Okay, the verdict is in - at least for me. I now have experience with Buff Magic and Pro Polish. I still needed some ibuprofin after the glorious day long event, but still much less than years past.
I had always used 3M Finesset II, and Colonite Fleet wax, and absolutely thought this was the best way to go. The boat always looked great, and the shine lasted a full season.
Bottom-line using Buff and Pro, easier to work with, and the results are better.
First washed boat, let dry. Apply Buff as directed by hand 3x3 area -I used a foam applicator pad. Then buff out using a fresh wool pad, and a 7" variable speed rotary buffer. The lowest setting was used, about 1K rpm. This seemed easier to do as compared to Finesset II. The shine came right through, and the results did look different - seemed to be more "glassy" in appearance. We only needed to do this once, and the shine was spectacular. Oh yea, the white gel coat seemed to be "whiter" as well - again as compared to Finessett II.
Next the Pro Polish. It went on by hand with the foam applicator pad - a little work here. Needed to let it dry completely - about 1/2 hour in the sun. Once dry, it comes off very easily with a cloth boat towel, again much easier than with the Colonite. This one step saved us lots of time and effort. The shine is spectacular. People walked by and commented at how "wet" it looked. We put two coats of Pro Polish on, and will see how long that lasts over the season.
When I'm done, I throw the wool pads into the washing maching with lots of detergent. The pads come out like new. Took one 200 mg IBU --- years past at least 3 to start.
Cheers!