Marine Mischief

can't imagine going in that river with no sail or power
 
http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=104524 Bill's link quotes USCG Petty Officer Angela Rorison: "Basically, the vessel was not safe to sail. It had no lights, no flares. It was not registered," she said. "Instead of safety violations, this could have turned into a search and rescue."

Safety Zone violations aside, this begs the question : Does a very ungainly 8'x4' peddle boat require lights, registration & flares? PFD yes of course. If the operator is considered the "engine" to consider it as a powerboat, what about rowboats? I suspect the answer to the 1st question is simply yes if they PO the USCG re Homeland Security...
 
That PO doesn't really know what she's talking about. Human-powered vessels do not legally need any of that equipment. If going at night, that's different. There is no law that says you have to have that equipment onboard during daylight. Registration also is not required for a craft like this. Also, from what I could tell from the file photos, they normally wear their life jackets.

I'm afraid that this just boils down to an over-zealous CG team that was afraid of the unknown. They could have easily told the guy "Hey, you're getting too close to the ship. Please stay X-number of yards away" (I don't think these guys would have challenged that) and been done with it. Instead, they're trying to turn this into a political statement of "Hey, look what we thwarted! - A replica of American history."
 
That midshipman doesn't really know what he's talking about, either. Based on news reports, the vessel meets the criteria of such but was not registered as such, carried no Visual Distress Signals, and iolate a Security Zone. If the vessel had no means to keep out of the Security Zone, it's not 'boo-hoo for him', It's shame on him for getting underway a vessel that had no means to control itself, no means to avoid collision, no means to stand out of danger (can't think of a better example of a Manifestly Unsafe Voyage).

33CFR and 46USC. Like the soup says, it's in there....
 
New York State does not require registration for vessels that are manually propelled (doesn't matter if it's oars, pedals, paddles etc).

Vessels under 16 feet in length (this sub has been reported to be 8 feet in length) and manually propelled vessels, are not required to carry daytime visual distress signals in New York State waters and must meet USCG regulations on federally controlled waters. The same exemption from daytime signals is here too.

This guy also had a small inflatable with two people in it, escorting him. He's not moving very fast, chose a relatively traffic-deficient area and had a support boat. Could they have gone somewhere else to ensure safer amounts of traffic? Sure, but I don't think they were criminally negligent in going where they did. Stupid, maybe, but you can't regulate that.

EDIT: Okay, so it appears that they got caught in the current.

Still,

The ONLY thing they can really get them for, is violating the security zone, and IMO, the situation could have easily been taken care of by simply informing the men that they had violated it. If they were argumentative, belligerent, drunk or whatever, fine - arrest them. But, our police state paranoia of the unknown and worries about any little perceivable threat turned this into a way bigger issue than it needed to be - all at the taxpayer's expense.
 
quote:

Police Commissioner Raymond W. Kelly issued a statement later calling the incident “marine mischief” — the “creative craft of three adventuresome individuals” — and saying nothing suspicious had been recovered “other than the vessel itself.” He played down the possibility that the cruise ship could have been endangered had the intent been more malicious than artful, suggesting that the sub had been detected in plenty of time.





Sounds harmless to me.
 
I think the powers that be are paranoid!
remindes me of the story of the boy who cryed wolf!!
woosterken
 
I think there was reasonable cause for concern, considering the vessel in question was knowingly modeled after a much earlier surriptitious bomb-delivering craft and was in semi-close proximity to the QM2. It would seem to be a bit of a stretch to say the young men involved would have been completely unaware of the potential impression their presence there would present and the reaction thereto in spite of lack of harmful intent, so perhaps they received attention they hoped for? Who knows. It was an entertaining news item though, & good for all it did not turn out to be sinister.
 
Back
Top