Montego engine sizes

LuBell

Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2008
RO Number
30482
Messages
65
I'm in the market for a 1990 Montego 3257. What can somebody tell me about the pros and cons of its twin 350s vs. some with 454s. I'm coming from a single 350 in a clean 23' Formula Cruiser (for sale BTW) so either option is going to be a leap. I want to cruise and go relatively fast without going irreparably broke.
 
LuBell,
Our 1988 Carver 3257 had the 454's so I can't say for certain how it would perform with the 350's. Ours jumped on plane relatively quickly, would cruise all day at 24 knots (3200 RPMs), nearly 32 knots at WOT (4400 RPMs) and was relatively fuel efficient (if I recall we were burning an average of about 22 GPH at cruise). As you are looking at a 13,000 lbs vessel (dry weight) with a nearly 13' beam I'd be leary of the smaller engines. They are going to have to work harder to get that boat on plane and keep it there and I doubt you'd save anything in the fuel department. JMHO. Great hull and super solid vessel with incredible room on and below deck. Best of luck. Let us know how you make out.
 
Fuel burn will be lower for the 454s as they won't be running nearly as hard. I burn less fuel at similar speeds with my current boat then my prior. Currently have 454 Crusaders in a 34 Conv vs. 350 crusaders in my old 31 Conv.
 
Thanks Mike and Greg for taking the time to respond. I asked the question because the ad sheet for the boat says twin 350's. When I went to see it, there were actually 454s. From what you guys said, I am quite relieved. By the way, I like it a lot and made an offer, getting ready to have it surveyed.
 
We owned our 1988 3257 Montego for 9 years. You want to go fast but not go broke, this is a contradiction in terms. If you want speed, you need larger engines. Larger engines translate to more fuel. If you own a boat you go broke. That is a given. Also the beam is 12'4" not close to 13'.

Here are some facts on the boat.
Model Montego
Length LWL 32' 3"
Length w Bow Pulpit 33' 9"
Length w Swim Platform 35' 3"
Length Over All 36' 9"
Beam 12' 4"
Draft 33"
Bridge Clearance 9'
Bridge Clearance w Radar Arch 12' 9"
Deadrise Transom 6 degrees
Displacement Dry 12,145
Cabin Head room 6' 5"
Sleeping Capacity 6
Fuel System 192 gls
Water Capacity 65 gls
Hot Water Heater 11 gls
Waste Water 20 gls
Generator Kohler 7.3
Propeller Shafts 1 1/4"
Rudders Bronze
Struts Bronze
Propellers 18 x 21 4 blade Bronze

Cruise speed with 454 inboards with 1.99 ratio Velvet V-drives:
3250-3270rpm. 27-28mph with a burn rate of 28-29gls per hour.
WOT 4200-4400 34-36mph Burn rate 36-38 gls.
I installed the Navman fuel monitoring system and performed tests on our boat.

I would shy away from the 350's They will burn less, cruise speed will be less, and engines will work harder. Stick with the 454's.

We enjoyed our boat and spent many vacation out to Block Island, Montauk, Conn,and the Jersey Shore.

The largest wave we went through with her were 6ft. You felt it in the aft due to the flat bottom, however in a mild chop she runs nice. Also she is a very dry riding boat with a very large front entry, similar to the front entries on the ocean convertible.

Below is a link of our prior to selling her back in Oct of 2007.
http://www.pbase.com/rbutka
 
Bob, Thanks for taking the time to share such details about the Montego. I agree with you about the contradiction which is the reason that I used the words "relatively fast". After realizing that the boat actually had 454s, it will be good to have a bigger boat that can give me almost the same mph enjoyment with efficient gph.
 
LuBell,

Let us know how how everything goes. Just an FYI, if and when you purchase your new boat post some pictures on the Carver forum.

Good Luck with the survey
 
Back
Top