New Batteries

Philyteach

Member
Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2003
RO Number
11439
Messages
704
Morning Folks,
This will be my 4th season on these batteries and I noticed toward the end of last season that they just weren't holding a charge as well as they did when new. I know that they should last longer and part of the problem is that they were left on the boat during winter when I needed some other servicing done. I'm pretty sure the one was fully discharged and froze...or thats my theory about why it holds a charge so poorly anyway.

I will be replacing the "bad" battery very soon, but I need some advice will all the options available now. My boat is a 23' trophy fisher with a big electronics load. I have an E-120 and E-80 multifunction, radar, sonar. 2 marine radios etc. Should I be looking at the good old flooded batteries or would gel or agm batteries serve me better? If I switch to gel or agm will I likely have to buy a new charger? I thought I read that when the gel 1st came out, but I really can't find much written about it now.

And most importantly, does boatfix ship these? I don't see them on the site, but I've learned that the catalog is only the tip of what boatfix really has!
 
My opinion based on my experience, go to COSTCO and get yourself Kirkland Marine flooded batteries. Great price and mine lasted 5 years even leaving them on the boat for the last 3 winters that I had them. Finally changed them when we sold the boat just because we knew we should. AGMs are great for several reasons but (again IMO) cost is not one of the advantages.
 
Even if you are not a member Costco will sell you the batteries-I think for 10% more. Call first and ask if you are not a member.
 
4 to 5 years isnt' that bad but it depends on your charger, if it's not a good 3 stage charger it will boil water out. how often have you been topping them off and how much have you had to add?

Letting a battery discharge to below 50% will also reduce its life expectancy.

If you have big electronic loads, you may want to use deep cycles for these, assuming they are wired separately for the engine.

Price wise, it's hard to beat lead acids and even if they dont' last as long, they're still provide the most AH/$/year
 
To add to what Mike and Pascal said, flooded lead-acid is the way to go, at least according to us and the Interstate Battery distributor I always buy from. He's very much of the opinion that flooded batteries give the most bang for the buck. AGM and Gel batteries are best for special applications (like strange mounting positions, etc.). And I think you're right that chargers for AGM & Gel have to be set for such (newer chargers usually have that option).

And also as Pascal says, 4-5 years is pretty darn good on a boat. If it ain't broke...
 
I agree.............one bad battery will cause the charger to overcharge the good one's.

I had this happen to me over the winter.......I just replaced all 4 with Deka ( flooded ) 27 series dual purpose batteries........should be good for 4-5 more seasons as long as I maintain them.
 
There is tons of information about batteries. The advice given was good. One thing not mentioned is hooking up different or old batteries together. If you have a battery switch and use it to isolate them, then its a non-issue. If not, and the batteries are tied together as one bank the new battery will start performing like the old battery. AGMs are good. They still have to be charged properly to get the expected life out of them. Overcharge them and they go down hill real quick. I would stick to deep cycle wet cell. AGMs are usally used in unusal applications. In a tightly enclosed area where hydrogen may present an issue AGMs are more suited. If they are going to discharged and recharged (properly)on a daily basis, then AGMs may be better. If its 20-30 times a year, I'd go for the cheaper wet cell.
 
There is nothing wrong with discharging a deep cycle lead-acid battery below 50%, or 60% or 70%. The damage comes when you leave them that way for an extended period. If you get a FULL charge within 24-36 hours of the discharge you will not harm the life of the battery. We used to discharge them down to 10-15% on a regular basis - of course they only lasted 7+ years. It's a little more critical on a starting battery and deep discharges shouldn't be done on a regular basis. Again, a prompt FULL (gassing) charge will preclude any serious damage. Do you replace your car battery every time you leave the lights on and have to get a jump start? My stbd. combination deep cycle-starting 8D was installed in March of 1999. The port one was installed in 2001. TLC!! Luck. Dale
 
Thanks guys,
I'm glad to hear that 4-5 years isn't a bad expectation. I'm also glad to hear that I wasn't just being a cheap skate whe I was questioning if the gel and agm batteries were worth the extra money. I don't have a costco membership (not sure if there is even one around here) but I do have both BJ's and Sam's club memberships. I'll check out their battery aisle and see if they have the brand that was recommended. Since there was only one mentioned, is that what all of you are using or are their other brand suggestions?

