that a geo-stationary orbit is approx. 22,000 miles.
 
Actually the GPS constellation is not geosynchronous. At an altitude of about 12550 miles, they orbit the earth every 12 hours. These are not equatorial orbits. There are 24 active satellites, in six different orbital planes.
 
Bill,
I stand corrected. Still, I'm willing to bet my mortgage that 12,000 miles is out of range for terrorists. It would take an established space program to knock out those satellites, not Bin Laden buying rockets on the black market and they would have to knock out more than a few to seriously cripple the system.
 
Back
Top