New to Boating

CoAMarcus

Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2007
RO Number
27390
Messages
3
Hi guys! I am looking to purchase a boat with one of my friends, which we will use primarily for SCUBA diving and fishing. Because we are both only 20, we have a fairly small budget of $12,000 for the boat. I apologize if this is a very "newbie" question, but I really and honestly have no idea what I should get. I have been researching them for the past week and a half, but almost every source I found contradicts another. Here is a list of stuff we would need:

-Preferably 20' - 25'
-Dive Step
-Bow Rider or Cuddy Cabin
-Bait Box
-Outboard Engine
-Low Maintenance/Repair Costs
-In fairly good shape (Preferably one we can drive right away, but we don't mind a few weekends of work)

I know it is a little bit of a vague list, but a few of the boats we have thought about are the Skipjack 20', a 20' Boston Whaler, and a 20' Bayliner. I do not know if these are good or bad boats, but I would love to know what you guys think.

Also, we will be taking this from San Pedro, CA to Catalina so it will have to be seaworthy for about 25 miles of open water with no more than 4' swells. Thanks a lot! Any input is greatly appreciated!
 
I go back and forth to Catalina. If it's for diving you want alot of deck space and a swim platform with ladder. You can add any smallbait tank at a later time to suit your needs. Skipjack and Boston Whaler are good boat (if you can find them for the price you have). Now let's get real, it is a boat there is no such thing as low maintenance/repair it is a B(reak)O(ut)A(nother)T(housand). Catalina has many boats going back and forth you could follow, but you will want your own Navagation equipment (compass,GDS, Depth Sounder etc.) My first boat was with a "friend" for diving.Get stuff in writing, mine ended up sold by him and I never saw any of the money.
 
I would say a minimum of 22' for the smoother ride. 24' would be better. I'd look for an inboard for access to the stern. (maybe a shamrock)(there are others like PennYan)
 
Yeah, we are looking at several Skipjacks for around $10,000. He and I have known each other for quite a while, but getting something in writing never hurt anybody. We will be taking a maximum of five people including ourselves for diving, so we were thinking that most boats will have enough space for all of our dive stuff.

One thing I like about the Boston Whaler is its reputation, which I have heard quite a bit about. However, it is also pretty expensive, and with our budget we could only get a 13' Whaler it seems.

What about Bayliners? They seem to be pretty good boats, but I know almost nothing about them. My roommate is from Michigan and wakeboards a lot and said that Bayliners are horrible boats, but I don't know if that is just his experience with them or not.

We are going to try to get a boat that comes with as much stuff as possible such as depth sounder, fish finder, VHF transceiver, etc. Haha, I am also pretty sure I know what I am getting myself into in regards to a money pit, I am just looking to minimize it if possible. Thanks for the advice!

EDIT: We are looking for an outboard so we can beach it possibly, and also because they are supposedly cheaper for maintenance. Is this true? It seems that most good boats are inboard, but it seems like a lot more trouble if something goes wrong on it. Thanks again!
 
For fishing and scuba diving in a 20- 25 footer, I would think that you would want a walk-around, in order to give yourself the maximum amount of cockpit space for all your gear.

Something along the lines of this 22’ Whaler;

http://www.whaler.com/Rec/default3.asp?boatid=12

A lot of used boats out there of this type… you should be able to find something for 12 grand.
 
For what you are doing, I would eliminate a bow rider immediately. I would look for a center console. There are a few in your size/budget.

The Boston Whaler guardian is a great choice. However, most of these are sold through the government and require $$$

You might be able to grab a Shamrock 20-22 in that range. Great boat, sips gas, simple straight forward inboard engine

Older Mako with newer power is an option

Finally, and I have never been on one, but I have heard of divers raving about these boats - Panga
 
I'm new to diving but have been boating all my life. I would highly recogmend a pontoon boat.
Lots of room for your gear and you can have 3 ladders down in the water at once.

You cab find these used for under your budget.
Good luck and be safe!

TJ
 
if on a budget, make sure you keep some $ aside for post purchase surprises and maintenance...

if operating budget is tight, consider a gas inboard.. that's as simple as it gets, anyone can work on an automotive based engines. or a sterndrive if beaching is important. Outboards are different and will require a learning curve.

you cant' say.. brand X is bad... or is better than y. it depends on the year and model although overall Boston Whalers are the gold standards in that class of boat. with survey, i'd definitely go for an older whaler vs a more recent bayliner or mako...

forget pontoon boats... unless on a small lake which isn't the case here.

one thing to consider about outboards is that the risks of sinkings are higher due to open transom design when operating off shore. especially with 5 or 6 on board and a lot of gear. an engine failure can easily result in waves/wake coming over the trnasom and swamping the boat. For diving, you want as closed a transom as possible and make sure any water can drain out.
 
Hey, thanks for all of the great replies! However, like most newbies, I have more questions:

1.) You said to go with a gas inboard because of the budget, but isn't an inboard harder to work on than an outboard and therefore cost more for repairs?

2.) For open water, a pontoon boat is pretty much off limits, right? I mean it would be perfect for what we need, but I always thought of pontoon boats for glassy conditions.

3.) What about older boats? I have seen several like this http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/1959...4QQihZ012QQcategoryZ80652QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem on the listing websites, but will this just turn out to be an unholy money pit?

4.) Lastly, what about buying a bare hull used and adding on our own engine and accessories? This way we can get a good hull for fairly cheap, much like this one http://losangeles.craigslist.org/lgb/boa/366584329.html , and we can decide where to go from there.

Again, thank you guys for all of the useful input!
 
An inboard is pretty straight forward to work on and you generally do not have to haul the boat, or better yet, lean over the stern to work on it. If you have basic mechanical skills and can work on a car engine, you can work on a gas IB

Two stroke outboards are easy to work on, but can be a real PITA in the water.

