Moving up and need help

bsteven43

Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2007
RO Number
28678
Messages
76
Guys - I've read pages of discussion about people wanting help picking out their next boat and it of course, always boils down to their boating preferences, budget, local waters etc. Currently, we have a 280 Sundancer and like it for the most part, although it has its shortcomings - some of which are related simply to it's size, others to the fact that it's an express cruiser.

We are a family of four with two young children boating on Lake Erie. We like to spend nights on the boat on the weekend and often have 8-10 people on the boat (including us) when we go out. We like to cruise around, anchor and swim. Like to tube as well. Would like a boat seaworthy enough to feel comfortable going the 75 miles or so to the islands of Sandusky or the 50 mile or so to Ontario.

We looked at boats at the Cedar Point boat and for the first time, I walked through mid-sized sedan bridge style boats. I couldn't believe how much room something like a Sea Ray 36 Sedan gives you versus an equivalent size Sundancer. I know, the sedan vs. express debate has been had here before - I've found it in the archives and have read them. I have a couple of specific questions.

1. My 280 Sundancer will basically not travel between 10 and 24 mph. To do so, you're way bow up and burning gas like crazy. Would I expect the planing characterstics of the mid-size sedans to be similar or do they tend to plane out better at lower speeds?

2. Deadrise - mine is 21 degrees but I noticed the mid-sized sedans tend to be in the 17 degree range. Is this to offset the higher center of gravity? Do you lose ride quality in chop because of it? Are sedan's at all prone to tip in rough conditions? Not like we willingly boat in rough conditions but Lake Erie can get snotty at times.

I would love some ideas on what might fit the profile we're looking for. I want to have quality, sportiness, nice lines, a fly bridge that can seat 6-8 comfortably, and affordability in either a sedan bridge or convertible. Would buy something 1-3 years old and would like to stay under $300k.

Thanks for the answers/comments/suggestions. Brad
 
You are on the right track. Define your needs then look for a boat that fits them. To do so you need to look at a lot of boats, hang around on them in the manner you would if you owned them and look for details that work or don’t such as uncomfortable seating, narrow decks, awkward boarding, low overheads in the bunks, cave like or bright, separate cabin areas for privacy, ladders, stairs or not etc. After you define your needs, the brand of the boat becomes less important and you can compare boats across brands, price etc because you understand what you want.

Flatter aft sections result in higher speed for a given HP at the sacrifice of handling in rougher conditions. Forward engines result in smaller wakes and lower planing speed over V drives etc. Again, you have to decide if you are buying an offshore any weather canyon runner, a weekend family boat, or a long distance cruiser. They are not the same boat.

IMO you will be happiest with a boat that fits your needs not some marketing department or the guy at the next dock that thinks he is going to do the great loop with three kids and a two dogs.
 
What Bruce said.

Also: 6-8 people on a flybridge is probably a bit much. You could really get into center of gravity issues with that much weight up there. In general, I think sedans are not going to move as fast as express cruisiers anyway, so you could be cruising a good bit under 24 knots. But in any planing boat, you'll still have the "hump" to get over, a speed range that just doesn't work. Some semi-planing boats will have a more continuous range, but sometimes that means a lower top end.
 
i think you will find a 36 sedan too small. I would for at least 38' for the number of people you say you regularly bring out. I would look seriously at either the meridian 391 or the silverton 38 sport bridge, possibly the regal 3880/4080 though that is the smaller of the 3. We've got a 2005 silverton 38 sport bridge and have 2 small kids and spend many, many nights on the boat anchored out. The silverton has a great family friendly layout and great finish and a very large flybridge. Since you aren't looking for an ocean going vessel, I'd consider looking at the models with full beam salons (such as the meridians, silvertons, or carvers) instead of the sea ray which is going to have a much, much more narrow salon than the others I mentioned. Personally, i think the best bang for the buck would be a slightly used silverton 38 sport bridge. Of course, I am biased as I own one and happen to be selling it for a larger boat. :)
 
Good morning Bruce.. Your looking dapper today .

