Me likee

Steel: need to have the hull carefully ultra sounded. Fiberglass, look carefully for blisters. Both are serious boats. The Steel vessel seems to have more range with a single 450 HP Volvo diesel and 4200 imperial gallons (5000 US gallons) vs twin 325 hp cats and 2700 US gallons of fuel. Looking at the two vessels on the specs, the Cheoy Lee seems to get the nod, with twins engines, two gensets, stabilizers, a day head on the main deck, a good helm chair and a flying bridge at less than half the price, The Lowland (well respected boat)--much more fuel and an easy trans Atlantic range, so it would depend on what you want.
 
UT of a steel hull is easy and is carried out every day in commercial shipyards. There are over 80 years of ABS and Lloyds experience with welded steel hulls. Ever wonder why there are no GRP ships? Post Katrina there was a Cheoy Lee 66, not a wide body, she had walk around decks, that was driven aground in Bayou Bernard. When the salvage rig was making the lift, the hull split into three sections. The hull core was rotten. That could happen with a steel hull but it would be much easier to predict. You hit a big rolling sea with a GRP hull and everything shakes, flexes, twist, heaves and then the interior falls apart. You hit a big rolling sea in an all welded steel hull and everthing shakes but you travel on to hit the next one.
 
Back
Top