Many boats transit offshore, especially sportfishes, it's really a matter of personal preferences (captain and owner).
The ICW has a bad reputation, for the most part unfounded in my opinion. congestion and no wake zones are not a big issue, except in So Florida and bridges are not a big problem if you time them rigth. you can usually adjsut your speed but just a knot to make sure you get at the next bridge on time. I see a lot of guys speeding up only to way 15 minutes... these must be those who complain...
Depth are not a big deal, you can play the tides and get the latest info.
running offshore is fine but on many days it's not a confortable ride. it all depends on the boat conditions and cruise speed but it's usually easier on the boat and crew to run outside.
It also depends on the speed you will be running at and on the price of fuel. On your typical 50 to 70 footer, fuel costs between 10 and 20 knots will be 2 to 2.5 higher... that's a big difference over 1500 miles and that's also a lot more wear and tear on the engines. Even if they will be running more hours at low speed, it is still less wear on the diesels. Dont forget maintenance intervals and longeivity on diesel is often measured in gallons burned, not just hours.
so if you're trying to keep the costs down and will be running slower, there is not point in running outside on most stretches. Plus if you run outside, in some areas (georgia and carolinas) you have to run 10 to 20 extra miles to get in and out of the rivers, sounds and inlets to clear shoals...
it's all a matter of preference and schedule. If i can, i prefer running inside... i'm sure many other guys will disagree.