A four stroke outboard can get very tricky - and you need an MIT tech in some cases.

While a bare hull can seem like a good buy, buying and rigging an Outboard is no simple task and may end up costing you in the long run.
 
well, what i like about inboards is that they are automotive based engine and that they're
easier to work on. no special knowledge unlike ouboards.

on the down side, in some cases the engines and some of the components can be hard to reach. But how
easy is it to be working on an outboard while hanging the back of the boat ? not that easy... Take a
a look at the Chris Craft on that link, and see how easy it is to reach the engines. On the other hand, look
at the shamrock link above, the engine is buried and seems hard to work on.

rule nr 1... nothing in boating is black or white... shades of grey !

forget pontoons... they're not boats.

forget wood boats... unless you and your friends are GOOD carpenters. and even then... you'd better be retired !

Now, older fiberglass boats are a VERY good option. In fact, a friend of mine has a 60s vintage Hatteras 34
for sale, which would be ideal if you were not on the other coast and not that far off your budget... Tons of rooom,
a big cockpit, ideal. But.. maintenance cost on a larger older boat are going to be a little higher,
that's why you need to consider not only your purchase budget but your operating budget as well.

When it comes to ouboards, you can indeed buy a used engine less boat and add a used engine. that's possible
but beware of the cost. used outboards can be ridiculously expensive and controls, steering cables, etc... arent' cheap

also, Id be concerned about running that small a boat offshore...

have you looked at yachtworld.com ? you search by price and size range. that can give you an idea of what's out there
and maybe get you to think outside the box... ex.. older fiberglass boats that maybe cosmetically challenged b ut otherwise
sound that you can upgrade over the years

do a search on yacht world for boats bet 8 and 12k, 25 to 35' in california...
 
Hi Guy, The Chris Craft is not the boat your looking for.I know from experence ( 15 yrs. of owning them and maintaining them.) I agree with PascalG about inboards for ease of repairs. Pontoons are out unless you keep your scuba tanks and bouancy vest on,I've seen them have trouble on a choppy Mississippi river where I boat now. A center console Boston Whaler would be a great boat as well as a fiberglass "hat" as PascalG has recommended.Good luck ..I envy you,I used to dive for the USN in Ca. Haven't in way to long!!!....Jerry
 
I spent over 50 years boating S. Calif--a lot of that time at Catalina and a lot of diving. If you are going to stay overnight, consider you need a cuddy cabin. Although it will be calm when you cross the channel early in the AM, it will be quite rough in the afternoon. I used to run a deep V runabout from my home in Huntington Harbor to a 45 footer I kept at the Isthmus. I could go back to the mainland at 45 knots in the early AM. At 5 PM I had to go up inside the breakwater, and cross from Pt. Ferman at about 18 knots--at the best...

Forget any bow rider, or a pontoon boat. The channel can get very rough. Forget any larger, older boat you might have to keep in the water. You will have difficulty finding a slip and it will cost you a bundle. Small boat slips come and go, because it costs more to keep the boat in a slip a year than what the boat is worth. Best to trailer. The Skipjack has a very good reputation and is a well built boat. The Shamrock is a good boat also, but have a pretty flat bottom (look at the aft photo) thus is a harsh ride. But it is a boat to consider. The $2500 boat with the tower is basically a "trihull" which will probably beat you to death--OK for going out to Horseshoe kelp, but not for a loaded trip to Catalina. Although a straight inboard has a lot of advantages, I prefer an outboard in this size boat--easier to trailer, you can take it to the beach, if you want to camp on the Island (and there are a number of camp sites--just anchor the boat off the beach, because of swells and tides).

There are two older skip jacks in the 28 foot range, which are excellent boats and have double bunks, are built like tanks (but twin engines use more fuel) have adequate accomidations two couples including head and shower. One of these has a trailer and they are 8'6" beam so trailerable--assuming you have a good sized truck, or can store near a ramp. Although these are I/O's they are excellent boats. There are also a couple of 25 and 24 foot Skipjacks. There are also a couple of the 24 to 27 foot Whalers, but none near S. Calif. One other I might consider; a bit unconventional, but a favorite of commercial divers is the Radon--there are a couple of 24's close to your price.

Get a good dive ladder, christmas tree/T type. Consider a swim step, and small freshwater shower for when you come out and take the wet suit off. I would like to have a small inflatable, and underwater sounding device for emergencies, even with a 28 foot boat, if you go that way. Anchoring gear will also be key.

So you have to also examine your operations budget for fuel costs (10 to 20 gallons an hour), for potential slip costs ($15 a foot a month) as well as other maintance costs.

Enjoy that world. We scattered my mothers and fathers ashes off ship rock 5 years ago--they also spent their lives around catalina--still a magical place!
 
Marcus-You have been given good advice above. I am assuming you want a boat that can be trailered. I think if you are planning to take 5 20' is a little small. We used to to go to the Island in a 24' Formula cuddy cabin similar to this one http://adcache.boattraderonline.com/6/9/2/85242192.htm
A boat of this style (not recomending a boat that old but formulas are well built) has a lot of things going for it for what you want. Good size cockpit space (we used to dive 4 pretty comfortably), relatively high freeboard for the the channel; decent speed depending on engine; trailerable; the cuddy cabin comes in handy for locked storage and a place for some of the group to sleep onthe way over or back; also nice to have an enclosed space for a head as you guys will be on the boat for long periods of time.

My $.02, The big thing I think is 20' would be very small for 5
 
I also forgot to ad, don't be put off by asking prices. It is a buyers market out there right now and you should be able to get a good deal. I just bought last year a 28' express 1989 in good shape for well under the $12k you have to work with.
 
Back
Top