No life jackets

baull

Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2002
RO Number
7674
Messages
61
Man drowns after canoe capsizes

LEXINGTON COUNTY

A 29-year-old Belvedere man drowned in Lake Murray early Saturday morning after his canoe capsized, said Lt. Robert McCullough, spokesman for the S.C. Department of Natural Resources.

Nicholas Moore and another man were in a canoe between 20 to 50 yards offshore just off Pine Point Drive in Lexington when the boat capsized. The other man swam to shore, and after Moore did not surface, his friends called authorities around 4 a.m., McCullough said.

DNR divers recovered Moore's body at 1:15 p.m. Saturday.

The two men in the canoe were not wearing life jackets.

Authorities have not ruled out alcohol as a possible cause, and the incident is still under investigation, McCullough said.

From staff reports

Once again...
 
Uh-Oh, now we're going to debate--- would the man have survived had he been wearing a PFD? A silly thing to debate.
 
Well we don't know. BUT WE DO KNOW he DIED NOT WEARING ONE.
 
I was wondering how long it would take for you to take the bait ITK!
 
In CA PFDs are required on canoes, kayaks, and such. I'm not sure about paddle boats though.
 
"would the man have survived had he been wearing a PFD? A silly thing to debate."

Yes, it is silly to debate it. Had he been wearing one, he would have survived longer. Perhaps long enough to dog paddle to shore. Or not, in which case he would have been at least easier to find and recover.
 
I know Bill, just trying to see if ITK was awake!
 
I am awake Greg, but Pascal's web cam has more allure than this thread right now.
 
God, I hope so. I keep checking it too. I didn't think he was making any progress. Kept seeing "smoke" on the horizon. I think it's dirt on the camera lens!
 
OK then debate this one...
Is it a requirement in the US that you wear or at least have lifejackets on board your dinghy?
We regularly tow our kids on a ski-bob with our Zodiac (8hp) at low speeds around the bay. The one(s) on the ski-bob always wears a lifejacket. But recently we were stopped by the Water(Fun)Police and advised that those in the dinghy were also required to be wearing a lifejacket (or at least have them in the dinghy) He further explained that this was only a requirement if not using the dinghy for "tender" purposes ie. from boat to boat or boat to beach etc.... Make sense to you all ?
 
quote:

Originally posted by To the Max

OK then debate this one...
Is it a requirement in the US that you wear or at least have lifejackets on board your dinghy?
................






Yes, a dinghy is a boat. Whatever requirements apply to a boat that size apply to a dinghy.
 
I believe CG rules now say any child under thirteen not in an enclosed cabin on a boat less than 26 feet must wear pfd. Adults are at their own risk, I guess.
 
In PA, everyone (regardless of age) boating on U.S. Army Corp of Engineers Pittsburgh District lakes, in boats less than 16 feet in length and on all canoes and kayaks must wear a PFD.

Otherwise, kids 12 and under need a PFD at all times on boats 20' and less in length and all canoes and kayaks.

So, oddly enough, my kids (ages 7 and 10), don't need PFDs on my 20' 6" boat in our little lakes in eastern PA and the Delaware River. That's just not right.

http://www.fish.state.pa.us/boatcrs/pfd/brochure.pdf
 
Either way, you SHOULD at least have one with you in the dingy. Speaking from personal experience, you can feel pretty dumb when you find yourself floating with a compromised boat and realize you forgot one.

As far as the accident, realize that underwater recoveries can be a real chose. Survived or not, it sure is convenient when they at least have the manners to float.
 
Bob, note that the law only covers the absolute minimum. Most laws fall far short of declaring what the recommended level should be. You, as captain of the vessel, are the one who decides what the "law" is on your boat. While Fed, State, Local laws tell what your minimums are, you are free to make ( actually, you are required to make! ) any of these laws more stringent aboard your vessel when conditions make it wise to do so.
 
Ghost is correct. Watching those beach patrol shows, those guys are always writing up the dudes who don't have PFDs on their dingys. Don't have to wear them, just have to have them aboard (except in PA, you gotta have one ON if your dingy in less than 16').
 
quote:

Originally posted by Radioactive

note that the law only covers the absolute minimum. Most laws fall far short of declaring what the recommended level should be. You, as captain of the vessel, are the one who decides what the "law" is on your boat.






Shhhh - do not say that too loud, that implies personal responsibility. Stupid people need stupid laws to protect themselves, from themselves.
 
dancerscap, I believe that CG rule only applies in states that do not have some kind of law of their own regarding children and PFDs.
 
Back
Top