NHC speak....

PascalG

Moderator
Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2003
RO Number
12212
Messages
12,221
it's always interesting to read the NHC discussion , you often find hints like...

11 am "IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT GUIDANCE FOR DAY 4 AND 5 IS MORE UNCERTAIN TODAY THAN YESTERDAY."

5am : "WITH A SLIGHT NUDGE TO THE RIGHT FROM 12-72 HR. AFTER 72 HR...THE FORECAST IS BECOMING MORE PROBLEMATIC DUE TO UNCERTAINTIES
IN THE EVENTUAL INTERACTION OF DEAN AND THE UPPER-LEVEL LOW FORECAST TO BE OVER THE GULF OF MEXICO. "

11pm : "GIVEN THE UNCERTAINTY IN GLOBAL MODEL FORECASTS AT LONG RANGES HOWEVER...A DIFFERENT EVOLUTION WITH THE UPPER LOW IS NOT OUT OF THE QUESTION"

this, along with a slight nudging to the right of dean's forecast track over the past 3 forecast is raising red flags for the central/western gulf coast... Too early to blame the white house but jsut about time for gas prices to rise :-)
 
Translation: "Beyond 48 hr forecast, we're clueless."

--

Everything that survived Katrina still fits in my vehicle so evac prep is easy. And the new house has more concrete and steel than several former condos; it should stay put for the next one. I've been busy deciding which casino I want to visit for a couple of days...
 
C'mon Bill that cant be true, after all they forecast the number of storms months in advance.
 
sometimes they even admit in their bulletin that their intensity forecast skills are limited...
 
More than once I have evacuated to "where the storm wasn't going to go", only needing to move again because the forecast was a few hundred miles in error. OOps. Note that for Katrina, for various reasons ( including "government planning" ) I ended evacuating Pass Christian, MS ( the eye wall passed over my house ) to Picayune, MS ( The eye passed directly overhead. ) Only advantage: no storm surge in Picayune.

The 48 hr and less is fairly accurate. 72 is useful, but shaky. Even NHC states that more than 72 is as much wishful thinking as it is science. Some storms have well defined paths, some seem to have a mind of their own and D^(*# the physics. ( Not knocking the NHC, they do a fine job predicting a chaotic event. Their rhetoric on the other hand, needs some refinement. )
 
this thread isn't meant to bash NHC, just to mention that you can usually read between the lines and see where the forecast is going to go...

problem is that some locations take 48 to 72 hours to evac... florida keys for instance, or any large metro area. New Orleans needs more like 96 hours considering how incompetent the local leadership is... :-)
 
I have yet to see a hurricane with any type of internet connection nor have I ever seen one with a sat dish to pick up the weather channel, so the hurricane doesn't get the script on where it is supposed to go. Hurricanes were once named soley for women, based on the theory that they can change their minds (direction) at any given time. Today is the 38th anniversary of hurricane Camille, a real Cat 5 storm. In 1969 the best you could get was a grainy satellite photo about every 12 hours, so marine interest from Panama City, FL to Cameron, LA took precautions. Now people expect not to do anything until the storm is predicted to come down their street and even then they wait until the local pols tell them to do something. (To be fair to C.Ray, he did tell folks to leave Saturday afternoon) The prudent people I know left New Orleans early Saturday, prior to Katrina striking on Monday. To expect a land fall prediction accurate to a few degrees of longitude and/or latitude is foolish. Take precautions Early and take precautions Often. I will be loading my extra hurricane lines, chain, fenders and fender boards in the morning with a possible move to my hurricane hole on Sunday or Monday. If I all goes well and the storm goes west as predicted, I will unload the lines and gear with the thankful attitude that good Karma prevailed. The explosion and fire yesterday at Chevron Pascagoula will cause a bump in the cost of gasoline.
 
yeah, they dont' follow the forecast but forecasters are doing a pretty good job with most storms, especially the "classic" mid season, cape verde type systems.

in all fairness, it was easier to evac 20 or 30 years ago than it is now. Our coastlines are now overcrowded, we have large metro areas on the water but more or less the same roads... The stakes are much higher as well... evac the keys "for nothing" twice in a season and the next time around people will stay put.

awareness and prep is critical as always.
 
Back
Top