On question 2. As you know anytime you get higher out of the water the effects of any side to side motion will have a tendency to be amplified. IMHO .. trolling at very slow speed fishing in the right conditions can give you a headache quickly but most other times it’s not a problem at all. As far as safety your seamanship with any boat keeps you out of trouble..

In that price rane you could also add the 411 meridian and 41sb Silverton.... and more

Good luck with your search.

Mark
 
i might look at something along the lines of an aft cabin in the upper 30's. you will find that most cruiser somewhere around 20kts. they will allow you the most sleeping room

also in regard to chop and rough water capabilities, just about anything that you look at would handle better then the the current boat...basically because of weight and size.
 
Regarding your deadrise question. Smaller boats need the sharp deadrise because their length does not allow them to span the wave troughs. Once you get up around 37' feet, a flater aft with a well designed hull will do just fine from a ride quality perspective. The key is to buy a boat that has a very fine entry and at least 17-18 degrees of deadrise aft. A keel helps alot too. This set up provides a stable platform at low speed, little side slip around a dock, better fuel burn figures and less pounding in a head or quartering head sea.
 
quote:

Originally posted by sbw1

Regarding your deadrise question. Smaller boats need the sharp deadrise because their length does not allow them to span the wave troughs. Once you get up around 37' feet, a flater aft with a well designed hull will do just fine from a ride quality perspective. The key is to buy a boat that has a very fine entry and at least 17-18 degrees of deadrise aft. A keel helps alot too. This set up provides a stable platform at low speed, little side slip around a dock, better fuel burn figures and less pounding in a head or quartering head sea.






Thanks for the great info guys ... can you give me a couple of examples that fit the above description? Would the Silverton 38 SB for instance?
 
here are some examples of a 44' with a compound but overall a little flatter aft sections
BottomJob2006-10-18133916.jpg

BottomJob2006-10-18133910.jpg

BottomJob2006-10-18133903.jpg

BottomJob2006-10-18133907.jpg
 
Sounds like a great winter project - deciding which boat to buy! We just went through the same process, and after we went through all of our pro/con lists, a list of absolute-requirements and a list of might-like-to-have features...we ended up having the choice between only 2 make/model of boats. One of the options was from Cruisers Yachts, and the other was from Regal. Keep doing what you are doing and the choices really narrow themselves...at least in my experience.

One thing to keep in the equation is the cost to keep and run the different sizes of boats. We too started with 28' express in a 30' slip. Moved to a 32' express as the kids grew (slip had to grow to 35'). Kids kept growing - now we're in a 40+ foot express in a 45' slip. Lots of extra slip and storage money got added to the budget. 28'er got nearly 2mpg on one I/O engine. 32' got 1.25mpg on twin I/O's. 43'er gets .75mpg on twin big block v-drives. Insurance is a big deal too, especially when you move to the first boat that your carrier thinks is 'big'. A lot of the insurance companies like to see an experienced owner/captain or the zing rate. Maintenance, winterizing and spring fitting out will include twin main engines, transmissions, generator, twin A/C systems, often two heads, sinks, ice makers, way more plumbing, 3 bilge pumps, two shower sumps, 4+ strainers, 4+ seacocks, tank tenders, sending units, props worth $5,000 a set, a lot more bottom paint, 6 stands, huge tabs, fragile and critically important rudders, auto-pilot, extra electronics, inverter, more batteries, enormous amount of fiberglass to keep waxed, expensive ground tackle, more filters, bigger tanks, a grill, more stuff on board, probably a dinghy eventually, davit system, and you like to tube, so another boat is in your future because you can't tow behind a cruiser...

It's worth it though. What a way to spend summers on the great lakes! And oh the places you'll be able to go!
The step to the 32'er was expensive. There's no way to know for sure, but I bet I would have saved $25k if I would have skipped that step.
-Jeff
 
Back
Top