need help figuring out planing problem

allisonmo2

Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2007
RO Number
28462
Messages
37
i didn't know if this was a motor issue per se so i am posting it here also. if this is a no-no lemme know and i will delete whichever post is not needed.

i just put on a 1990 mariner 90hp 3 cyl on my 17' sportcraft center console. i went out to a river in md today and with 3 of us it wouldn't plane. granted we are all big guys but we weighed maby 600-650 lbs and my capacity plate says 880 lbs. i would throttle up and it would run up to 3000-3200 rpms but just wouldn't climb on plane. two of them in the very front of the boat and i was in front of my console steering over the windshield so all the weight we could was forward. my boat weighs about 1100 lbs. my prop is a stainless steel quicksilver with 19" pitch. once i ditched the passengers it planed right out and ran great.
i just see lots of boats my size with 75-90 hp outboards and they can't all run this way.
the bottom of my hull is clean with no buildup at all and no barnacles. i am at my wits end and don't know what to do now. i want to be able to take out my friends but it is a bit embarrasing when a 15' aluminum boat with a 20 hp motor goes by us.

any suggestions?
 
do you have power trim? If not check the angle the motor sits in relation to the transome. For quicker plane the shaft/ prop should tilt slightly toward the boat. for more top speed the motor would trim up(away from boatThere are a few settings that you can run through
 
i do have power tilt/trim and it has no affect. i have tried starting with the motor all the way down and started with the motor trimmed up a ways. neither had any help.

do you think a hydrofoil on the motor would help. i have heard they help with getting on plane nut have no first had experience with them.
i was looking at this but don't want to just throw away money.

http://www.boatbandit.com/stingray-hydrofoil-stabilizer-6703.aspx

do you think a 19" pitch prop is appropriate for my motor/boat combo?
 
That sounds like way to much prop for that combo. No more than a 17" and possibly a 15". What is your RPM when you are by yourself? I think the max recommended for that motor is about 5200, no more than 5300. You should be right at the top of that range running light. But if that is the motor I think it is, do not exceed max recommended. Check your owners manual or get a Merc factory manual and check it out.
 
even with just me on board - 250lbs - and minimal gear mabye another 100 lbs i was only about 4400-4500 if my tach is accurate
 
http://www.deltaprop.com/shopdisplayproducts.asp?id=363&cat=%2A%2ATurbo+One%2C+3+Blade+Stainless+%2840%2D135hp%2C+15+spline+prop+shaft%29%2A%2A i am torn between a 15" or 17"
i do not know enough to make an educated guess so i need advice. i do not care about top end. just getting out of the hole and on plane with some weight on board. i would think 17" won't give me that much of a difference so i should jump down to a 15" but i also don't want to go too far and over rev the motor.

basically my options are a nice stainless prop one time and hope for the correct pitch or i can cheap out with an aluminum one and have a try or two to get it right.
 
If you work with a good prop shop, I'm sure they would let you test a prop to see how it performs. I've done it and they just said it you ding it, you bought it. If it's a good shop, they should be able to size it properly. You can also try the Mercury prop site below. It's pretty good.

http://appcenter.mercurymarine.com/propSelector/home.do
 
what would be the performance difference in switching diameters from 13.25" to 14.5"?
 
when i put in the closest info i have on the merc site it tells me to go to a 14" prop 12-13p
what i have now is approx 13.25 x 19p and with that prop i can plane with me on board and run up to a decent speed. from the 300-400 rpm per inch of pitch i have learned the new prop will increase me 2100-2800 rpm bringing me well over 6000.
unfortunately i do not have a prop shop near me that i can find to try different pitches.
 
It's actually closer to 200 RPM per inch plus that extra diameter will drop the revs a bit so a 14X13 should take you to 5700. Still to high. It really sounds like what you want is a good 15". Then if it over revs a little with a light load you can ease off just a bit and still be able to handle a couple of hefty friends. And over propped like you are will definitely shorten the life of your engine too. And the 300-400 revs is per standard pitch change, generally 2 inches. Go with the 15" and you will probably pick up about 700 or 800 RPM which will be just right.
 
should i stick with the 13.25" diameter and 15" pitch or could i move up to a 14.5" diameter by 15" pitch?
 
A 14.5" prop just may not fit. It may hit the cav plate. I think a 14" will work, but that's about as big as you should go. And you really need to find a way to test it with the prop with some way to return it if not damaged.
 
Another avenue you can try is propgods dot com. They say try before you buy. You may try to talk to them about your issues first. They may just give you some directions with their experience.
 
so i took my boat to a local outboard mechanic and explained everything to him. he seems to think 19p is fine for the boat and my problem is in fuel delivery or spark issue. he claims that even if i have a weak or dead cylinder the motor will still sound okay just not have the power to get up on plane. i don't know who to believe?! he is going to check the plugs and fuel filter screen to make sure it has no buildup or tears. i just don't know how he will be able to diagnose a performance problem like that while it is at his shop and not on the water unless he finds a glaring problem.
he stated it sounds like the motor isn't delivering full power and going to a 14 or 15p prop would be akin to driving your car in 2nd gear to remedy a low power issue. it may still go but all you will do is turn more rpms and get there slower without getting to the issue of why the motor is low on power. all 3 cylinders checked at 134-135 lbs compression and the motor runs fine in neutral in the water and on the hose.
 
Well, a tune-up isn't going to hurt anything except your wallet.... It MIGHT save you the price of a prop but could just as easily cost you MORE than a prop, and you may still need the prop. Does he give you a refund if you still can't get the RPM???

He's right about second gear; but the other side of the same coin is like trying to tow your boat with the car in overdrive.
 
well i've just had a crappy day so far. my mechanic called me and told me the slight tapping i asked about is now a nice solid knocking. apparently my problems are more than prop related. so now i am in the market for a new motor. he pulled the top plug wire off and it still ran, pulled the second off and it still ran, third one off and it died instantly. says most likely a wrist pin or bearing is on its way out. 1500-2000 to re-build a 18 year old motor. nope. gonna part it out and hope for the best with a new used one since i can't afford new.
 
Back
Top