Opinion for electronics

Claeys44

Member
Joined
Mar 4, 2008
RO Number
29548
Messages
4
We purchased a new (1 year old) boat last year. It is as bare as you can get, it doesn't even have a radio/cd player or speakers at the helm (which we added immediately). I would like to buy some electronics for the boat, but I am finding myself just wanting them for looks. We boat on a river and don't go out for long trips. I don't think we need radar, gps, chartplotters etc.... The resale of the boat will undoubtably be lower, but adding all the equipment would cost triple what I would get out of it correct?? Any opinions on what are must haves??

Thanks.
 
Sarah, in my opinion, you should have a marine VHF and a GPS. Both are considered safety devices, even in a river.

A VHF and a 4ft antenna are relatively inexpensive. It is the "preferred method" of summoning help on the water. Better than a cellphone for many reasons, but notably, because a nearby boat may hear your distress call and come over to help. ( This does not happen when using a cellphone ).

A GPS, even the simplest, cheapest, gives you location in a form that even rural cops can use. This is how you tell the people who are trying to rescue you where you are. It is an important tool. One that charts is nice as a aid to navigation, but, if cost is an issue, charting in not required.

--

A quick note about boats and stereo: One of the top reasons that boats get towed back to the dock is that they ran down the battery from using the stereo. It is a hazard that many are unaware of, but you need to pay attention to it. Consider running the stereo off of a separate battery if you want to anchor out and play music for a while.

Enjoy the boat! Have fun! ( Be safe! )
 
I'm a boat electronics nut so don't listen to most of my posts however Bill is spot on about the VHF radio and GPS. I looked at your profile thats a fairly large boat not to have a depth finder, radar, chartplotter combination. What would you do if you got caught out in the fog?
Bill
 
Basics are Depth finder, VHF(mounted AND handheld) and at the least a handheld GPS.
AM/FM/CD player will get you no help in an emergency.
You can get all of these at a pretty reasonable cost if you get the cheaper brands.
If you don't have a spot light, a hand held rechargable spot light is pretty reasonable also,
as well as a good flashlight.
AND last but not least, have a manual bilge pump or a couple buckets in case you run batteries down.
 
It does have a depth guage, but the basic one which our other boat had a tri-data. We also have a vhf radio with a built in antenna but the cord has a short, so we use the hand held. You know how it is...every boat on our dock has radar, gps, and all the toys & we need to keep up with the Jones's, however, the boat payment alone is stiff. I would love to have radar, because of the safety factors, but I can't justify over $3,000.00 for a setup they we might use on the river....
 
I bought a spankin' new Furuno 16 mile radar for around $1500.
It picks up some 6" PVC no wake markers from ~.25 miles away.
A lot better than my old one.
I installed it myself. For free.
 
"a couple buckets" -- rduhon

Ah, yes, the infamous "de-watering device"

--

An inexpensive depth finder certainly could be useful, and though I have had them aboard most every boat I have been aboard, I have found them to be of little use ( to me ). Generally, the water wher I boat is too shallow for them to be useful ( or too deep for me to need one ), in the first place, and they usually just tell me, "Yup, you are hard aground". I know many other boaters find them much more useful, and you, too, may find this to be true, for your usage.

Chart book: Well, a chart of the area, certainly, but paper charts are not ( ahem, ) electronic.

Compass: A magnetic compass. Imho, a required item aboard all boats, but, again, not "electronic".

Bilge pump(s): Always a good idea, but, again, while electric, not generally considered part of the "electronics suite". And the "human powered" versions are always a good plan.

--

BillyIII and I are both electronics junkies and regretfully, he has better equipped boats than I do <<sigh>>. But both he and I boat in areas where having all of the bells and whistles can become not just a "cool dashboard" but a matter of survival. All of those nifty thinghys are "tools", not just bling. And while not all of them are strictly required, all of them do contribute to the overall higher safety of the all aboard.

But back to the question at hand:

Inshore, in restricted waterways, esp "non-commercial" waterway, such as smaller, non-channelized rivers, a much abbreviated electronics suite will do just fine.

For these circumstances, a marine VHF ( either Handheld, or preferably, fixed mount ), a ( any ) GPS, and perhaps a depthfinder should serve most of your needs.

For "more challenging" situations, a boat so equipped may need to anchor and "wait it out", while a better equipped vessel may be able to continue on their way. What you carry aboard, in addition to the basics ( as far as the electronics suite is concerned ) truly depends on: the boat itself, where and when you boat, how you use the boat, and it depends on the skills of the operator. The tools themselves do NOT do anything useful themselves; it is the skill of the operator that makes these tools useful. ( In fact, a massive electronics suite can, in itself, become a safety issue: they can blind the operator at night, or the operator stays "head down", looking at instruments, when the proper action is "heads up" looking at the real world. Sometimes, the different types of "viewpoint" can confuse an operator. Proper operation is a requirement. )

So, try a "small suite" at first. I recommend these, in order of acquisition:

marine VHF
GPS
Depthfinder ( simple type; not an elaborate "fishfinder". All you -need- is depth )

Then, as your experience and skills ( and budget ) improves, add those tools that are uniquely suites to your particular situation.

As always, be safe, and have fun!
 