Oh and thanks for the reminder to replace them both. I had planned on that already especially if they were different chemical types. Might even replace the charger, it was a good 2 bank charger when I bought it 7 years ago, but I'm not sure if it is 3 stage or not and its long since discontinued.

THanks,

PhilyT
 
There is another reason to have AGMs, and that is ease of use for maintenance. In my engine room, its tough to get to the batteries, much less check the level and top them off. Went with AGMs in 2000 and still have the same batteries, optima blue top starters and Concorde (Lifeline)deep cycles for the house bank. Using a three bank, three stage charger from 2000 that uses the same setting for AGMs as wet cells (gels need a different setting). I believe the AGMs charge faster (they can accept a higher charge)than wet cells and can be discharged to a greater degree on a regular basis.
 
The Kirkland brand mentioned is a Costco house brand...not sure who the actual mfg. is. Don't know what or if Sam's and BJ's have an alternative...if they do, it may be from the same mfg.
 
I'm a big fan of AGM's. Sears has a great AGM battery for a very good price. The battery is built by Enersys (same as Odyssey brand), made from 99.9% pure lead, not recycled like many other battery brands.

Many reasons to go with the Sears AGM's.

Price is not higher is you look at the big picture and understand that they will probably last 8+ years.

AGM's will charge and recover faster than any other battery type.

AGM's do not need maintenance, no distilled water fills, no battery acid to worry about.

AGM's do not put off the gases in the amount that lead cells do. If your batteries are located in a tight space with some wiring exposed, there is a corrosion possibility.

AGM's can store for 2 years and hold the charge unlike lead cells that cannot hold the charge that long, sometimes not ever over the winter.

The AGM's I feel would be better since you have such a high load situation, they will recharge quicker when you jump from spot to spot when you are fishing.

The case on the Sears AGM is rugged and will take the pounding that you will give it. The case/sidewalls will not fail like cheaper batteries.

You get what you pay for, AGM's are no exception.
 
The Kirkland batteries are mfr by Johnson Controls.
 
I had a pair of Interstate group 27 batteries and just replaced them with Sears Platinum AGM group 31 batteries. Much more expensive but it was very hard to inspect the old batteries and extremely difficult to refill if needed. Glad I made the change.
 
Fred,

Did you notice the extra power you have when cranking the motor?
 
Wow, now I'm leaning to AGM. Decisions, decisions, whats a boat owner to do (other than throw $ at the problem)?
 
When I bought my Kirklands at Cosco 7 yrs ago, they were made by Delco....at least they were the exact same spec as Delco. Since the Kirkland brand is Cosco specific, I'd look for Delco or at least Delco spec batteries. I'll be checking out Walmart for my replacements to see if they match Delco's spec. I use two Marine 27 Deep Cycle.

There are only three different mfg for all the wet cell batteries on the market, so look for the cheapest brand which meets the spec you like.
 
quote:

Originally posted by MikeeH

The Kirkland batteries are mfr by Johnson Controls.






I do believe Johnson Controls owns Interstate. Interesting.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Philyteach

Wow, now I'm leaning to AGM. Decisions, decisions, whats a boat owner to do (other than throw $ at the problem)?






True, it's your money and your decision. Nothing wrong with any of the battery types mentioned here. If you've got access problems, go with something sealed. But when you spend the extra money on AGMs, make sure your charger will deal with them. You got 4-5 years out of flooded batteries. Personally, if there aren't any access problems, I'd do the math. However, we all like our toys, don't we?
 
Back
Top