Get the VHF radio/antenna fixed or a new one--the range with a fixed 25 watt radio and higher antenna will be better. The hand held GPS to give at least Lat and Long is cheap (no more than $100)--you already have a depth guage (I like a fish finder better, because it gives a bottom profile and bottom condition).

Putting anything more on the boat will not increase the value. Electronics are changing rapidly and "out dated" in a couple of years (not really, but many want the "latest". Save your money for fuel--you'll need it!
 
I agree with Bob.

And I'd add, look around for used equipment. There are great deals out there on slightly use stuff these days.
 
"I would like to buy some electronics for the boat, but I am finding myself just wanting them for looks."

??????? electronics for... looks??

seriously, bare minimum would be...

- a fixed VHF with the antenna as high as possible
- a depth sounder. nothing fancy, just basic depth, the Tri Data is fine but you dont' really need the inacurate speedo/log, water temp, etc...
- a basic GPS unless you really boat on a river where people typically identify locations by name or mileage instead of coordinates.
- if you never boat in restricted vsibility, dont' bother with a radar... if you do boat in fog, rain, dark night, then yes, add a basic radar.

simple electronics dont' add much value to a boat, after all after a few months, they're are used and worth a fraction of their cost so stuffing the boat with gadgets you don't need is plain silly.
 
"finding myself wanting them for looks". I'm biteing my tongue pretty hard!
 
Boated the Ohio River for 15 years, giving GPS Co ordinates to anyone would have resulted in " you're where ?"

Give the river mile, and or proxcimity to islands and other charted points and help would be on the way.

What if the fog dropped in on you ? Get out of the channel,(depth sounder needed) set anchor, use your VHF to see if barge traffic had ceased, and communicate with any vessels that may be near by.
 
Uh, Bobalong, that's why you also carry paper charts ( if you have no chart plotter ): Get the coordinates, look it up on your map, then radio that, "I'm near Thud's favorite Thursday fishin hole". Then they will know where you are... But Osifer Fiendly of the local police won't know that, nor would USCG. In those cases giving proper lon/lat would be the best bet. As stated above, it depends where you are as to which devices are most useful under any given set of circumstances. But in the case you describe, any old, cheap GPS will tell -you- where you are, and that gives you an accurate starting point, so that you might translate as required... ( Of course, the listener should also be able to translate as required, but, I agree, that won't always happen. )

--

Sort of an after thought, but it seems to me, that the more "cool" the equipment appears, the less likely that it will perform well. Usually, the "beauty" is from it's function and ease of use, not it's cabinet.
 
You're getting reat advice so far. I'll only add a small contribution.

I ended up stipping everyting off my boat and replacing it with modern gear. At first I went with piece work, but found technology was jumping forward too quickly for my taste. I ended up selling my first VHF and chartplotter in favor of a better radio with DSC and a network system for the remainder. As the budget allows, you may add electronics to the network until it is complete to your staisfaction.

I've had great luck with Garmin and their new networked gear is backward compatible to the first gen network. All of their stuff is available via Boatfix too!

Good luck in your project. But just like computers, by the time it's unboxed and installed, there's something new in the market.
 
You are absolutely correct, It all depends where you are , what devices work. The local Coast Guard (Ohio River Valley, Louisville Ky Group) approximate miles 600 to 850 or so) regularly gives "notice to mariners", pahn pahn and other information for safety. NEVER do they make reference to GPS coordinates. All reference is always given in the name of the river, or tributary, and the river mile, and possibly which descending bank. Trust me, give GPS coordinates to anyone and you will hear crickets.

As for the local malitia knowing where you are ? Are you kidding me ? Call the Coast Guard and they will call the local sheriff,(nearest Coastie office is hours away) and they will try and find someone via telephone who can explain where the problem is. Then the fire dept tows a flat bottomed boat to the ramp and trys to figure out which way to go, with the help of local boaters. It's a different world here on the river. There is one conservation patrol boat working 50 or so miles of river. Never after dark, seldom on Sundays, and never before Memorial Day or after Labor Day. (The boat is dry docked) Most of the hundreds of miles of river are just banks and trees, great in the spring and fall.

After all, this river runs from Pittsburgh to Cairo Ill, (981 Miles,to Mississippi Riv) but there is only one downstream, and upstream, and kinda difficult to make a wrong turn into a tributary. Charts are primarily used for locating channel markers that may have been wiped out by a barge, knowing how far your destination is, the next lock, the channel location, and where you are if someone needs to to come to your rescue, (OH River Mile) and points of interest.

Radar and a chart plotter would be nice in a fog drop, but we only get those in the early spring and in the winter. Depends on when they intend to boat. Other than that. . . .on this river an open array going round and round on an arch just looks cool, not that it isn't cool to have, but really is unnecessary except in certain circumstances.

Made the trip from Cincinnati to Mobile more than once. Paper chart, depth sounder, VHF, you got all that is necessary. . . . . ok, except for beer and a good first mate.

Also, on Kentucky Lake and Lake Barkley, two HUGE lakes (Tennessee River and Cumberland) which are part of the trek to Mobile, other than transient boats . . . . . you will be hard pressed to find locals with their VHF on. Marina's yes, commercial vessels, yes, locks yes, boaters seldom. Don't ask me why. I can only preach, and leave mine on.

It just is what it is.

When in ROME . . . .
 
Back
Top